WikiProject Palestine/ImportReports

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Jumpstart NGO has helped Palestinian students to map their territory and has given a public license to their work.

So far, their work were published on a dedicated server

Import West Bank was achieved on July 2, and the one about Gaza on September 21 and 22

http://www.openstreetmap.org/user/JumpStart_International/edits

We find ourselves facing some problems,

1. The green line (border internationally recognized) on both versions (on the dedicated server and after the import) has nodes and no way.

http://www.openstreetmap.org/edit?lat=31.5319&lon=34.966&zoom=14

It should be recreated so that it replaces the current, much more approximate.

Done --Esperanza 10:02, 2 October 2009 (UTC)

2. Some administrative boundaries (governorates) have their nodes duplicated.

http://www.openstreetmap.org/edit?lat=31.86123&lon=35.22062&zoom=15

The same problem arises on Gaza after the import:

http://www.openstreetmap.org/edit?lat=31.33515&lon=34.24295&zoom=16

3. A final concern arises over an area located in the south of Bethlehem when the import of ways has not proceeded.

http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=31.6825&lon=35.1903&zoom=14

here also, north Nablus :

http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.2449&lon=35.3262&zoom=14&layers=B000FTF


Jump Start Error, Ways with no Tags

From: Tal Kat

Here's another report I created. Below is a list of ways that have no tags at all. I would suggest that at first run, all non-closed-loops should be tagged as highway=road. So they are at least visible for future mappers.

All closed loops (I'm not sure such exist in this report) needs to be looked at in more details. They could be parking lots, buildings, forests, etc.

talkat. 37147456 37147466 37147650 37148903 37149283 37149949 37149967 37150290 37150560 37150952 37150953 37153498 37153547 37153614 37153620 37153701 37153722 37153944 37153998 37154001 37154507 37155032 37155827 37155972 37156024 37156039 37156179 37156426 37156704 37156957 37157176 37157395 37157771 37157808 37157852 37157876 37157877 37157897 37157908 37157928 37158030 37158510 37158637 37158647 37158761 37158826 37159021 37159079 37159167 37159235 37159496 37159568 37159692 37159839 37159879 37159992 37159994 37160093 37160239 37160303 37160358 37160467 37161166 37161393 37161458 37161558 37161580 37161632 37161797 37161882 37162086 37162087 37162196 37162270 37162405 37162537 37162543 37163025 37163473 37163503 37163999 37165065 37166099 37166178 37166301 37166408 37166432 37166955 37166980 37167102 37167441 37168171 37168580 37168680 37168693 37169019 37169233 37169359 37169653 37169681 37171448 37171763 37171782 37171783 37172416 37172454 37172556 37172628 37172640 37172820 37172866 37172905 37172950 37173123 37173198 37173256 37173394 37173435 37173526 37173565 37173632 37173803

Duplicate named Nodes

Hi,

Below is a list of duplicate named nodes that I got as output from Mkgmap

Hopefully, I'll send you later today some more error reports if I'll have the time to run them.

talkat.


Warn node (32.062023|35.178013) id=432353913 name=Khirbet Qeis / node (32.062023|35.178013) id=432359756 name=null Warn node (32.331356|35.110634) id=432400561 name=null / node (32.331356|35.110634) (town) id=332961821 name=????? Warn node (31.858793|35.257626) id=432266090 name=null / node (31.858793|35.257626) id=432294655 name=Al Ansar Mosque Warn node (31.856945|35.26321) id=432260830 name=null / node (31.856945|35.26321) id=432262168 name=Al Atqya' Mosque Warn node (32.350994|35.351776) id=431708604 name=Bilal Ibn Rabah / node (32.350994|35.351776) id=431708768 name=Akkaba New Shop Warn node (32.426666|35.363014) id=431710987 name=null / node (32.426666|35.363014) id=432544813 name=Al Shaheed Yasser Arafat Mosque Warn node (32.426666|35.363014) id=431711218 name=null / node (32.426666|35.363014) id=432544813 name=Al Shaheed Yasser Arafat Mosque Warn node (32.42495|35.3633) id=431711794 name=null / node (32.42495|35.3633)id=432544811 name=Al Majd Supermarket Warn node (32.322445|35.368053) id=431695102 name=null / node (32.322445|35.368053) id=431708703 name=Mini-Market Warn node (32.455498|35.26198) id=431735543 name=null / node (32.455498|35.26198) id=432545015 name=Omar Bin Al Khatab Mosque Warn node (32.4117|35.274837) id=431741942 name=null / node (32.4117|35.274837) id=431717763 name=Police Center Warn node (32.420357|35.407272) id=431741206 name=null / node (32.420357|35.407272) id=432544802 name=Al Mutilla School For Boys & Girles Warn node (32.421154|35.384907) id=431739106 name=null / node (32.421154|35.384907) id=432544266 name=Al Mughayyir Ben Sho'aib Mosque Warn node (32.421154|35.384907) id=431740548 name=null / node (32.421154|35.384907) id=432544266 name=Al Mughayyir Ben Sho'aib Mosque Warn node (32.420357|35.407272) id=431740784 name=null / node (32.420357|35.407272) id=432544802 name=Al Mutilla School For Boys & Girles Warn node (32.421154|35.384907) id=431747122 name=null / node (32.421154|35.384907) id=432544266 name=Al Mughayyir Ben Sho'aib Mosque Warn node (32.387474|35.29154) id=431748723 name=Meslia Fuel Station / node (32.387474|35.29154) id=431737641 name=null Warn node (32.501255|35.169727) id=431729004 name=null / node (32.501255|35.169727) id=431715414 name=Bilal Ben Rabah Mosque Warn node (32.387104|35.324375) id=431729106 name=null / node (32.387104|35.324375) id=432545064 name=Jawarjious Church Warn node (32.42495|35.3633) id=431732963 name=null / node (32.42495|35.3633)id=432544811 name=Al Majd Supermarket Warn node (32.334217|35.303066) id=431819515 name=null / node (32.334217|35.303066) id=431828768 name=Almojahed Minimarket Warn node (32.329853|35.291847) id=431818982 name=null / node (32.329853|35.291847) id=431727923 name=Siris School For Girls Warn node (32.331173|35.29201) id=431819079 name=null / node (32.331173|35.29201) id=431746393 name=Siris School For Boys Warn node (31.583723|35.144253) id=431855627 name=null / node (31.583723|35.144253) id=432161163 name=Se'er Police Warn node (32.49735|35.319836) id=431757265 name=null / node (32.49735|35.319836) id=432544965 name=Arraneh School For Girls Warn node (32.38409|35.324123) id=431753548 name=null / node (32.38409|35.324123) id=432545055 name=Alzababda High School For Girls Warn node (32.387104|35.324375) id=431753540 name=null / node (32.387104|35.324375) id=432545064 name=Jawarjious Church Warn node (32.470207|35.35819) id=431753097 name=Beit Qad High School / node (32.470207|35.35819) id=431712968 name=null Warn node (32.385258|35.324844) id=431753029 name=null / node (32.385258|35.324844) id=432545068 name=Alzababda Pharmacy Warn node (32.420357|35.407272) id=431780268 name=null / node (32.420357|35.407272) id=432544802 name=Al Mutilla School For Boys & Girles Warn node (32.50469|35.166367) id=431792685 name='Anin Elementary School For Boys / node (32.50469|35.166367) id=431728930 name=null Warn node (32.330166|35.291824) id=431784132 name=Siris High School For Boys /node (32.330166|35.291824) id=431818989 name=null Warn node (32.329647|35.291874) id=431784767 name=Siris Taxi Office / node (32.329647|35.291874) id=431819058 name=null Warn node (32.459686|35.414642) id=431785585 name=Jalbun Mosque / node (32.459686|35.414642) id=431732504 name=null Warn node (32.385258|35.324844) id=431815976 name=null / node (32.385258|35.324844) id=432545068 name=Alzababda Pharmacy Warn node (32.38409|35.324123) id=431805278 name=null / node (32.38409|35.324123) id=432545055 name=Alzababda High School For Girls Warn node (32.501255|35.169727) id=431801133 name=null / node (32.501255|35.169727) id=431715414 name=Bilal Ben Rabah Mosque Warn node (32.27664|35.19816) id=431918673 name=null / node (32.27664|35.19816) id=432167990 name=Al Badawi

UnitedMaps Report

United Maps has prepared a conflated data set and report, which may be useful for cleaning up the West Bank data further.

http://brainoff.com/osm/palestine/091015_UM_Conflation_Westbank.pdf http://brainoff.com/osm/palestine/UM_Conflation_091015.zip