User:Hubert87/SemiAutomatedEdit

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Motion for an Automated Edit in Rostock and surrounding.

Reasons

I have used a variation of the "Lübecker Methode" in the past to map cycle ways in and around Rostock. This has worked fine for me so far. However , the current tagging method is creating double reportings for many tags. For example cycleway:bicycle=designated on a highway=road and bicycle=designated on a parallel highway=cycleway. This is visualized by certain renderes like http://www.fahrrad-stadtplan.eu/ and it's IMO not a bug in their coding, but a problem in the data.

Recently I have been working on a [url=https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/sidepath_tagging_scheme]new scheme[/url] for tagging cycle way (and other ways) that is potentially safer for data consumers and mappers but aims mostly on resolving tagging disputes.

In addition, I'd like to change how I store the Information that a way is a sidepath.

Goal

My goal is not to promote my proposal, but to resolve the tagging problem.

Edit

Using JOSM this will be a one time edit with one change sets:

Filter for
highway=primary/primary_link/secondary/secondary_link/tertairy/tertairy_link/unclassified/residential and cycleway:(right/left/both)=sidepath
and prefix all cycleway:(right/left/both):*=* with adjecent:=*
Then replace
adjecent:cycleway:(right/left/both)=sidepath with adjecent:cycleway:(right/left/both)=track

Example
highway=secondary => highway=secondary
cycleway:right=sidepath => adjecent:cycleway:right=track
cycleway:right:bicycle=designated => adjecent:cycleway:right=designated
cycleway:right:segregated=no => adjecent:cycleway:right=no
cycleway:right:oneway=no => adjecent:cycleway:right=no

The same will be done for footway / sidewalk.

Discussions

https://lists.openstreetmap.de/pipermail/meckpomm/2015-November/002420.html
http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=52730

Comments