User:Cybereric/Tests

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

TESTS

STATUES

Ideas

Put things together

There's a need to organize and group the different types of statues.

Back to Art

What is a statue?

  • a type of sculpture.
  • in 3 dimensions (full-round) unlike "high-reliefs" and "low-reliefs"
  • a medium-sized sculpture that represents a human, a deity or an animal.
  • "medium" means equal to or greater than half the natural size (of a human), below this half it is a statuette or a figurine.
  • It's possible to classify it by "genre" (ex: nude) and "style" (combination of visual elements, techniques and methods) like classic, renaissance, modern ....

In OpenStreetMap

So it's a bit different.

We have "artwork_type=statue" used for figurative works and "artwork_type=sculpture" which is recommended for non-figurative works

And we have 3 different ways to map the statues because we distinguish between "memorial" ones (small and large) and "non-memorial" ones.

Which give :

- artwork_type=statue + statue=*

- memorial=statue + statue=*

- monument=statue + statue=*

Classification

First we need to avoid having a huge list of statue=* :

- statue=name 1

- statue=name 2

- statue=name 3

- ...

You can imagine with the Hindu pantheon which has 330 million gods !

In my opinion, we should use some "kind of statue" categories to put information in this tag.


For example in the current wiki page we have:

- statue=virgin (Mary)

- statue = saint

- statue = buddha

In fact these three statues have something in common, they are linked to religion !

So "statue=religion" would be better than "statue=buddha"

Buddha should be in the name=*

And in the future, "statue=religion" might be refined with "religion=*" and maybe even more information.

Research

So I tried to find "kinds of statues" based as much as possible on artistic criteria.

For example "statue=equestrian" wasn't very hard to find because it's a well-documented style of statue.


So you will find below:

1/ A table which is a summary with all "statue=*" tags with a small comment.

2/ Followed by three tables with visual examples for artworks, memorials and monuments.


Good reading !

Summary

Artworks (tourism=artwork)
Pure artistic works without any dedication and/or commemoration
statue=allegory Pure artistic allegory. No dedication and presence of symbolic features
statue=mythology Statue linked to mythology (greek, roman,etc.) by her subject.
statue=funeral_art Pure funeral artwork. No dedication. Unidentified people.
statue=equestrian Pure artistic artwork. No dedication. Unidentified people and horses.
statue=animal Pure animal artwork. No dedication. No allegories but « naturalist » style.
Memorials (historic=memorial)
Statues to commemorate something, somebody,...
statue=allegory Allegory dedicated to something, somebody (presence of symbolic features).
statue=public_figure Statue dedicated to a public figure.
statue=representative_figure Statue dedicated, through a representative, to a group of people (social class, members of an organization, inhabitants of a city, country, ...)
statue=religious_figure Statue linked to religious figure.
statue=funeral_art Funeral statue of identified people.

In this category of statues it's possible to distinguish :

  • the orants [fr only] (those who pray)
  • the mourners (weepers)
  • the recumbent effigies (tomb effigies)
  • the transis (cadaver monuments)
statue=equestrian Equestrian statue of an identified person.
statue=animal Memorial statue dedicated to one or more identified animal(s).
Monuments (historic=monument)
Monumental statues to commemorate something, somebody,...
statue=allegory Monumental dedicated allegory.
statue=public_figure Monumental dedicated statue to a public figure.
statue=representative_figure Monumental dedicated statue to a group of people through a representative
statue=religious_figure Monumental dedicated religious statue.
statue=equestrian Monumental dedicated equestrian statue.
statue=animal Monumental dedicated animal statue.

Tableau

ARTWORKS (tourism=artwork)
Pure artistic works without any dedication and/or commemoration
Tags Examples To go further Comments
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=allegory
The Peace
The Justice
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=allegory
  • allegory=
    • peace
    • justice
    • abundance
    • prudence
    • faith
    • mercy
    • courage
    • discipline
    • liberty
    • truth
    • ...


To go further why not use allegory=* as sub tag

  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=mythology
Jupiter
Qilin
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=mythology
  • mythology=
    • greek
    • roman
    • chinese
    • indhu
    • ...
  • Mythological or legendary statue
  • Should be use for ancient religions (greek, roman,etc.) or folklore


Be careful, mythology and religion are linked.

Try to make difference between the legendary and the sacred.

The statue must not be worshiped.

If so see «historic=memorial + memorial = statue »


To go further why not use mythology=* as sub tag

  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=funeral_art
Angel of Grief
Angel of Grief
Mourning statue
Mourning statue
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=funeral_art
  • funeral_art=
    • angel_of_grief
    • mourning_statue
    • ...
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=equestrian
Horse tamer
Physical energy
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=animal
Rhinocéros
Conger
  • tourism=artwork
  • artwork_type=statue
  • statue=animal
  • animal=
    • rhinoceros
    • fish
    • ...
MEMORIALS (historic=memorial)
Statues to commemorate something, somebody,...
Tags Examples To go further Comments
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=allegory 
Boy Scout Memorial
Sámuel Diószegi and Mihály Fazekas Memorial
Allegory of "American Manhood

and Womanhood and the ideals

they will pass onto the youth."

 Boy Scout Memorial dedicated

in 1964 for the fiftieth anniversary

of the Boy Scouts of America

Allegory of Nature

Memorial dedicated to

Sámuel Diószegi and

Mihály Fazekas authors

of the first Hungarian 

botanical treatise

  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=allegory 
  • allegory=*
  • Allegory
  • Presence of symbolic features
  • Special allegory. Must be dedicated to something, somebody
  • Unidentified people


To go further why not use allegory=* as sub tag.

Many allegories come from « virtues »

Others can represent institutions, cities, countries, concepts, ideas ...

  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=public_figure
Gandhi
Captain Frederick John Walker
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=public_figure
  • public_figure=
    • king /queen
    • emperor / emperess
    • statesman
    • politician
    • soldier
    • scientist
    • artist
    • ...
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=representative_figure
Policeman
C.C.C Worker
Dedicated to the local police in Burgos (Spain) for its 150th anniversary. Dedicated to the workers of Civilian Conservation Corps between 1934 and 1942.
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=representative_figure
  • representative_figure=
    • policemen
    • soldiers
    • citizens
    • workers
    • ....
  • Statue dedicated, through a representative, to a group of people (a social class, the members of an organization, administration, society, the inhabitants of a city, country, ...)
  • Unidentified people
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=religious_figure
Pietà
Yamuna
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=religious_figure
  • religious_figure=
    • god / goddess
    • divinity
    • saint
    • pope
    • priest
    • monk
    • yogi
    • guru
    • lama
    • ...
  • Statue linked to religious figure
  • The statue can be whorshiped
  • Dedication to a deity, clergy member, saint, ...
  • Identified people


To go further why not use religion=* as sub tag.

The values of Key:religion could be used

  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=funeral_art
Orant of Antoine Achille de Morell
Pleurants ( tomb of Charles III of Navarre )
Tomb effigy of Denis Affre
Transi (cadaver monument) - Boussu (Belgium)
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=funeral_art
  • funeral_art=
    • orant
    • pleurant
    • tomb_effigy
    • ...
  • Funeral statue of identified people
  • In Christianity it's possible to distinguish different dedicated funeral artworks ː
  • There are certainly other types of funerary statues in other civilizations
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=equestrian
Duke of Orléans
Christian IX
  • Equestrian statue of an identified person
  • For the biggest ones see « monument = statue »
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=animal
Emily the cow
Sledge dogs of the Scott Polar Research Institute
 Emily the cow Sledge dogs
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=statue
  • statue=animal
  • animal=
    • cow
    • dog
    • ...
  • Memorial statue dedicated to one or more identified animal(s)
MONUMENTS (historic=monument)
Monumental statues to commemorate something, somebody,...
Tags Examples To go furth Comments
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=allegory
Statue of Liberty
Monument to the Republic
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=allegory
  • allegory=
    • peace
    • justice
    • abundance
    • prudence
    • faith
    • mercy
    • courage
    • discipline
    • liberty
    • truth
    • ...
  • Monumental allegory
  • Presence of symbolic features
  • Dedication to something
  • Unidentified people


To go further why not use allegory=* as sub tag.

Many allegories come from « virtues »

Others can represent institutions, cities, countries, concepts, ideas ...

  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=public_figure
Mao Zedong
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=public_figure
  • public_figure=
    • king / queen
    • emperor / empress
    • statesman
    • politician
    • soldier
    • scientist
    • artist
    • ...
  • Monumental statue of a public figure
  • Dedication to somebody
  • Identified people
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=representative_figure
Miner
The Amazon (Cotonou - Benin)
Monumental statue of a miner commemorating the deaths in a mining accident in 1960. Statue celebrating the Dahomey Amazons.
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=representative_figure
  • representative_figure=
    • policemen
    • soldiers
    • citizens
    • workers
    • ....
  • Monumental statue dedicated, through a representative, to a group of people (a social class, the members of an organization, administration, society, the inhabitants of a city, country, ...)
  • Unidentified people
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=religious_figure
Lord Muruga
Christ the Redeemer
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=religious_figure
  • religious_figure =
    • god / goddess
    • divinity
    • saint
    • pope
    • priest
    • monk
    • yogi
    • guru
    • lama
    • ...
  • Monumental religious statue
  • Dedication to a deity, clergy member, saint, ...
  • The statue can be whorshiped
  • Identified people


To go further why not use religion=* as sub tag.

The values of Key:religion could be used.

  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=equestrian
Maceo monument
José Gervasio Artigas
  • Monumental equestrian statue
  • Dedication to somebody
  • Identified people
  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=animal
The Big Ram
The Kelpies
The purposes of these statues :
" The Big Ram signifies the

importance of the sheep

and wool industry".

From the  Merino breed


''The Kelpies represent

the lineage of the heavy

horse of Scottish industry

and economy"

From  Clydesdale horse breed

  • historic=monument
  • monument=statue
  • statue=animal
  • animal=
    • sheep
    • horse
    • ...
  • Monumental animal statue

Statues in « Artworks» category (tourism=artwork)

Statues in « Memorials » category (historic=memorial)

Statues in « Monuments » category (historic=monument)

CÉNOTAPHES

Idées de définitions pour le tag « cenotaph=* »

cenotaph=tomb They look like real tombs so they are the « real » cenotaphs in the strict sense ;-)
cenotaph=pillar Very often used for war memorials

One can distinguish square pillars and rectangle ones

cenotaph=broken_column Quite often used for war memorials.
cenotaph=cross Seem to be found in anglo-saxon countries, in Germany, ...
cenotaph=pyramid
cenotaph=statue
cenotaph=statuary_group
cenotaph=sculpture
cenotaph=stone
Tags Examples Comments
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=broken_column
Monument du Souvenir Column to Faisal I Alton Downs
Père-Lachaise - Division 55 - Monument du Souvenir 02.jpg
אנדרטת פייסל.JPG
AltonDownsCenotaph1.jpg
Père-Lachaise - Paris - France Haifa - Israel Queensland - Australia
+ war_memorial=yes
Quite often used for war memorials.
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=cross
Saint Andrew war memorial Lothringer Kreuz War memorial of The Queen's Own Rifles
St Andrew, Preston, war memorial - geograph.org.uk - 3215263.jpg
Münster, Schlossgarten, Lothringer Kreuz -- 2021 -- 7280.jpg
War memorial of The Queen's Own Rifles.jpg
Preston - United Kingdom Münster - Germany Toronto - Canada
+ war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes
Seem to be found in anglo-saxon countries, in Germany, ...
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=pillar
London cenotaph Southampton cenotaph World War I cenotaph
Portland.stone.cenotaph.london.arp.jpg
Southampton Cenotaph, 2014 (1).jpg
Ballarat World War I Cenotaph 001.JPG
London - United Kingdom United Kingdom Ballarat - Australia
+ war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes
Very often used for war memorials

One can distinguish square pillars and rectangle ones

  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=pyramid
Antonio Canova cenotaph U.S. Coast Guard Memorial Merrickville
Basilica di Santa Maria dei Frari interno - Monumento di Canova.jpg
US Coast Guard Memorial - looking ENE - Arlington National Cemetery - 2011.JPG
Merrickville, Ontario - Cenotaph Park - War Memorial.jpg
Florence - Italy Arlington - Virginia - USA Ontario - Canada
+ war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=sculpture
Charles Brockden Brown cenotaph Hiroshima victims cenotaph National police memorial
Charles Brockden Brown cenotaph.jpg
Cenotaph, Hiroshima, South view 20190417 1.jpg
London, UK (August 2014) - 149.JPG
Philadelphia - Pennsylvania - USA Hiroshima - Japan London - United Kingdom
+ war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes (not only)
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=statuary_group
Tomb of Julius II Northumberland Fusiliers Memorial Giuseppe La Farina cenotaph
'Moses' by Michelangelo JBU010.jpg
Northumberland Fusiliers Memorial.jpg
Monumento funebre Giuseppe La Farina.jpg
Roma - Italy Newcastle - United Kingdom Florence - Italy
+ war_memorial=yes
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=statue
Amarube viaduct cenotaph Police Memorial Monument to the War of 1812
Cenotaph under Amarube-tekkyo bridge.JPG
Police Memorial, Kolkata.jpg
Monument to the War of 1812 photo by Djuradj Vujcic.jpg
Japan Kolkata - India Toronto - Canada
+ war_memorial=yes
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=stone
Battleship Yamato Memorial 14th Regiment of Jazłowiec Uhlans memorial stone
戦艦大和戦死者之碑.jpg
14th Regiment of Jazłowiec Uhlans memorial stone in Kampinos near Łomianki 01.jpg
Japan Kampinos - Poland
+ war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes
  • historic=memorial
  • memorial=cenotaph
  • cenotaph=tomb
Charles Baudelaire cenotaph City of Surrey cenotaph John Chandos cenotaph
Cénotaphe de Baudelaire (1).jpg
City of Surrey Cenotaph 2009.jpg
Cénotaphe Jean Chandos 1.jpg
Paris - France Cloverdale - Canada Mazerolles - France
+ war_memorial=yes + war_memorial=yes
The « real » cenotaphs in the strict sense ;-)

Types de monuments

FR

Attention !

Pour ce qui concerne les parcs commémoratifs.

Le fait qu'un parc porte le nom d'une personnalité ou d'un événement historique ne suffit pas à en faire obligatoirement un parc commémoratif. Il doit avoir été structurellement et architecturalement conçu ou aménagé dans un but commémoratif. De plus pour être monumental il doit s'étendre sur une certaine superficie. S'il est de taille réduite il faudra plutôt envisager d'utiliser historic=memorial. (Voir les exemples ci-dessous)

Types de monuments

Il est possible de définir une douzaine de types différents de «monuments » commémoratifs :

  • Arc de triomphe
  • Bâtiment commémoratif
  • Buste
  • Butte
  • Colonne
  • Croix
  • Obélisque
  • Parc
  • Sculpture
  • Statue
  • Structure architecturale
  • Tour
  • ...

Les hauteurs des exemples ci-dessous sont données en mètres. (sans celles des socles / piedestaux pour les statues)

Exemples de types de monuments
Arcs de triomphe Bâtiments Bustes
Triumphal Arch of Orange, built during the reign of Augustus on the Via Agrippa to Lyon, Arausio (14827022832).jpg
Arc d'Orange
Паметник "Арка на Свободата".jpg
Arche de la Liberté (35 m)
Buttes Colonnes Croix
Chili
Obélisques Parcs Sculptures
Allemagne
Statues Structures Tours
Inde

EN

Monument types

It is possible to define about twelve different types of commemorative "monuments" :

  • Triumphal arch
  • Memorial building
  • Bust
  • Column
  • Cross
  • Mound
  • Obelisk
  • Park
  • Sculpture
  • Statue
  • Architectural structure
  • Tower

The heights of the examples given below are in meters (without the base / pedestal for the statues).

Examples of monuments by type (alphabetically ordered)
Arches (triumphal) Buildings Busts
France
Bulgaria
Taiwan
United States
Columns Crosses Mounds
Italy
Canada
Chile
Spain
Belgium
Poland
Obelisks Parks Sculptures
Ethiopia
Peru
France
Japan
Croatia
Germany
Statues Structures Towers
Malaysia
Russia
Portugal
Danemark
Northern Ireland