WikiProject Malaysia/Data Sources
This page is, more or less, the elaboration from what has been told in the data source section on the main WikiProject page and also from the other articles in this Wiki. Furthermore, the details about satellite coverage over Malaysia (with some related tools) and other potential data source will also be discussed.
Again, adding things into OpenStreetMap should be coming from your knowledge, be it through daily commute to work (or school), balik kampung journeys or during leisure holidays, outdoor activities e.g. cycling or running, and might be from mapping parties. Read more about tagging sources.
Permitted tracing layer
These are the satellite imageries which is available as a tracing layer:
- Bing imagery
- This shows current coverage area with excellent high resolution, full colour satellite (up to level 19) imagery offered by Microsoft's Bing.
- Another useful tool, the Bing Coverage Analyzer can be used to know the age of a certain area of a satellite imagery. It can also show the coverage areas.
- In short, a few spots have somewhat recent imageries (e.g. from 2013, at high zoom levels). Klang Valley have high zoom level imageries, but they are from 2011 or 2012. Half of the Penang island has imageries from 2008 (the rest of Penang has the ones captured in October 2013).
- To be honest, some key places do not even have high zoom level imageries, so it is quite hit-and-miss.
- It is not recommended to blindly trace things from an outdated satellite imagery layer. The best way to deal with this is to go mapping outside!
- As a good practice, please include the source=Bing tag.
- Digital Globe satellite imagery (via Mapbox)
- There will be some places with a more recent full colour imagery. For some, it might be the same with Bing's. For most of the places, it's greyscale imagery up to zoom level 17 only (believed to be from around 2011). The rest might not have a decent ones at all. At least one may send a request for a fresh imagery at a certain area.
- Can be a relief for most of the places without Bing imagery coverage. Well, half a loaf is better than none.
- For Greater Klang Valley, Ipoh, Kuching and Kota Kinabalu mappers, please use Mapbox satellite - it more recent imagery is available.
- Johor Bahru mappers can also benefit from Mapbox satellite as well. There's colour imageries up to zoom level 18 (from 2012).
- source=Mapbox or source=digitalglobe tags can be put up.
- OpenAerialMap (OAM)
- Imagico.de's Bakun Reservoir imagery
- Landsat 8 from 2011. Ask help if you have problems to load custom TMS imagery.
Supplementary data that can be really useful for tracing is:
These can be used to align the provided aerial imagery. Things on the imagery may be displaced away from the their own real position.
Strava heat maps and Slide tool
Public domain database or out-of-copyright maps can be a possible source, such as:
- Perry-Castañeda Library Map Collection
- Pre-independence maps. Out-of-date, but quite useful for rivers and peaks. Malaya AMS Topographic Maps
- GEOnet Names Server
- A database of names of places and geographical features from the U.S. National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency and U.S. Board on Geographic Names. A member of Mapbox Data Team wrote a guideline on how to use this, so please read his diary first. Get some help from experienced users on how to make use this database in the iD Editor, for example. But please, please, please DO NOT make a blind import. Consider some common sense because e.g. some place names are really misplaced from where they are in reality or are incorrectly spelled.
Possible data source?
Let the community know (in the forums). Otherwise, send an e-mail to the Licensing Working Group to know whether a certain data source can be added into OpenStreetMap.
Warning: these are meant as planning tools (i.e. to do future surveys in a place without a decent satellite imagery) - this not an excuse to copy stuff from Google and/or other map providers.
- Map Compare from Geofabrik
- OSM vs. Google map compare from OSM-tools.org may be used to look for places with missing major roads
Don't use these!
Do not freely copy things from these:
- Google Maps, Google Earth and Google Street View (obviously!)
- Geodata from Wikipedia
- Anything that says "copyright reserved" and requires permission
The OpenStreetMap community would love to avoid any copyright violations. This should be a kind reminder why OpenStreetMap contributors may not freely copy things from copyrighted maps. The maps are free as in someone's buying you food for lunch, but not as free as in freedom. Also, this piece of opinion further describes the reasons why we should not simply copy things.
But, in terms of planning to do a survey, feel free to use them – remember, no copying stuff afterwards!
Malaysia Government's Open Data Portal
The terms and conditions mention that every third party app must provide a specific attribution – see section 3. In short, license incompatibility - this was the result of some discussion on the Legal Mailing List. But, again, the datasets can be used as a list of things to be surveyed. Mapping party, anyone?
- OpenStreetMap Help
- Waze Terms of Service, under the Use Restrictions segment
- personal use only, not compatible with OpenStreetMap's license
- strictly non-commercial, thus, license incompatibility
- [OSM-legal-talk] Use of data from the Malaysian government Open Data portal