DE talk:Tag:historic=aircraft

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Name vs. Typ

Hi, sollte der Flugzeugtyp in den Namen rein oder sollte es dafür besser ein eigenes Tag geben? Gruß S-Man42 (talk) 07:38, 22 March 2013 (UTC)

Habe lt. TagInfo einige Ergänzungen vorgenommen, die eine bessere Detailierung ermöglichen. Könnte mir z.B. vorstellen name=Rosinenbomber, description=Douglas C-47 Skytrain, aircraft:type=cargo. --Reneman (talk) 08:54, 22 March 2013 (UTC)
Hi, I think the use of aircraft:type=* as described here is rather unfortunate as it combines aircraft role and aircraft method of lift in one cathegory, in other words, is a civilian (not civil) version of an Mi-8 an aircraft:type=helicopter, or aircraft:type=transport? Also, using aircraft:type=* this way only leaves the name=* tag for the aircraft type, leaving no place for the actual name of the particular plane, if it has one - e.g. WWII bombers were routinely named by their crews and quite a few of these planes ended up in museums.
How about this:
aircraft=fixed_wing|helicopter|aurogyro|tiltrotor|ekranoplan|...
aircraft:role=fighter|bomber|airliner|transport|reconnaissance|experimental|general_aviation|...
aircraft:type=* - e.g. MiG-25, Bf 109, B-2 Spirit, ...
aircraft:manufacturer=* - e.g. Mikoyan-Gurevich, Messerschmitt, Northrop/Grumman, ...
name=* e.g. Endeavour, Spirit of St. Louis, Enola Gay, ...
?
Sorry for writing this in English - my German is passive at best and the tagging isn't described in this much detail on the English wiki. Michalfabik (talk) 18:04, 12 August 2017 (UTC)