User:BudgieInWA/Completeness Criteria

This is a list of different criteria that the (Perth? WA? Aus?) community uses to determine the completeness of regions of the map. Different use cases are represent by different categories.

This page is an early draft and the criteria for each category is still in flux. It also needs motivations detailed for each category, and instructions/expectations for validating completeness (in general and specifically for individual categories).

Buildings

Basic Buildings

• All buildings outlines are present (not worrying about small shelters and private carports or sheds, etc).
• Building outlines are reasonably accurately positioned and aligned with nearby features.

Detailed Buildings

• Buildings are tagged with the appropriate specific `building` tag.
• All public entrances are present on the building outline.
• Buildings are split into parts as appropriate, each tagged with `building:levels`, `roof:shape`.
• ...

Micromapped Buildings

• Building are mapped according to Simple 3D Buildings.
• All entrances and exits are present and tagged with the appropriate entrance type.
• ...

Public Transport & Parking

Basic Transport

• bus stops,
• train stops,
• car/bike parking,
• airports
• boat terminals

Detailed Transport

• parking type, cover, etc.
• stop number/station name

Micromapped Transport

Detailed Transport and

• Amenties
• ground cover
• nice buildings
• ...

Cars

Basic Roads

• All roads residential and above are present.
• Roads are tagged with `name` or `noname`.

Routable Road

Following on from Basic Roads.

• All parking aisles, drive-throughs and access roads are present.
• Unpaved roads are tagged as such.
• All stop signs, give way signs and traffic lights are present.
• All traffic calming features are present.
• All turn restrictions are present.
• Roads are tagged with `lanes` and `turn:lanes` and `access:lanes`.
• Dual-carriageways are split into two ways where appropriate.

Micromapped Roads

Following on from Routable Roads.

• Road surfaces are tagged.
• Unusual intersection shapes and traffic islands are mapped as areas.
• Roads are tagged with `width:lanes`, ...
• ...

Bikes

Basic Cycleways

• All bike paths are present.
• All bike lanes on roads are present.

Routable Cycleways

Following on from Basic Bike Paths.

• Bike paths are tagged with designations and access restriction.
• oneway/twoway
• All give way signs (that bike riders should observe) are present.
• All bike crossing are present, with the type tagged.

Micromapped Cycleways

Following on from Routable Cycleways.

• surface
• incline
• width
• shape?

Walking

Basic Footpaths

• All public footpaths connections, including crossing, are present.
  • This means that if two points are connected by footpaths, there should be a footpath present connecting them,
  • but the precise geometry is not necessary, and every small offshoot and bend is not necessary.

Routable Footpaths

Basic Footpaths and

• crossing types
• all Barriers, gates and entrances (with height indicating if you can step over it)
• ...

Mircomapped Paths

• surface
• incline direction
• width
• areas for odd-shaped paths
• ...

Wheeling

Wheelchair Routability

Routable footpaths

• curbs
• inclines
• Barriers (gates, bollards) tagged with `wheelchair`
• lifts
• ...

Wheelchair Access

• Shops and amenities have wheelchair accessibility tagged.
• ...

Tapping

Blind Routability

Wheelchair Routability and

• All tactile paving is present.
• Crossings have push buttons, and audio/tactile signals tagged.
• speaking timetables

Places

Basic Places

• All shops, parks and major attractions are present.
• correct level

Detailed Places

Basic Places and

• Shops, parks and attractions are tagged with `name`.
• specific detail (cuisines, services, etc.)
• contact (website, email, phone, social media)
• ...

People & Parks

Basic Amenities

• All public toilets, drinking water, benches, bins are present.
• ...

Detailed Amenities

Basic Amenities and

• functional details (bottle filling, bench backrest, etc.)
• ... more amenities

Micromapped Parks

Detailed Amenties and

• water, grass, gardens, shrubs and trees
• things: street cabinets, light poles, drains? pipes?
• ...

Basic Tourism

• Tourist info infra
• lookouts and names places
• ...

Detailed Tourism

• signs posts
• destination signs