|This article is a stub. You can help OpenStreetMap by expanding it.|
|This article or section may contain out-of-date information. The information is no longer correct, or no longer has relevance.
If you know about the current state of affairs, please help keep everyone informed by updating this information. (Discussion)
This is the page of the Penang Editing Guide, as well as a discussion page for editing maps of Penang on OSM.
Firstly, please go to your OpenStreetMap.com account setting page, scroll to the end and click on the link to make all your edits public. This will make other you visible and accessible to other people, so we can better coordinate the effort to map Penang roads.
Secondly, please read the Editing Standards and Conventions page. Specifically, motorways (called highways in Penang and Malaysia) must be laid down as two ways for each highway: one for each direction. In addition, there must be two paired notes parallel to each other. If any important road (such as trunk or primary) is divided in the middle, and there are more than two lanes for each direction, then use the same convention as motorways for placing nodes.
Only lay down nodes, segments and ultimately ways for places and roads where GPS data is available.
If you have no idea on the method of mapping particular streets, or some special cases, it's best to download an area where mapping has been done and refer to the convention. You could also contact one of the people who has mapped the area and ask them for help.
Proposed Penang Road Classification
|Colour||Malay||English||Proposed OSM highway tag|
|Red||Jalan Persekutuan||Federal Road||trunk|
|Blue||Jalan Utama Negeri||Primary State Road||primary|
|Indigo||Jalan Sekunder||Secondary Road||secondary|
|Purple||Jalan Perbandaran||Municipal Road||tertiary|
|Black||Jalan Tempatan||District Road||tertiary or residential|
There might be some overlaps between which highway tag to use for particular road. For example, Jalan Masjid Negeri could be seen as a very important, trunk or primary road to road users. PeGIS classify it as Jalan Perbandaran, which is a tertiary road. However, the highway tag is for the relative importance, not for administrative purposes (from the mailing list). We will have to look into that.
I propose that unclassified tag should only be used for non-tarred roads or tracks (such as agriculture use tracks).
In addition to that, please have a look at Malaysian Roads Tagging for more information and reference.
Wikipedia also has a good article on the translation between English street classification and Malay ones.
The following offset has been used for Bing imagery of Penang Island on JOSM: 10.43; 2.13
To Do List:
1. Write better Wiki and Guides for absolute newbies
2. Coordinate our effort, Edit this wiki
3. Get more GPS tracklog for Penang roads
4. Upload coastline data
More people knowing and contributing to this project would be great. However, I think we need to coordinate our effort first before getting more people to edit.