Bir Tawil

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Bir Tawil, Africa
Latitude: (21.870556, Longitude: 33.737222
Browse Bir Tawil map
Edit map
External links:

Keep Right!

Use this template for your cityWhat do the links do?

Bir Tawil is a territory in Africa at latitude 21° 52′ 14″ North, longitude 33° 44′ 14″ East. It is a small area of desert that technically belongs no country because of a discrepancy between the straight political boundary of 1899 and the irregular administrative boundary of 1902.

This page contains information relating to mapping activity that affects Bir Tawil.

Background

Egypt: You take it.
Sudan: No, you take it.

Egypt asserts the straight boundary, and Sudan asserts the irregular boundary, meaning that both countries claim the nearby Hala'ib Triangle, and no one claims Bir Tawil. On the other hand, if one side were to claim Bir Tawil, they would fear losing claim to the larger Hala'ib triangle.

Relation and presentation

Bir Tawil is defined as relation Osm element relation.svg 3335661. Unlike the site of Titanic, which is well inside international waters, Egypt and Sudan bounds the territory, meaning that Nominatim mistakes Bir Tawil for being part of either if it is just marked as a mere locality.

As a temporary workaround, Amaroussi, who set up the basics for the locality, included a level 2 administrative boundary so that Nominatim returns Bir Tawil without a country. There's a note for that:

"Technically unclaimed by any country, but using ‘locality’ still attaches it to a country, hence the choice of a level 2 ‘boundary’ as a temporary workaround."

Geography

You might be thinking: what's the reality on the ground? It is simple: it is generally just a desert with mountains. As Atlas Obscura puts it:

"Neither nation is interested in Bir Tawil simply because there is nothing there."[1]

However, just because Bir Tawil is desolate does not imply that OpenStreetMap cannot have a try a making at map of Bir Tawil in good faith. We are not sure about the Bing Imagery though: tracks tend to get blown over quickly.

On the plus side, it is probably the most Keep Right error-free territory, apart from the temporary workarounds.

Well, that's great, I'll just build a new city there...

Uh, no. Fake cities are vandalism.

References

  1. http://www.atlasobscura.com/places/bir-tawil-1 (accessed 22 November 2013)