Finland:Joukkoliikenne/HSL/train

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This is a comparison of OSM public transit route data with HSL train transit data (via digitransit.fi) generated by a script.

Summary of train transit in HSL region.

15 lines in OSM.

13 lines in HSL.

4 lines in OSM but not in HSL:

N (1, 2), Москва - Хельсинки (1), Хельсинки - Москва (1), Хельсинки - Санкт-Петербург (1)

2 lines in HSL but not in OSM:

X, Z

0 lines without a 'ref' tag:

Old lines

1 routes with type 'was:route=train'.

X (1, 2)

0 routes with type 'disused:route=train'.

HSL train lines in OSM

This table compares HSL train routes with OSM routes. The checker uses Refined public transport schema as a reference.

Direction 0 Direction 1
Route Master Match OSM HSL Tags Shape Platf. OSM HSL Tags Shape Platf.
A 7440364 Uniq. 357190 HSL:3002A:0:01 OK 92% +7 -4 7440363 HSL:3002A:1:01 OK gaps +7 -4
D 7433393 Uniq. 358112 HSL:3001D:0:01 OK 97% +7 -7 7433392 HSL:3001D:1:01 OK 100% +7 -7
E 7442189 Uniq. 357220 HSL:3002E:0:02 OK 98% +4 -4 7442188 HSL:3002E:1:01 OK gaps +3 -3
I No Uniq. 358139 HSL:3001I:0:02 diffs gaps +16 -9
K 7435653 Uniq. 358138 HSL:3001K:0:01 OK 95% +14 -14 7435652 HSL:3001K:1:01 OK 86% +14 -14
L 7442589 Uniq. 358114 HSL:3002L:0:03 OK 97% +8 -8 7442588 HSL:3002L:1:05 OK gaps +8 -5
P No Uniq. 357191 HSL:3002P:0:01 diffs 95% +15 -9
R 7439055 Uniq. 358111 HSL:3001R:0:03 diffs 67% +10 -10 7439054 HSL:3001R:1:01 diffs 69% +9 -9
T 14079401 Uniq. 358140 HSL:3001T:0:02 OK 98% +20 -20 7439174 HSL:3001T:1:01 OK 91% +19 -19
U 7442496 no Matching problem, see details
Y 7442716 Uniq. 357219 HSL:3002Y:0:01 OK 98% +8 -8 7442715 HSL:3002Y:1:01 OK gaps +8 -8

11 lines total.

11 lines with differences.

A

Direction 0, route 357190, HSL:3002A:0:01

Platforms:

5/8 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,5 +1,8 @@
-15;16
-11
-3;4
-4
+H0070
+H0071
+H0078
+H0079
+H0080
+H0081
+E1171
 E1060

Direction 1, route 7440363, HSL:3002A:1:01

Shape:

Route has gaps!

Route 7440363 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3002A:1:01 is 100 %.

Platforms:

5/8 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,5 +1,8 @@
 E1060
-3
-3;4
-9
-15;16
+E1172
+H0081
+H0080
+H0079
+H0078
+H0071
+H0070

D

Direction 0, route 358112, HSL:3001D:0:01

Platforms:

7/7 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
-6
-3
-3
-5
-3
-4
-7
+H0070
+H0087
+V0612
+Ke0041
+Jä0103
+Hy0105
+Ri0106

Direction 1, route 7433392, HSL:3001D:1:01

Platforms:

7/7 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
-1
-1
-2
-1
-1
-5
-6
+Ri0156
+Hy0155
+Jä0153
+Ke0042
+V0618
+H0089
+H0070

E

Direction 0, route 357220, HSL:3002E:0:02

Platforms:

11/11 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
-15;16
-7
-1;2
+H0070
+H0090
+H0079
 E1057
 E1330
 E1832
@@ -8,4 +8,4 @@
 E1606
 E6059
 E6038
-E5141
+E5142

Direction 1, route 7442188, HSL:3002E:1:01

Shape:

Route has gaps!

Route 7442188 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3002E:1:01 is 98 %.

Platforms:

11/11 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -6,6 +6,6 @@
 E1833
 E1331
 E1058
-1;2
-8
-15;16
+H0079
+H0091
+H0070

I

Direction 0, route 358139, HSL:3001I:0:02

Tags:

Tag name has value 'I Helsinki–Tikkurila–Lentoasema–Huopalahti–Helsinki' (should be either 'I Helsinki–Helsinki' or 'I Helsinki–Helsinki').

Shape:

Route has gaps!

Route 358139 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3001I:0:02 is 90 %.

Platforms:

16/23 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,16 +1,23 @@
-1
-2
-4
-3
+H0070
+H0071
+H0072
+H0073
+H0074
+H0075
+H0076
+H0077
+V0613
+V0601
 V0706
-2
-2
+V0536
+V0521
 V0231
 V0251
 V0172
 V0171
 V0152
 V0151
-3;4
-9
-17;18
+H0084
+H0083
+H0082
+H0079

K

Direction 0, route 358138, HSL:3001K:0:01

Platforms:

15/15 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,15 +1,15 @@
-1
-2
-3
-3
-3
-3
-3
-3
-5
-3
+H0070
+H0071
+H0072
+H0073
+H0074
+H0075
+H0076
+H0077
+V0611
+V0601
 V0741
-3
-3
-3
-6
+V0731
+V0811
+Ke0091
+Ke0044

Direction 1, route 7435652, HSL:3001K:1:01

Shape:

Route 7435652 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3001K:1:01 is 86 %.

Platforms:

15/15 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,15 +1,15 @@
-6
-4
-4
-4
+Ke0043
+Ke0092
+V0816
+V0736
 V0746
-4
-6
-4
-4
-4
-4
-4
-4
-1
-1
+V0606
+V0617
+H0077
+H0076
+H0075
+H0074
+H0073
+H0072
+H0071
+H0070

L

Direction 0, route 358114, HSL:3002L:0:03

Platforms:

19/19 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
-9;10
-11
-3;4
-3;4
-4
-4
+H0070
+H0071
+H0078
+H0079
+H0080
+H0081
 E1171
 E1059
 E1330
@@ -15,5 +15,5 @@
 E5141
 Ki0103
 Ki0104
-1
-1
+Ki0105
+Ki0101

Direction 1, route 7442588, HSL:3002L:1:05

Shape:

Route has gaps!

Route 7442588 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3002L:1:05 is 98 %.

Platforms:

16/19 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-1
+Ki0151
 Ki0155
 Ki0154
 Ki0153
@@ -10,7 +10,10 @@
 E1833
 E1331
 E1060
-3
-3;4
-9
-9;10
+E1172
+H0081
+H0080
+H0079
+H0078
+H0071
+H0070

P

Direction 0, route 357191, HSL:3002P:0:01

Tags:

Tag name has value 'P Helsinki–Huopalahti–Lentoasema–Tikkurila–Helsinki' (should be either 'P Helsinki–Helsinki' or 'P Helsinki–Helsinki').

Platforms:

16/22 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,16 +1,22 @@
-17;18
-11
-3;4
+H0070
+H0071
+H0078
+H0079
+H0082
+H0083
+H0084
 V0156
 V0157
 V0176
 V0177
 V0256
 V0236
-1
-1
+V0526
+V0531
 V0701
-4
-6
-1
-2
+V0606
+V0617
+H0073
+H0072
+H0071
+H0070

R

Direction 0, route 358111, HSL:3001R:0:03

Tags:

Tag name has value 'R Helsinki–Riihimäki–Tampere' (should be either 'R Helsinki–Riihimäki' or 'R Riihimäki–Helsinki').

Shape:

Route 358111 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3001R:0:03 is 67 %.

Platforms:

10/10 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
-5
-3
-3
-5
-2
-3
-3;4
-2;3
-4
-4
+H0070
+H0087
+V0612
+Ke0041
+Jä0109
+Jä0103
+Jä0110
+Tu0104
+Hy0105
+Ri0106

Direction 1, route 7439054, HSL:3001R:1:01

Tags:

Tag name has value 'R Tampere–Riihimäki–Helsinki' (should be either 'R Helsinki–Riihimäki' or 'R Riihimäki–Helsinki').

Shape:

Route 7439054 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3001R:1:01 is 69 %.

Platforms:

10/10 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
-1
-1
-1
-1
+Ri0156
+Hy0155
+Tu0154
+Jä0160
 Jä0153
-1
-1
-1
-5
-6
+Jä0159
+Ke0042
+V0618
+H0089
+H0070

T

Direction 0, route 358140, HSL:3001T:0:02

Platforms:

21/21 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,21 +1,21 @@
-8
-2
-3
-3
-3
-3
-3
-3
-5
-3
+H0070
+H0071
+H0072
+H0073
+H0074
+H0075
+H0076
+H0077
+V0611
+V0601
 V0741
-3
-3
-3
-5
-2
-3
-3;4
-2;3
-4
-7
+V0731
+V0811
+Ke0091
+Ke0041
+Jä0109
+Jä0103
+Jä0110
+Tu0104
+Hy0105
+Ri0106

Direction 1, route 7439174, HSL:3001T:1:01

Platforms:

21/21 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,21 +1,21 @@
-1
-1
-1
-1
+Ri0156
+Hy0155
+Tu0154
+Jä0160
 Jä0153
-1
-5
-4
-4
-4
+Jä0159
+Ke0043
+Ke0092
+V0816
+V0736
 V0746
-4
-6
-4
-4
-4
-4
-4
-4
-1
-1
+V0606
+V0617
+H0077
+H0076
+H0075
+H0074
+H0073
+H0072
+H0071
+H0070

U

More than 2 matching OSM routes found: 357221, 7442495, 10993680, 10993681.

Y

Direction 0, route 357219, HSL:3002Y:0:01

Platforms:

9/9 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
-11;12
-7
-1;2
+H0070
+H0090
+H0079
 E1057
-1
-1
-1
-1
-So0156
+E6038
+E5141
+Ki0103
+Ki0101
+So0106

Direction 1, route 7442715, HSL:3002Y:1:01

Shape:

Route has gaps!

Route 7442715 overlap (tolerance 100 m) with HSL pattern HSL:3002Y:1:01 is 99 %.

Platforms:

9/9 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
 So0156
-2
-2
-2
-2
-2;3
-1;2
-8
-11;12
+Ki0151
+Ki0153
+E5142
+E6039
+E1058
+H0079
+H0091
+H0070