Talk:Organised editing/activities/bymiljøetaten

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Accidental page capitalization & feedback for tagging scheme

You accidentally capitalized Oslostandarden in the page titles

The page title should however be all lowercase (otherwise links break e.g. oslostandarden:cycleway:width=*). I think moving the pages requires elevated privileges, you could ask an admin.

Also note that the syntactic convention for new tags is to use (British) English, so perhaps oslo_standard: would be a better prefix than oslostandarden:, which might be a bit hard to read for contributors who don't speak Norwegian.

Also looking at key:Oslostandarden:cycleway:width, do you know the actual numerical widths of the cycleways? Because in that case I think tagging them with cycleway:width=* would be preferable since the key:Oslostandarden:cycleway:width can be trivially derived from the numerical width, in which case adding the (broad, normal, narrow) classification would seem redundant to me.

--Push-f (talk) 16:43, 16 June 2022 (UTC)

I'll contact an administrator to fix the page titles, thanks! I agree that key:Oslostandarden:cycleway:width would be redundant in that case. I'll ask an admin to change the page title of key:Oslostandarden:cycleway:width to Oslostandarden where I'll explain more about all details of the document. Preferably, I would like to have a wikipage explaining how to derive the right width category from the cycleway:width=* tag.

--BYM - Ola Juul Holm (talk) 09:39, 17 June 2022 (UTC)