Talk:Calgary Transit

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Latest comment: 25 days ago by Hoserab in topic network=*
Jump to navigation Jump to search

network=*

Resolved: Recommendations adopted 18 February 2023

Currently, the recommendation is to use network=Calgary Transit. However, a default point feature type, called CT, already exists that automatically sets bus stop network values as follows.

TagInfo

Looking at the tag info, there are nearly 10-times as many features tagged with network=CT.

Network Abbreviations

In the article, Buses#Adding a bus route to OpenStreetMap, the description of network=* permits using abbreviations. While the article, Key:network#Public transit, states,

There is currently no consensus whether the values should be abbreviated or not.

Recommendations

Since a default feature type already exists, there are significantly more uses of network=CT, and network abbreviations are permissible, I suggest the following.

  1. Modify Calgary Transit#Bus Stops to recommend using network=CT for the Regular bus stop, Future bus stop, and Bus zone sections
  2. Manually replace existing network=Calgary Transit tags with network=CT
  3. Add the section Possible tagging mistakes to Calgary Transit with the following information
  • network=Calgary Transit🔎
If you know places with this tag, verify if it could be tagged with another tag.
Automated edits are strongly discouraged unless you really know what you are doing!

Mkyleran (talk) 23:27, 15 February 2023 (UTC)Reply

FYI I've changed all of the references in the article to recommend the opposite: tag for "Calgary Transit", not "CT". The "CT" tag is no longer recommended by the Name Suggestion Index, and regardless of its frequency of use, was not abbreviated for any particularly good reason in the first place. See this discussion on at community.osm.org. Hoserab (talk) 16:33, 10 April 2026 (UTC)Reply