Tag:highway=unclassified: Difference between revisions

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(→‎Urban and rural contexts: tone down narrow; lots of unclassifieds are "regular wide" even if narrower than most tertiaries around)
(Even more comparatives. Expand urban hints. Purge "contradictions" (they weren't, but maybe it was unclear). Use language from Key:highway verbatim. It's about relative importance in the road network, arrive here by exclusion.)
Line 21: Line 21:


__NOTOC__
__NOTOC__
{{InfoBoxStart|titel=Attention}}
This page is in contradiction to [[Key:highway]]. Don't get confused. See [[Talk:Tag:highway=unclassified]]
{{InfoBoxEnd}}


== Description ==
The OSM tag '''highway=unclassified''' is used for minor public roads which have lower importance then tertiary roads and which are not residential streets or agricultural tracks. Unclassified roads are considered usable by motor cars. They are often unpaved in larger, poorer or more rural areas, and are typically paved in denser, richer or more urban areas.


The OSM tag '''highway=unclassified''' is used for minor public roads typically at the lowest level of the interconnecting grid network. Unclassified roads have lower importance in the road network then tertiary roads, and are not residential streets or agricultural tracks. Unclassified roads are considered usable by motor cars.
Do not use this tag for roads where the OSM {{tag|highway}} tag value has not been determined yet. Use {{Tag|highway|road}} for those.

Physically, the roads which should be tagged in OSM as ''highway=unclassified'' can vary greatly between countries, and even between areas in the same country. However, within the same local area, physical comparisons can be made to decide the level of importance: use your local knowledge and judgement! One generality, perhaps, is that "unclassified" roads are often unpaved in larger, poorer or more remote/rural areas, and are typically paved in denser, richer or more central/urban areas.

'''NOTE:''' do not use this tag for roads where the OSM {{tag|highway}} tag value has not been determined yet. Use {{Tag|highway|road}} for those.

== How to tag ==

=== When is ''highway=unclassified'' applicable? ===

In short, when other highway tags are more applicable, use those instead. If a public road is of lesser importance than what's called a {{tag|highway|tertiary}} in your region, and is also not a {{tag|highway|residential}}, a {{tag|highway|service}}, or a {{tag|highway|track}}, then it's probably an unclassified road. The distinction between unclassified and tertiary often causes confusion: in general, consider the road's relative importance in the region's road network and tag appropriately.


=== Urban and rural contexts ===
=== Urban and rural contexts ===


In an urban context, ''unclassified'' roads are likely to have pavements (sidewalks) and be fit for two-way traffic, perhaps in an industrial or commercial district.
In an urban context, ''unclassified'' roads are more likely to have pavements (sidewalks) and be fit for two-way traffic than in rural areas in the same region. They are commonly found in industrial or commercial districts, or linking to residential areas. They may be distinguished from tertiary roads in the same geographical region by:
* Being ''narrower'', perhaps requiring you to drive slower;
* Having a ''lower speed limit'' than the tertiary roads;
* Being the ''most minor'' type of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collector_road distributor road];
* Being [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Side_road side road] linking developments into more major roads;
* ''Lack'' of any visible classification; or,
* ''Lower'' classifications, for countries which classify both and where the official classifications drive OSM tagging.


In a rural context, ''unclassified'' roads can be distinguished from tertiary roads by:
In a rural context, ''unclassified'' roads can be distinguished from tertiary roads in the same geographical region by:
* Being ''narrow'', such that vehicles might even need to slow down to pass in opposite directions;
* Being ''narrower'', such that vehicles might even need to slow down to pass in opposite directions;
* Being ''unpaved'', in less populous or poorer regions;
* Being ''unpaved'', in less populous or poorer regions when the tertiary roads are not;
* Being used ''more for access than for through traffic'' between towns and villages;
* Being used ''more for access than for through traffic'' between towns and villages;
* ''Lack'' of any visible classification; or,
* ''Lack'' of any visible classification; or,
* ''Lower'' classifications, for countries which classify both and where the official classifications drive OSM tagging.
* ''Lower'' classifications, for countries which classify both and where the official classifications drive OSM tagging.


=== Supplementary tags ===
=== Situations where other tags should be used ===

* Residential roads, primarily for access to properties, should be tagged {{Tag|highway|residential}} instead.
* In rural contexts, narrow paved roads with only private access for motorcars (maybe public access for agricultural vehicles, cyclists and pedestrians) should be tagged as {{Tag|highway|service}} and {{Tag|access|private}} (maybe {{tag|access|agricultural}}, {{tag|bicycle|yes}}, {{tag|foot|yes}}).
* NOTE: The 'Unclassified' tag should not be used to tag roads where the OSM road class has not been determined yet. Use {{Tag|highway|road}} instead.
* UK: unsurfaced country roads ("green lanes") should be tagged as {{Tag|highway|track}} if they are unfit for standard motorcar usage but available to 4x4, bikes and foot usage.

=== Determining public/private status when it's unclear ===

If the "public" vs. "private" status is unclear, a road can be considered public for motor cars if any of the following apply:
* The road is the only connection to a village, hamlet or commercial area.
* The road is an officially signposted connection to a residential or commercial area.
* The quality or width of the road is significantly greater than other paved roads (tracks) in the area.
* From experience you know that the road is frequently and legally used as a through route or to reach a (non-farm) workplace or tourist attraction.
* The road has any standard traffic markings or signs (perhaps including city limit signs, depending of how usual they are in your country).

== Supplementary tags ==


Since this tag is used in both urban and rural contexts, and because the assumptions a data consumer may make in both contexts vary, it is helpful to explicitly tag some features of the road.
Since physical characteristics vary between regions, and because the assumptions a data consumer may make in urban and rural contexts vary, it is helpful to explicitly tag some features of the road.


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
Line 66: Line 95:
| Indicates the local context of the road; may be omitted if there's nothing notable to the sides of the road, or less subjectively: if there's a surrounding landuse area and you'd just be reiterating that implicit context.
| Indicates the local context of the road; may be omitted if there's nothing notable to the sides of the road, or less subjectively: if there's a surrounding landuse area and you'd just be reiterating that implicit context.
|}
|}

=== Situations where other tags should be used ===

* Residential roads, primarily for access to properties, should be tagged {{Tag|highway|residential}} instead.
* In rural contexts, narrow paved roads with only private access for motorcars (maybe public access for agricultural vehicles, cyclists and pedestrians) should be tagged as {{Tag|highway|service}} and {{Tag|access|private}} (maybe {{tag|access|agricultural}}, {{tag|bicycle|yes}}, {{tag|foot|yes}}).
* NOTE: The 'Unclassified' tag should not be used to tag roads where the OSM road class has not been determined yet. Use {{Tag|highway|road}} instead.
* UK: unsurfaced country roads ("green lanes") should be tagged as {{Tag|highway|track}} if they are unfit for standard motorcar usage but available to 4x4, bikes and foot usage.

=== Determining public/private status when it's unclear ===

If the "public" vs. "private" status is unclear, a road can be considered public for motor cars if any of the following apply:
* The road is the only connection to a village, hamlet or commercial area.
* The road is an officially signposted connection to a residential or commercial area.
* The quality or width of the road is significantly greater than other paved roads (tracks) in the area.
* From experience you know that the road is frequently and legally used as a through route or to reach a (non-farm) workplace or tourist attraction.
* The road has any standard traffic markings or signs (perhaps including city limit signs, depending of how usual they are in your country).


== International usage ==
== International usage ==

Revision as of 21:37, 18 December 2011

Public-images-osm logo.svg highway = unclassified
Highway unclassified-photo.jpg
Description
Public access road, non-residential. Edit or translate this description.
Rendering in OSM Carto
Rendering-highway unclassified.png
Group: Highways
Used on these elements
should not be used on nodesmay be used on waysmay be used on areasshould not be used on relations
Useful combination
Status: in use


Description

The OSM tag highway=unclassified is used for minor public roads typically at the lowest level of the interconnecting grid network. Unclassified roads have lower importance in the road network then tertiary roads, and are not residential streets or agricultural tracks. Unclassified roads are considered usable by motor cars.

Physically, the roads which should be tagged in OSM as highway=unclassified can vary greatly between countries, and even between areas in the same country. However, within the same local area, physical comparisons can be made to decide the level of importance: use your local knowledge and judgement! One generality, perhaps, is that "unclassified" roads are often unpaved in larger, poorer or more remote/rural areas, and are typically paved in denser, richer or more central/urban areas.

NOTE: do not use this tag for roads where the OSM highway=* tag value has not been determined yet. Use highway=road for those.

How to tag

When is highway=unclassified applicable?

In short, when other highway tags are more applicable, use those instead. If a public road is of lesser importance than what's called a highway=tertiary in your region, and is also not a highway=residential, a highway=service, or a highway=track, then it's probably an unclassified road. The distinction between unclassified and tertiary often causes confusion: in general, consider the road's relative importance in the region's road network and tag appropriately.

Urban and rural contexts

In an urban context, unclassified roads are more likely to have pavements (sidewalks) and be fit for two-way traffic than in rural areas in the same region. They are commonly found in industrial or commercial districts, or linking to residential areas. They may be distinguished from tertiary roads in the same geographical region by:

  • Being narrower, perhaps requiring you to drive slower;
  • Having a lower speed limit than the tertiary roads;
  • Being the most minor type of distributor road;
  • Being side road linking developments into more major roads;
  • Lack of any visible classification; or,
  • Lower classifications, for countries which classify both and where the official classifications drive OSM tagging.

In a rural context, unclassified roads can be distinguished from tertiary roads in the same geographical region by:

  • Being narrower, such that vehicles might even need to slow down to pass in opposite directions;
  • Being unpaved, in less populous or poorer regions when the tertiary roads are not;
  • Being used more for access than for through traffic between towns and villages;
  • Lack of any visible classification; or,
  • Lower classifications, for countries which classify both and where the official classifications drive OSM tagging.

Situations where other tags should be used

  • Residential roads, primarily for access to properties, should be tagged highway=residential instead.
  • In rural contexts, narrow paved roads with only private access for motorcars (maybe public access for agricultural vehicles, cyclists and pedestrians) should be tagged as highway=service and access=private (maybe access=agricultural, bicycle=yes, foot=yes).
  • NOTE: The 'Unclassified' tag should not be used to tag roads where the OSM road class has not been determined yet. Use highway=road instead.
  • UK: unsurfaced country roads ("green lanes") should be tagged as highway=track if they are unfit for standard motorcar usage but available to 4x4, bikes and foot usage.

Determining public/private status when it's unclear

If the "public" vs. "private" status is unclear, a road can be considered public for motor cars if any of the following apply:

  • The road is the only connection to a village, hamlet or commercial area.
  • The road is an officially signposted connection to a residential or commercial area.
  • The quality or width of the road is significantly greater than other paved roads (tracks) in the area.
  • From experience you know that the road is frequently and legally used as a through route or to reach a (non-farm) workplace or tourist attraction.
  • The road has any standard traffic markings or signs (perhaps including city limit signs, depending of how usual they are in your country).

Supplementary tags

Since physical characteristics vary between regions, and because the assumptions a data consumer may make in urban and rural contexts vary, it is helpful to explicitly tag some features of the road.

Tag Meaning
sidewalk=both/right/left/none Used to indicate the presence or absence of a sidewalk, a parallel path for nonvehicular traffic which is called a "pavement" in some countries. Typically absent in rural contexts, common in urban contexts, but it's better to represent sidewalks explicitly.
footway=both/right/left/none This is an older scheme for indicating the presence or absence of sidewalks/pavements/parallel nonvehicular paths.
lit=* Indicates the presence or absence of street lighting. Only likely in urban contexts.
surface=* Explicitly mark the type of road surface.
lanes=* Explicitly record the total number of marked lanes (both directions, minimum 1).
abutters=* Indicates the local context of the road; may be omitted if there's nothing notable to the sides of the road, or less subjectively: if there's a surrounding landuse area and you'd just be reiterating that implicit context.

International usage

This tag is intended for use in all countries, for public roads at the very lowest level of classification or which actually are unclassified, and which are of lesser importance than a tertiary road.

The definition of this tag evolved from a scheme to describe the rather populated British countryside, where most of the public roads are paved because they also carry much non-agricultural traffic. The name derives from the official "U" classification used by UK local councils, but the OSM tag has also been applied to roads which carry other official classifications: the "D" and "C" categories in particular. This has happened because these three official classifications are typically not signposted and so have historically not been available to OSM mappers; nevertheless, the tag is still useful for marking low-importance minor roads.

In primarily rural and often mountainous areas i.e. in Germany the countryside is characterised by many paved tracks of grade1 with primarily agricultural traffic. The following page is a summary of intensive discussions in Germany. It is still a draft but may be helpful: Countryside.