User:Dknelson9876/Salt Lake County Road Classifications

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Although I intend to eventually cover the whole county, to make this feasible I'm breaking it down by city, and starting with the cities I'm most familiar with.

Methodology

To provide the base line of importance of a road, I'm referencing three things:

  • Speed Limit (a number)
  • Lane count (a number)
  • Length

As I'm starting in the suburbs, my base reference for whether the length of a road is significant, I'm referencing the typical size of a major block in the suburbs, which according to the measuring tool on Bing Maps is about 1 mile x 0.5 miles. Therefore, I'm classifying length by "Major or Minor {direction} access" meaning that a road crosses 3+ blocks, even if those blocks are in the neighboring city. This is opposed to "access through/inside a {size} block", which means that the road in question does not cross a road of higher priority.

The next factor I'm using is the Utah Department of Transportation's Functional Classification Map, available here. For the most part, it is already a good match up, where:

But, these don't line up perfectly, so I'm including three more factors on the lower priority highways table:

  • Significant Landmarks: does this road go beyond one block, or does it have any non-residential destinations (i.e. shops and schools)
  • Priority Access: does traffic turning onto this road from a road with higher priority have a stop sign or traffic signal to stop cross traffic, making it easier to turn onto this road?
  • Priority Inside Block: Is this road is completely free flowing inside a block? This road earns a NO for having stops signs or speed bumps slowing down through traffic.

Further, to make sure the line is clear for whether a road should be tertiary or residential, I've split up the tables for primary and secondary highways from tertiary highways and what I'm calling "significant local roads". A road counts as a significant local road by meeting at least one of the following:

  • Classified above local traffic according to UDOT
  • Has a non-residential destination (i.e. shops and schools)
  • Has painted lanes

Taylorsville

Taylorsville Primary and Secondary Roads
Road Name(s) First/Last Link(s) Current highway= UDOT Classification Speed Limit Lanes Significant Landmarks/Access
Redwood Road primary Principal Arterial 45/40 mph 7 Major north/south access
4500/4700 South primary Principal Arterial 40/50 mph 5-7 Major east/west access
5400 South primary Principal Arterial 45/50 mph 5-7 Major east/west access
Constitution Blvd/2700 West secondary Minor Arterial 40 mph 5/3 Major north/south access
4100 South secondary Minor Arterial 40 mph 5 Major east/west access
6200 South secondary Minor Arterial 35 mph 5 Major east/west access*

*especially for I-215 traffic. The segment of Redwood Road that connects east/west traffic from 6200 S to/from I-215 is busy enough that it has 2 uninterrupted right turn lanes and the two of the on-ramps just got increased from 1 to 2 lanes.

Taylorsville Tertiary and Significant Residential Roads
Road Name(s) First/Last Link(s) Current highway= UDOT Classification Speed Limit Lanes Significant Landmarks/Access Priority Access Priority Inside Block
4000 West/4015 West tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 3+* Minor north/south access, Bangerter Hwy alternative YES YES
2200 West (South from 6200 S) tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 2 Minor north/south access YES YES
3200 West tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 2/3 Minor north/south access, Bangerter Hwy alternative YES YES
3600 West tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 2/3 Minor north/south access YES YES
4800 South/Murray Taylorsville Rd tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 3 Minor east/west access over Jordan River YES YES
2200 West (North from 5400 S) tertiary Major Collector 30 mph 2/4 Minor north/south access, connects community college to I-215 YES YES
Canal St/1300 West tertiary Major Collector 30 mph 2 Minor north/south access under I-215 YES YES
Bennion Blvd/6015 South tertiary Major Collector 30 mph 2 Continuation of 6200 S to 1300 W YES YES
UT-292 (Bruin Blvd/Community Blvd) tertiary Minor Collector 25 mph 2/3 Access to/around community college YES YES
1300 West (North from Atherton Dr) tertiary Major Collector 25 mph 2/3 Access through large block YES YES
Atherton Dr (North from 4700 S) tertiary Major Collector 25 mph 2 Access through large block to elementary school YES YES
4200 South tertiary Minor Collector 25 mph 2 Access through large block to elementary school YES YES
Sunstone Blvd + Atherton Dr (South from 4700 S) tertiary** Local 25 mph 3 Access through medium size block to higher density housing PARTIAL YES
1175 West tertiary% Local 25 mph 2 Access through medium block NO NO
Chentelle Dr + Midwest Dr tertiary% Local 25 mph -- Access inside block to Taylorsville Temple PARTIAL NO
Gold Medal Dr tertiary% Local 25 mph 2 Access through standard block NO NO
5600 South + 1900 West unclassified*** Local 25 mph 3 Access inside and behind large shopping plaza. YES YES
Warrior Way/1500 West + 5770 South unclassified Local 25 mph 2 Access through standard block to Walmart, hospital clinic, and high density housing PARTIAL YES
Mantle Ave residential Minor Collector 25 mph 2/-- Access through standard block to elementary school PARTIAL NO
Vixen Way + Fox Hills Dr residential Local 25 mph -- Access through standard block to elementary school PARTIAL NO
4850 South + Huntington Dr residential Local 25 mph -- Access through standard block to elementary school NO NO
Bastille Dr + Sierra Grande Dr residential Local 25 mph -- Access through standard block to elementary school NO YES
Ledgewood Dr residential Local 25 mph 2 Access through standard block NO YES
Ivory Way residential Local 25 mph 2 Access through standard block, interrupted by stop sign NO YES

Note: -- for lanes indicates there are no painted lines

%: I disagree with the current highway= value. These 3 roads have more in common with what are all currently residential roads than the rest of the tertiary roads.

*Traffic from 4015 W to 5400 S is busy enough that it has a 1000 ft additional turn lane

**I'm torn on whether this road should be tertiary, as construction has started September 2024 to build nicer than standard bus stops for an improved bus line, which increases its relative importance, as almost no buses run on residential roads.

***While these roads look like good candidates for tertiary, something feels wrong to me about upgrading a road that just connects shops to other shops over a short distance

Murray

Murray Primary and Secondary Roads
Road Name(s) First/Last Link(s) Current highway= UDOT Classification Speed Limit Lanes Significant Landmarks/Access
4500 South primary Principal Arterial 45/40 mph 7 Major east/west access
5300 South/5400 South (West of State St) primary Principal Arterial 40/50 mph 5/7 Major east/west access
State St primary Principal Arterial 40 mph 7 Major north/south access
900 East (South of Van Winkle Expy) primary Principal Arterial 45 mph 5 Major north/south access
700 East/Van Winkle Expy primary Principal Arterial 45/50 mph 5/7 Major north/south access
Winchester St (between State St and Fashion Blvd) primary Minor Arterial 40 mph 6 Connector for split freeway interchange
6600 South (between 900 E and Union Park Ave) primary Minor Arterial 40 mph 5 Connector for two primary roads and freeway interchange
5300 South -> Vine St -> 5600 South secondary Minor Arterial 30/35 mph 3 Minor east/west access
5900 South between State St and 900 E secondary Major Collector 30 mph 3 Minor east/west access*
Winchester St/6600 South (except for parts above) secondary Minor Arterial/Major Collector 35/40 mph 2-5 Major east/west access, including over/under Jordan River, freight rails, I-15, and I-215
500 East/Murray Boulevard/700 East secondary Major Collector 35 mph 2/3 Minor north/south access, including over I-215
1300 East secondary Minor Arterial 40 mph 5 Major north/south access

*OSM currently downgrades this road to tertiary past 900 E, but UDOT keeps it as a Major Collector until Van Winkle Expy (~2000 E)

Taylorsville Tertiary and Significant Residential Roads
Road Name(s) Current highway= UDOT Classification Speed Limit Lanes Significant Landmarks/Access Priority Access Priority Inside Block
5600 S (between State St and Vine St) tertiary Minor Arterial 30 mph 3
1300 West tertiary Major Collector 40 mph 5
Main St tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 3
Cottonwood St tertiary Major Collector 35 mph 2/3/5
4800 S/Murray Taylorsville Road tertiary Major Collector 35/30 mph 3/2
Vine St (between Murray Blvd and 5300 S) tertiary Major Collector/Local 30/35 mph 2/3/4/5
5900 S (between 700 W and State St) tertiary Major Collector 30 mph 2
Vine St (between 5600 S and Van Winkle Expy) tertiary Major Collector 30/35 mph 2/3
Commerce Dr tertiary Major Collector 30/35 mph 2/3
Fashion Blvd tertiary Major Collector 30 mph 3/5
725 East/700 East tertiary Major Collector 25 mph 2
6400 South tertiary Minor Collector 35 mph 2
Atwood Blvd tertiary Minor Collector/Local 25 mph 2
6100 South (west of State St) tertiary Local 40 mph 3
Woodoak Lane (between Vine St and 900 E) tertiary Local 30 mph 3
Murray Parkway Ave tertiary Local 30 mph 2
Glendon St -> Vine St (West of Murray Blvd) tertiary Local 25 mph 2
5800 S + Bullion St tertiary Local 25 mph 2
Anderson Ave (west of 700 W) -> 800 West (north of Anderson Ave) tertiary Local 25 mph 2