User:Ulamm/Tables of street layouts

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Roadline only tagging and records with separately drawn cycletracks

  • innovative values are written in purple.
  • oneway:bicycle=* is written in blue.
  • better tagging of cycleway and other cycling direction is written in green
    • A good possibility of tagging the oneway destination of road-tagged cycleways may be the use of the values forward and backward. Bidirectionality can be tagged by using the value twoway.
  • oneway=yes on separately drawn cycletracks is not emphasized, as there oneway:bicyle=yes obviously is nonsense.

Cars and cycling in one direction only

Layout of the road or street
(Straßenaufteilung)
Roadline-only tagging (highway=* omitted)
(Notierung mit Fahrbahntags)
Tagging with separately drawn cycletracks
(Notierung mit separat gezeichneten Radwegen)
1+RWDT
1dCaW rieq1dobBcT.png
oneway=yes
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway
(:right)=yes

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=yes
bicycle=use_sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
1+LWFT
1dCaW leeq1dfrBcT.png
French signs:
"advisory cycleway" & "oneway"
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes

cycleway:left=track
oneway:forward:cycleway(:left)=yes
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:left:track=optional
oneway:forward:cycleway(:left)=yes
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:left:forward:track=optional

drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes
Paris Bd Richard-Lenoir pcyclable.jpg
Bd. Richard Lenoir in Paris

Cars in one direction, cycling in both

Layout of the road or street
(Straßenaufteilung)
Roadline-only tagging (highway=* omitted)
(Notierung mit Fahrbahntags)
Tagging with separately drawn cycletracks
(Notierung mit separat gezeichneten Radwegen)
1+LAT
1dCaW leop1dBcT.png
oneway=yes
cycleway=opposite_track
cycleway=left

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:left:backward=track

drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
oneway=yes


drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes
1+LADL
1dCaW leop1dobBcL.png
oneway=yes
bicycyle:forward=yes
cycleway:left:opposite_lane=obligatory

OR
oneway=yes
bicycyle:forward=yes
cycleway:backward:left=strict_lane
Separately drawn cyclelanes can be useful
for short sections between cycletracks.
1+LAFL
1dCaW leop1dsoBcL.png
oneway=yes
oneway:bicycle=no
cycleway:left:opposite_lane=soft

OR
oneway=yes
bicycyle=twoway
cycleway:backward:left=soft_lane
Separately drawn cyclelanes can be useful
for short sections between cycletracks.
1S+LADT
1dShL leop1dobBcL.png
oneway=yes
bicycyle:forward=shared_lane
cycleway:left:opposite_lane=obligatory

OR
oneway=yes
bicycyle:forward=shared_lane
cycleway:backward:left=strict_lane
Separately drawn cyclelanes can be useful
for short sections between cycletracks.




                                                   Boise, Idaho
BoiseSharrows.jpg
1+L2DT
1dCaW le2dobBcT.png
oneway=yes
cycleway:left=track

oneway:cycleway(:left)=no
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:left:twoway:track=obligatory
drawn backward
or forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=no
drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=yes
bicycle=use_sidepath

1+R2DT
1dCaW ri2dobBcT.png
oneway=yes
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway(:right)=no
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:twoway:track=obligatory
drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=yes
bicycle=use sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=no
1+L2DL
1d2CaL le2dobBcL.png
oneway=yes
bicycyle=use_sidepath*
cycleway:left=lane
oneway:cycleway:no

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:left:lane=obligatory
oneway:cycleway:no

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:left:=strict_lane=twoway
Separately drawn cyclelanes can be useful
for short sections between cycletracks.
1+RWFT+LAT
1dCaW rieq1dfrBcT leop1dBcT.png
oneway=yes
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway:right=yes
cycleway:left=opposite_track

OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=optional
cycleway:left:backward=track
drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
oneway=yes

(obligatory=yes)
drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
1/B2
1dCaW-Bc2d.png
oneway=yes
bicycle:backward=yes

OR
oneway=yes
bicycle=twoway

OR
oneway=yes
oneway:bicycle=no
cycleway:opposite
drawn forward: highway=residential PLUS
oneway=yes
bicycle:backward=yes

OR
oneway=yes
bicycle=twoway

OR
oneway=yes
oneway:bicycle=no
cycleway:opposite

Cars in both directions, cycling only in one

Layout of the road or street
(Straßenaufteilung)
Roadline-only tagging (highway=* omitted)
(Notierung mit Fahrbahntags)
Tagging (with separately drawn cycletracks)
(Notierung (mit separat gezeichneten Radwegen))
2/B12dir-car, bike 1dir.png bicycle:forward=no
bicycle:backward=yes
drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
bicycle:forward=no
bicycle:backward=yes

Cars and cycling in both directions

Layout of the road or street
(Straßenaufteilung)
Roadline-only tagging (highway=* omitted)
(Notierung mit Fahrbahntags)
Tagging with separately drawn cycletracks
(Notierung mit separat gezeichneten Radwegen)
2+1FT
2dCaW 1x1dfrBcT.png
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway:yes
bicycle:both=yes

OR
cycleway:right:track=optional
oneway:cycleway
(:right)=yes
OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=optional

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle=yes
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
2+1DT
2dCaW 1x1dobBcT.png
cycleway:right=track
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath*
bicycle:backward=yes

OR
cycleway:right:track=obligatory
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle:backward=yes
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes


2+1DT+1FT
2dCaW 1x1dobBcT 1x1dfrBcT.png
cycleway:both=track
oneway:cycleway:both=yes
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath*
bicycle:backward=yes

OR
cycleway:both:track
cycleway:right=obligatory
cycleway:left=optional
oneway:cycleway:both=yes
OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory
cycyleway:left:backward:track=optional

drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle:backward=yes
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes

2+1DT+1FL
2dCaW 1dobBcT 1dsoBcL.png
cycleway:forward=track
cycleway:backward=lane
oneway:cycleway:both=yes
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath*
bicycle:backward=yes

OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory
cycleway:left:backward=soft_lane

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle:backward=yes
cycleway:backward=lane
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath

OR
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
cycleway:backward=soft_lane
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes


2+1DT+1DL
2dCaW 1dobBcT 1dobBcL.png
cycleway:forward=track
cycleway:backward=lane
oneway:cycleway:both=yes
bicycle=use_sidepath*

OR
cycleway:right:forward=track
cycleway:left:backward=lane
cycleway:both=obligatory

OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory
cycleway:left:backward=strict_lane

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle:backward=yes
bicycle:forward=use_sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes

2+1DL+EADST
2foMoL 1baMoL ri1foobBcL rr1baobBcFtT.png Elbbrücke Rosslau Radfahrstreifen+Radweg.jpg
bridge across the Elbe in Rosslau
drawn forward:
highway=primary
lanes:forward=2
lanes:backward=1
bicycle=use_sidepath
cycleway:forward=lane
drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
oneway=yes
bicycle=designated
foot=designated
segregated=no

OR
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
foot=shared
Note: Bridge tags
have been omitted.
2+FL+1DL
2dCaW 1dsoBcL 1dobBcL.png
cycleway:both=lane
bicycle:forward=yes
bicycle:backward=use_sidepath*

OR
cycleway:both=lane
cycleway:right=soft
cycleway:left=obligatory
oneway:cycleway:both=yes
OR
cycleway:right:forward=soft_lane
cycleway:left:backward=strict_lane

Separately drawn cyclelanes can be useful
for short sections between cycletracks.
2/SL+FL
2dCaW-1ShL 1x1dsoBcL.png
bicyle:forward=shared_lane
cycleway:left:backward=lane
cycleway
(:backward)=soft
OR
bicyle:forward=shared_lane
cycleway:left:backward=soft_lane
Separately drawn cyclelanes
can be useful for short sections
between cycletracks.
Letňany, Beranových, staré domky.jpg
forward: soft lane / backward: shared lane (near Prague)
2+2x1FT
2dCaW 2x1dfrBcT.png
cycleway:both=track
oneway:cycleway:both=yes
bicycle:both=yes

OR
cycleway:both:track=optional
oneway:cycleway:both=yes

OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=optional
cycleway:left:backward:track=optional

drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle=yes
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
2+FL+2x1FT
2dCaW 1x1dsoBcL 2x1dfrBcT.png
drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes

drawn forward:
highway=tertiary
oneway=no
bicycle=yes
cycleway:right:forward=soft_lane
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes


Dual carriageway

Layout of the road or street (Straßenaufteilung) Roadline-only tagging (highway=secundary omitted)
(Notierung mit Fahrbahntags)
Tagging with separately drawn cycletracks
(Notierung mit separat gezeichneten Radwegen)
2xdCaW 1x2dfrBcT 1x1dfrBcT.png drawn backward:
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
bicycle=yes

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:track=optional
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:forward:track
                                 =
optional

drawn forward:
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
bicycle=yes

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:track=optional
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:twoway:track
                                 =
optional

drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
drawn backward:
highway=secundary
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes
drawn forward:
highway=secundary
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
2xdCaW 1x2dobBcT 1x1dfrBcT.png drawn backward:
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
bicycle=yes

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:track=optional
oneway:cycleway(:right)=yes
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:forward:track
                                 =
optional

drawn forward:
cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway(:right)=no
bicycle=use_sidepath*

OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:track=obligatory
oneway:cycleway(:right)=no
OR
oneway=yes
cycleway:right:twoway:track
                                 =
obligatory

drawn backward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
drawn backward:
highway=secundary
oneway=yes
bicycle=yes
drawn forward:
highway=secundary
oneway=yes
bicycle=use_sidepath
drawn forward:
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes

Bicycles and pedestrians

The shared use or segregation of spaces among these two kinds of traffic is paid little attention in the English articles Map features → Chapter: Paths and Bicycle. The most used kinds of tagging are quite complicated and nevertheless defective. Therefore also the recording of this feature ought to be improved.

Layout of cycletrack and footway
(Rad- und Gehweggestaltung)
Roadline-only tagging (highway=* omitted)
(Notierung als Fahrbahntags)
Tagging on separately drawn cycle- or footway
(Notierung an separat gezeichneten Wegen)
(CaW) 1dobBcT SW.tif & (CaW) 1dobBcT Veg SW.tif & (CaW) Veg 1dobBcT SW.tif

& (CaW) 1dobBcT SWsg.tif & (CaW) 1dobBcTsgSW.tif & (CaW) sg1dobBcT SW.tif

cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway:forward=yes
bicycle:cycleway=designated
foot:cycleway=designated
segregated:cycleway=yes

(Hence, all tagging schemes have forgotten that tags on the roadline without ":cycleway" logically do not describe the cycleway, but the road.)
OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory
sidewalk=right

(The relative positions of cycletrack and sidewalk are missing in both versions)
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
sidewalk=right
(CaW) SW 1dobBcT.tif highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
sidewalk=left

OR
highway=primary or else
sidewalk=right
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
(CaW) 1dfrBcT SW.tif & (CaW) 1dfrBcT Veg SW.tif & (CaW) Veg 1dfrBcT SW.tif cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway:forward=yes
bicycle:cycleway=yes
foot:cycleway=designated
segregated:cycleway=yes

OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=optional
sidewalk=right
highway=cycleway
cycleway=optional
oneway=yes
sidewalk=right
(CaW) 1dshFBcT.tif cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway:forward=yes
bicycle:cycleway=designated
foot:cycleway=designated
segregated:cycleway=no

OR
cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory
foot:cycleway=shared

OR
foot_cycleway:right:forward:track=obligatory
highway=cycleway
oneway=yes
bicycle=designated
foot=designated
segregated=no

OR
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
foot=shared

OR
highway=foot_cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=yes
(CaW) Veg 2dshFBcT.tif cycleway:right=track
oneway:cycleway=no
bicycle:cycleway=designated
foot:cycleway=designated
segregated:cycleway=no

OR
cycleway:right:twoway:track=obligatory
foot:cycleway=shared

OR
foot_cycleway:right:twoway:track=obligatory
highway=cycleway
oneway=no
bicycle=designated
foot=designated
segregated=no

OR
highway=cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=no
foot=shared

OR
highway=foot_cycleway
cycleway=obligatory
oneway=no
(CaW) SW-1dBc.tif sidewalk=right
bicycle:sidewalk=yes
oneway:bicycle:sidewalk:forward=yes
highway=footway
footway=sidewalk
bicycle=yes
oneway=yes

OR
highway=footway
footway=sidewalk
bicycle:forward=yes
ZH - SH-Platz.png
Schaffhauserplatz (and other squares) in Zürich: mainly cycling on
the carriageway, moderate contra-flow cycling permitted on the sidewalk
sidewalk=right
bicycle:sidewalk=yes
oneway:bicycle:sidewalk:backward=yes
drawn backward:
highway=footway
footway=sidewalk
bicycle=yes
oneway=yes

OR
drawn forward:
highway=footway
footway=sidewalk
bicycle:backward=yes

Notes

  • Of course, highway=*-tags are also inevitable, if all is tagged on the roadlines
  • Of course, sidewalks also have to be recorded, on roadline if there is no cycletrack line beside, otherwise preferrably on the cycletrack line.
  • *The application of this tag for roads with cycletracks not separately drawn is disliked by its initiator.
  • The tag cycleway=obligatory (or perhaps bicyle=oblig) is a new suggestion instead of bicyle=desginated, which is equivocal.
  • The tag cycleway=optional (or perhaps bicyle=free) is a new suggestion instead of bicyle=yes, if uesd on cycletracks as a couterpart of "obligatory".
  • On cycleway-lines, instead of cycleway=obligatory vs. =optional, also obligatory=yes vs. =no could be tagged. But highway=cycleway + cycleway=obligatory is more similar to the roadline tag.
  • "(:right)" and "(:left)": If only on one side of a carriageway there is a cycletrack, it seems to be questionable whether it is better or unnecessary to repeat its localisation in the "oneway"-tag.

Bemerkungen:

  • Bei der Notierung allein mit Fahrbahntags ist die Straßenklassifizierung Highway=* hier weggelassen, obwohl sie selbstverständlich immer erforderlich ist.
  • Ebenfalls sind natürlich die Gehwege zu notieren, wo es keine Radweg-Linie an der Fahrbahn, wo es separat gezeichnete Radwege gibt, vorzugsweise an diesen.
  • Das Tag cycleway=obligatory (oder auch bicyle=oblig) ist ein neuer Vorschlag anstelle der Lübecker Verwendung von bicyle=desginated, die wegen paralleler Praktiken anderer Mapper missverständlich ist, und darüber hinaus in Ländern mit speziellen Schildern für Radwege ohne Benutzungspflicht unpassend.
  • Das Tag cycleway=optional (oder auch bicyle=free) ist ein neuer Vorschlag als Gegenpol zu cycleway=obligatory.
  • An separat gezeichneten Radwegen könnte man grundsätzlich statt cycleway=obligatory vs. =optional, auch obligatory=yes vs. =noeintragen, aber highway=cycleway + cycleway=obligatory unterscheidet sich weniger vom Fahrbahnzusatztag.
  • "(:right)" und "(:left)": Wo es nur an einer Fahrbahnseite einen Radweg gibt, ist zu diskutieren, ob es für die Auswertungsprogramme eine Erleichterung ist, bei der näheren Charalterisierung die Seitenangabe zu wiederholen, oder ob man die Wiederholung als überflüssig weglassen soll.

See also

International surveys in