User:JeroenHoek

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Below is a collection of tag-values I have started using and would like to present to a broader audience. Because all of these are new (or adopted) values for existing keys, I am wondering if formal proposals are needed, or if documentation on the wiki will suffice.

cycleway=link

Analogous to footway=link, cycleway=link marks bits of cycleway that are needed to connect cycling paths to the rest of the road network, but which are not represented by a direct physical presence (e.g., lines, barriers, or signs). Explicitly marking these 'virtual' bits of cycleway with cycleway=link lets other mappers know the function of these ways, and provides renderers with the possibility to de-emphasize or otherwise render these in a slightly different manner.

Example

The cycleways on both sides of the road going East from the crossroad (shown in purple) are separated from the main road by a low barrier, and mapped separately. At the crossroads, these parallel cycleways end, and cyclists continue their way on the residential roads going North, West, and South. The red ways in this JOSM screenshot are typical examples of bits of cycleway linkage, and are tagged with cycleway=link. They connect the cycleways to the residential roads, but no markings appear on the road surface. Conversely, the purple parallel cycleways are explicitly marked by a barrier separating them from the main road, traffic signs for cycleways, and a reddish surface.

Example of cycleway=link in JOSM

footway=alley

Analogous to highway=service combined with service=alley, this tag adds the same 'alley' semantics to a highway=footway. Marking footways as 'alleys' allows mappers to indicate that a mapped footway has a primarily utilitarian function. This offers the following benefits:

  • Routing software can penalize these ways more heavily than normal footways. 'alley'-like footways may be used as shortcuts when no more suitable way is available, but in general are less suited to through-traffic.
  • Renderers may de-emphasize these footways to declutter the map.
  • It helps other mappers understand the nature of these footways.

Typical example of 'alley'-like footways are the narrow footways that give onto the backs of residential properties.

Note that this tag does not replace access=* tags. an 'alley'-like footway can be access=private or have no legal limits on access at all. footway=alley implies nothing about its access=* status.

Additional documentation

Add documentation to highway=footway about footway=alley and similarly utilitarian footway-values for routers to consider penalizing these to nudge routes towards more suitable paths.

TODO: Add photographs illustrating examples. Examples of when not use this tag.