Proposed features/hollow way

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Currently closest way for mapping hollow ways is to use tag cutting=yes in combination with suitable highway=* tag.

hollow_way
Status: Proposed (under way)
Proposed by: saharadesertfox
Tagging: historic=hollow_way
Applies to: way
Definition: Is a path/way which has over time fallen significantly lower than the land on either side. They are created incrementally by erosion, by water and traffic.
Rendered as: tagged together with highway=* but with a border marking the hollow part. Viewable at Only zoom=15 and 16
Drafted on:
Proposed on: 2009-01-20
Vote end: *

This proposal is coordinated by user Kslotte with approval from author.

Summary

Vossbruch hohlweg.jpg

A hollow way or sunken lane is a "road which has over time fallen significantly lower than the land on either side".

This proposal suggests to tag the sunken parts of a way (usually with highway=*) with historic=hollow_way. It applies to both used and unused highways.

An alternative suggested that emerged in the discussion is to expand cutting=* to allow cutting=hollow_way for this kind of way.

Alternative naming is cutting=sunken_lane or historic=sunken_lane.

Currently closest way for mapping is to use tag cutting=yes.

Reasoning

Like alleys with old trees, these forgotten hollow lanes are abandoned, although used for centuries because they are not suitable for modern transportation (hunting and forestry). These cultural assets can become alive with OpenStreetMap.

The earth banks on either side, sometimes topped with hedges and trees, give the impression of a tunnel enclosing the traveller. Because the roadway is restricted by the banks on either side, sunken lanes typically admit the passage of only one vehicle; that is, they are single track roads. Occasional passing places may be provided, but a meeting of vehicles in a sunken lane often requires one party to reverse to a suitable passing place. In central Germany, "dual carriageways" have been observed with two trenches side by side where a trackway was in such heavy use that it had lanes dedicated for each direction.

Up to the present day, some writers have assumed that low banks were deliberately created with shovels as a means to hem in cattle, but there is no evidence for this, and in any case, banking only appears intermittently in certain types of soil. In recent time, they became too narrow and were abondened or got a bypass.

How to Map

ElementWay.png To map hollow_lane tag historic=hollow_way (or alternatively cutting=hollow_way) together with highway=* and add the tag unused=*, depth=*, width=* if appropriate.

Example & Description

Viewable at Only zoom=15 and 16.

Comments

Use Talk:Proposed_features/hollow_way

References

  • Kreutzer, Lee: National Historical Trails: Across Wyoming, US National Park System, 2008
  • Nicke, Herbert: Vergessene Wege, Nümbrecht, Martina Galunder Verlag, 2001
  • Inglis, Harry RG: The Roads Leading to Edinburgh, PSAS, vol. 50, (1915-16), pps 18-49

Kosmos rendering rule suggestion

Highways

Rule Name Targets Selector Template Options Comment
HighwayHollowWay Way historic=hollow_way Polyline (MinZoom=8, Color=#FDBF6F, BorderColor=brown, Width=8:1;10:2;13:4;17:12, BorderWidth=30%) EliminateSeams
HighwayHollowWayText Way historic=hollow_way Text (MinZoom=15, Color=black, TagToUse=name, FontName=Arial, FontStyle=regular, FontSize=15:6;17:9)

Weblinks

Weblinks in German