- 1 Introduction
Exit refs not used
- 1.2 Draw order of ways is not understood
No basemap/overview map is created
Routing over tile boundaries is broken in Mapsource/Basecamp
Sea polygon generation works inconsistently
- 1.6 add-pois-to-areas sometimes places the POI outside the polygon
- 1.7 Area too large
- 1.8 Relations
- 1.9 Error parsing pbf files
This is a list of current issues known to affect mkgmap.
Exit refs not used Motorway exits (highway=motorway_junction) can be assigned a reference number and an exit_to value indicating where the exit leads. Neither of these values is used by mkgmap to generate routing hints.
For instance, if there is an exit with ref 32 on a highway with ref E-11, and the exit is also tagged with exit_to=somePlace, the ideal situation would be routing hints that read:
- Proceed along highway E-11 to exit 32
- Exit at junction 32 to somePlace
This is not currently possible with mkgmap.
There are two options that fix the problem: --process-destination and --process-exits.
Draw order of ways is not understood
MapSource and Garmin GPS units ignore any OSM layer tags in ways, meaning that when rendered, the order of crossing ways does not reflect the true layer hierarchy stipulated in the layer tags. It is not clear if this is an explicit limitation of the Garmin IMG format, or if mkgmap is just not able to encode the appropriate information.
No basemap/overview map is created Work is needed to create a basemap, which will speed up map redraw when zoomed far out inside when using Basecamp/Mapsource/Qlandkarte GT. This will allow for more sensible resolutions.
Routing over tile boundaries is broken in Mapsource/Basecamp Routing inside Mapsource/Basecamp (though not on GPS) works inconsistently when the route crosses (several) tile boundaries.
Should not happen any more since mkgmap r3116.
Sea polygon generation works inconsistently The --generate-sea option can be used to generate the sea polygons but is currently to be considered as "beta". There are two alternative ways of using --generate-sea: either with multipolygons (--generate-sea:multipolygon) or without multipolygons (--generate-sea:no-mp) combined with a TYP file.
This is fixed since r2278. Since this version the --precomp-sea option gives the directory where precompiled sea tiles containing the sea/land data only are located. Sea tiles can be compiled once and used for each mkgmap run. Please read http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/svn/wsvn/mkgmap/src/uk/me/parabola/mkgmap/sea/optional/readme.txt how to compile the sea tiles. There are some sites that provide readily compiled sea tile packages.
add-pois-to-areas sometimes places the POI outside the polygon
When the --add-pois-to-area switch is applied to complex polygons (e.g. with strongly concave edges, such as beaches) the POI can be placed outside of the polygon with which it is associated. The calculation of what is "inside" a polygon is computationally complex, hence why no solution has yet been implemented.
Area too large
The Garmin files have a maximum size, so to create a map of a large area you need to split the file into a number of tiles using splitter. Here is how to do it:
java -Xmx1000m -jar splitter.jar file.osm
- Run mkgmap on the resulting files, for instance
java -Xmx1000m -ea -jar mkgmap.jar -c template.args
See here for more details (you will most likely need to change splitter's --max-nodes switch to a lower value than the default).
- Match member roles by regular expression
apply role=valueis for fixed strings.
- Match relation members by type (way, node, relation)
- Currently, relation members can only be matched by role
- Match relation members by the tags that they already carry
- Example: apply certain things to highway=bus_stop nodes only
- Before applying, sort the relations by a user-defined criterion
- A way may be served by multiple bus lines. Sort the bus route relations by alphabetic order of ref=*.
- Allow filtering out duplicates
- Opposing bus routes of the same line can consist of oneway segments as well as shared non-oneway segments.
- Currently, the oneway segments would be labeled “42” and the non-oneway segments “42,42” for a bus line “42”.
- If the bus route is defined as a single relation comprising both directions, then
apply_oncewould do the trick.
- Generate multiple map layers in one pass
- This would reduce parsing overhead and reduce the complexity in style files and invocation scripts.
- You normally might want to see only one of route=road, route=bicycle, route=bus at a time, by selecting visible map layers on the device.
- This would be useful for certain points and lines too, e.g., generate traffic_calming=* on a separate layer
Error parsing pbf files
The error message:
Error at line 1, col 1 Bad file format: 63240001.osm.pbf Error parsing file
usually means that mkgmap's pbf support is disabled. This happens if the pbf dependency jars are unavailable at buildtime and/or runtime.
The versions of mkgmap at http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/snapshots/ have been built with pbf support enabled and the required jars are included, so they should work. If you build mkgmap from the svn repository yourself, you can use the ant buildscript. The resolve target downloads all required jar files.