From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Yet a another bad constructed proposal which is not needed
man_made is bad, it is rather overloaded key now. monument:* subkey will be much better. --Surly 20:25, 4 February 2011 (UTC)
- This proposal is about obelisks, not about monuments. Not all obelisks are monuments. There is also very small ones. Only the obelisks with a size obelisk:size=monumental can IMHO be regarded as monuments, but I leave this open to the mapper. There is no reason not to additionally add historic=monument to an obelisk, I also suggest this in the proposal. -- Dieterdreist 12:19, 9 February 2011 (UTC)
- Small obelisk mey be tagged with historic=memorial. In any case an obelisk is a kind of memorial construction.
- Fine. Why not memorial:type=war, memorial:type=politician? There are infinite ways to order the world and I decided to classify obelisks according to their shape. -- Dieterdreist 19:19, 26 March 2011 (UTC)