Finland:Joukkoliikenne/HSL/tram

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This is a comparison of OSM public transit route data with HSL tram transit data (via digitransit.fi) generated by a script.

Summary of tram transit in HSL region.

11 lines in OSM.

21 lines in HSL.

1 lines in OSM but not in HSL:

6T (1, 2)

11 lines in HSL but not in OSM:

1H, 2H, 3H, 4H, 4S, 5H, 6H, 7H, 8H, 9H, 10H

0 lines without a 'ref' tag:

Old lines

0 routes with type 'was:route=tram'.

0 routes with type 'disused:route=tram'.

HSL tram lines in OSM

This table compares HSL tram routes with OSM routes. The checker uses Refined public transport schema as a reference.

Direction 0 Direction 1
Route Master Match OSM HSL Tags Shape Platf. OSM HSL Tags Shape Platf.
1 12116142 Uniq. 52918 HSL:1001:0:03 diffs 82% +7 -11 533552 HSL:1001:1:04 diffs 81% +6 -9
2 12116144 Uniq. 52932 HSL:1002:0:01 diffs 79% +2 -5 533553 HSL:1002:1:01 diffs 34% +13 -15
3 12116149 Uniq. 52930 HSL:1003:0:01 OK 100% 26/26 533548 HSL:1003:1:03 OK 100% +1 -2
4 12116155 maybe 52941 HSL:1004:0:03 OK 100% 23/23 533551 HSL:1004:1:04 OK 100% 23/23
5 12116158 Uniq. 6334310 HSL:1005:1:02 OK 100% 9/9 6334311 HSL:1005:0:01 OK 100% 9/9
6 12116159 diffs Uniq. 52945 HSL:1006:0:01 OK 100% 23/23 533542 HSL:1006:1:01 OK 100% 21/21
7 12116160 Uniq. 52947 HSL:1007:0:04 OK gaps +10 -9 533550 HSL:1007:1:02 OK 89% +7 -4
8 12116163 Uniq. 52948 HSL:1008:0:02 diffs 56% +10 -14 533545 HSL:1008:1:01 diffs 54% +11 -14
9 12116164 Uniq. 52950 HSL:1009:0:02 diffs 97% 26/26 533549 HSL:1009:1:01 diffs 98% +1 -2
10 12116165 maybe 52951 HSL:1010:0:03 OK 98% 19/19 533543 HSL:1010:1:01 OK 100% 18/18

10 lines total.

7 lines with differences.

1

Direction 0, route 52918, HSL:1001:0:03

Tags:

Tag name has value '1 Eira–Töölö–Käpylä' (should be either '1 Eira–Ooppera–Sörnäinen (M)–Käpylä' or '1 Käpylä–Sörnäinen (M)–Ooppera–Eira').

Shape:

Route 52918 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1001:0:03 is 82 %.

Platforms:

33/29 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -7,15 +7,16 @@
 H0801
 H0701
 H0101
-H0201
-H0203
-H0205
-H0207
-H0209
+H0103
+H0105
 H0241
 H0243
 H0245
-H0259
+H0278
+H0249
+H0313
+H0331
+H0333
 H0265
 H0267
 H0269
@@ -26,8 +27,3 @@
 H0281
 H0283
 H0285
-H0333
-H0331
-H0313
-H0249
-H0278

Direction 1, route 533552, HSL:1001:1:04

Tags:

Tag name has value '1 Käpylä–Töölö–Eira' (should be either '1 Eira–Ooppera–Sörnäinen (M)–Käpylä' or '1 Käpylä–Sörnäinen (M)–Ooppera–Eira').

Shape:

Route 533552 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1001:1:04 is 81 %.

Platforms:

32/29 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -8,15 +8,16 @@
 H0270
 H0268
 H0266
+H0334
+H0332
+H0314
+H0250
 H0248
 H0246
 H0244
 H0242
-H0210
-H0208
-H0206
-H0204
-H0202
+H0106
+H0104
 H0102
 H0702
 H0802
@@ -26,7 +27,3 @@
 H0449
 H0444
 H0446
-H0334
-H0332
-H0314
-H0250

2

Direction 0, route 52932, HSL:1002:0:01

Tags:

Tag name has value '2 Olympiaterminaali–Töölö–Pasila as.' (should be either '2 Olympiaterminaali–Ooppera–Pasila as.' or '2 Pasila as.–Ooppera–Olympiaterminaali').

Shape:

Route 52932 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1002:0:01 is 79 %.

Platforms:

26/23 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -5,11 +5,8 @@
 H0404
 H0402
 H0101
-H0201
-H0203
-H0205
-H0207
-H0209
+H0103
+H0105
 H0107
 H0109
 H0641

Direction 1, route 533553, HSL:1002:1:01

Tags:

Tag name has value '2 Pasila as.–Töölö–Olympiaterminaali' (should be either '2 Olympiaterminaali–Ooppera–Pasila as.' or '2 Pasila as.–Ooppera–Olympiaterminaali').

Shape:

Route 533553 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1002:1:01 is 34 %.

Platforms:

22/20 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,18 +1,16 @@
-H0664
-H0610
-H0608
-H0606
-H0604
-H0602
-H0639
-H0112
-H0110
-H0108
-H0210
-H0208
-H0206
-H0204
-H0202
+H0340
+H0330
+H0320
+H0318
+H0316
+H0314
+H0250
+H0248
+H0246
+H0244
+H0242
+H0106
+H0104
 H0102
 H0401
 H0403

3

Direction 1, route 533548, HSL:1003:1:03

Platforms:

26/25 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -7,9 +7,8 @@
 H0634
 H0632
 H0278
-H0258
 H0256
-<no ref in OSM>
+H0254
 H0252
 H0306
 H0304

4

5 route pattern(s) in HSL data, matching may be wrong.

52941 -> HSL:1004:0:03
533551 -> HSL:1004:1:04
HSL:1004:0:03 -> 52941
HSL:1004:0:05 -> None
HSL:1004:1:05 -> None
HSL:1004:1:01 -> None
HSL:1004:1:04 -> 533551

6

Route master:

route_master has extra members: 2692584, 2692585


7

Direction 0, route 52947, HSL:1007:0:04

Shape:

Route has gaps!

Route 52947 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1007:0:04 is 80 %.

Platforms:

28/29 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -15,14 +15,15 @@
 H0307
 H0309
 H0311
-H0313
-H0331
-H0333
-H0265
-H0267
-H0269
-H0271
-H0618
+H0314
+H0250
+H0259
+H0261
+H0655
+H0657
+H0659
+H0661
+H0619
 H0616
 H0614
-H0612
+H0621

Direction 1, route 533550, HSL:1007:1:02

Shape:

Route 533550 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1007:1:02 is 89 %.

Platforms:

26/29 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,6 +1,9 @@
-H0612
-H0617
-H0619
+H0285
+H0284
+H0282
+H0280
+H0276
+H0274
 H0272
 H0270
 H0268
@@ -9,7 +12,7 @@
 H0332
 H0312
 H0310
-H0251
+H0308
 H0454
 H0452
 H0450

8

Direction 0, route 52948, HSL:1008:0:02

Tags:

Tag name has value '8 Jätkäsaari–Töölö–Arabia' (should be either '8 Kolmikulma–Ooppera–Sörnäinen (M)–Arabia' or '8 Arabia–Sörnäinen (M)–Ooppera–Kolmikulma').

Shape:

Route 52948 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1008:0:02 is 56 %.

Platforms:

23/19 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -1,23 +1,19 @@
-H0295
-H0293
-H0291
-H0213
-H0215
-H0217
-H0221
-H0207
-H0209
+H0709
+H0701
+H0101
+H0103
+H0105
 H0241
 H0243
 H0245
 H0278
+H0249
+H0313
+H0315
+H0317
+H0319
 H0321
 H0323
 H0325
 H0335
 H0327
-H0249
-H0313
-H0315
-H0317
-H0319

Direction 1, route 533545, HSL:1008:1:01

Tags:

Tag name has value '8 Arabia–Töölö–Jätkäsaari' (should be either '8 Kolmikulma–Ooppera–Sörnäinen (M)–Arabia' or '8 Arabia–Sörnäinen (M)–Ooppera–Kolmikulma').

Shape:

Route 533545 overlap (tolerance 30 m) with HSL pattern HSL:1008:1:01 is 54 %.

Platforms:

23/20 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -3,21 +3,18 @@
 H0328
 H0326
 H0330
+H0320
+H0318
+H0316
+H0314
+H0250
 H0248
 H0246
 H0244
 H0242
-H0210
-H0208
-H0222
-H0218
-H0216
-H0214
-H0290
-H0292
-H0294
-H0250
-H0314
-H0316
-H0318
-H0320
+H0106
+H0104
+H0102
+H0702
+H0802
+H0709

9

Direction 0, route 52950, HSL:1009:0:02

Tags:

Tag name has value '9 Jätkäsaari–Rautatieasema–Kallio–Pasilan asema' (should be either '9 Länsiterminaali–Rautatieasema–Kallio–Pasilan asema' or '9 Pasilan asema–Kallio–Rautatieasema–Länsiterminaali').

Direction 1, route 533549, HSL:1009:1:01

Tags:

Tag name has value '9 Pasilan asema–Kallio–Rautatieasema–Jätkäsaari' (should be either '9 Länsiterminaali–Rautatieasema–Kallio–Pasilan asema' or '9 Pasilan asema–Kallio–Rautatieasema–Länsiterminaali').

Platforms:

24/23 platforms in OSM / HSL.

--- OSM
+++ HSL
@@ -6,9 +6,8 @@
 H0654
 H0652
 H0250
-H0258
 H0256
-<no ref in OSM>
+H0254
 H0252
 H0306
 H0304

10

3 route pattern(s) in HSL data, matching may be wrong.

52951 -> HSL:1010:0:03
533543 -> HSL:1010:1:01
HSL:1010:0:03 -> 52951
HSL:1010:1:03 -> None
HSL:1010:1:01 -> 533543