User:Zverik/Main Road Research

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

So, the discussion with Harald from Skobbler has given us three major points for good routing applications with lanes:

  1. Turn Lanes tagging scheme (being voted on right now)
  2. Destination signs (already present, but not popular)
  3. Tagging scheme for main roads / through direction.

On this page I research the latter. In English, because it could be discussed with mappers from other countries.

The Task

There are several key points, for which we need tagging scheme(s):

  1. There is a sign, "main road". It currently has no representation in OSM data.
    8.13 (Road sign).gif
  2. Sometimes a road does a slight turn, while a secondary road goes at such angle, that it can be considered "forward" direction by a program, although it's a right turn for a human. In this case a program should shut up.
  3. On complex crossings, or when angles are all askew, a program cannot determine if the route goes through, or if it's a turn. Routing can depend on a number of left turns and such.
  4. To apply the turn lanes tagging scheme, one must know which way is "forward", and which are turns.
  5. And don't forget two-way roads.

Immediate Problems

This intersection. Clearly the main road goes slightly left, and the way forward is as wide. If a software will keep silent, a driver could forget to keep left and miss the main road. Possible solution: "stay on the main road", something like that. Is it better than "turn left"?

In such situation a clear instruction is needed, something like "Stay on the left lanes and follow further the XXX". --Imagic 15:47, 19 January 2012 (UTC)

Main Road Relation

A relation with two or more connected ways, with type=main_road. Probably with optional straight=yes/no. This automatically eliminates two ways from a crossing while searching for "through" way, and helps determining how much time would the crossing take (a lot less when driving the main road, naturally).

Taginfo

There are 24 main_road=yes tags, used in relation type=right_of_way. There is a proposal, probably the same as main_road relation proposed above (todo: read it). There are 52 relations of that type in total (which means only half of them have main_road tag). An extract from Overpass API.

No type tags with "main" inside values.