Proposed features/mark vehicles, for which restriction is operating

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Relation:Restriction - mark vehicles, for which restriction is operating (Variant I)
Status: Abandoned (inactive)
Proposed by: Dinamik
Tagging: restriction=*
Applies to: Relation
Definition: sometimes we have a restrictive sign, that doesn't have exceptions, but has a sort of vehicles, for which this sign is operating; in such cases it is more comfortable to mark vehicles, for which sign is operating, not exceptions from restrictions
Drafted on: 2011-07-05
Relation:Restriction - mark vehicles, for which restriction is operating (Variant II)
Status: Abandoned (inactive)
Proposed by: Dinamik
Tagging: restriction:hgv, restriction:caravan, restriction:motorcar, restriction:bus, restriction:agrucultural, restriction:bicycle, restriction:hazmat=*
Applies to: Relation
Definition: sometimes we have a restrictive sign, that doesn't have exceptions, but has a sort of vehicles, for which this sign is operating; in such cases it is more comfortable to mark vehicles, for which sign is operating, not exceptions from restrictions
Drafted on: 2011-07-08

Description

Sometimes we have a restrictive sign, that doesn't have exceptions, but has a sort of vehicles, for which this sign is operating. It doesn't mean, that we have a part of road, which is prohibited for using: perhaps, we have a crossing with restriction for some actions for some vehicles. In such cases it is more comfortable to mark vehicles, for which sign is operating, not exceptions from restrictions.

Originally, tag for= was suggested, but remark was made, that in such case software, that doesn't know, how to work with new tag, will be thinking, that there is a restriction for all vehicles. If we use type=restriction:hgv, type=restriction:caravan, type=restriction:motorcar, type=restriction:bus, type=restriction:agricultural, type=restriction:motorcycle, type=restriction:bicycle, type=restriction:hazmat software, that doesn't know, how to work with new tag, will be thinking, that there is no any restriction for all vehicles.

When commenting, please, mark: a) do you support and idea of marking vehicles, for which restriction is operating? b) do you support Variant I (type=restriction:hgv, type=restriction:caravan, type=restriction:motorcar, type=restriction:bus, type=restriction:agricultural, type=restriction:motorcycle, type=restriction:bicycle, type=restriction:hazmat)? c) do you support Variant II (restriction:hvg=, restriction:caravan=, restriction:motorcar=, restriction:bus=, restriction:agricultural=, restriction:motorcycle=, restriction:bicycle=, restriction:hazmat=)?

Examples

Example 1:
3.19 Russian road sign.png
8.4.1 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:hgv
restriction=no_u_turn

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:hgv=no_u_turn

Example 2:
4.1.1 (Road sign).png
8.4.2 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:caravan
restriction=only_straight_on

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:caravan=only_straight_on

Example 3:
4.1.2 (Road sign).png
8.4.3 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:motorcar
restriction=only_right_turn

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:motorcar=only_right_turn

Example 4:
4.1.5 (Road sign).png
8.4.4 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:bus
restriction=no_right_turn

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:bus=no_right_turn

Example 5:
4.1.6 (Road sign).png
8.4.5 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:agricultural
restriction=no_straight_on

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:agricultural=no_straght_on

Example 6:
4.1.3 (Road sign).png
8.4.6 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:motorcycle=
restriction=only_left_turn

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:motorcycle=only_left_turn

Example 7:
3.18.2 Russian road sign.png
8.4.7 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:bicycle
restriction=no_left_turn

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:bicycle=no_left_turn

Example 8:
3.18.1 Russian road sign.png
8.4.8 (Road sign).png

Variant I:

type=restriction:hazmat
restriction=no_right_turn

Variant II:

type=restriction
restriction:hazmat=no_right_turn

Voting (is not active)

Questions:
1) How do you think, can we have possibility to mark in restrictions not only exceptions from this restrictions, but types of vehicles, for which restriction is operating?
2a) Do you think, that Variant I (with using type=restriction:<type of vehicel>=) is acceptable?
2b) Do you think, that Variant II (with usung restriction:<type of vehicle>=) is acceptable?
2c) If you think, that we can have possibility to mark in restrictions not only exceptions from this restrictions, but types of vehicles, for which restriction is operating, but don't consider Variants I, II, III and IV acceptable, what realization do you suppose?