User:Phobie

Phobie submits data to OpenStreetMap under the name phobie-odbl.

Contents 1 User phobie 2 Copyright 2.1 OSMF License Change 3 My tagging proposals 3.1 maxspeed values 3.2 access namespace 3.3 addr namespace 3.4 contact namespace 3.5 Railways 3.6 Foot- and Cycleways (Rad- und Wanderwege) 3.6.1 Bike/foot informations on the street 3.6.2 Bike/foot informations on separate line 3.7 Roundabout (Kreisverkehr) 3.8 general tagging help 4 Links 5 Software 6 OSM-Wiki Links 7 External Links 8 Map services 8.1 Template:MapLinks 8.2 unlinkable 8.3 misc

User phobie

phobie lives in Schleswig-Holstein, Germany and contributes to OSM since 2007.

Sources for GPS-traces:

• NMEALogger on a TomTom One of the 4th generation
• Openmoko on a Neo Freerunner.
• Nokia N900

Show uploaded GPS-Traces of phobie (Only a very small part of my traces have been uploaded to OSM because of privacy concerns)

Send message to phobie

Copyright

• Aerial photography, cock fighting and vodka bottles

OSMF License Change

Während die Rechteabtretung an die OSMF eine gute Idee zu sein scheint, gibt es doch einige "Unschönheiten":

• Die OSM.org CTs sind inkompatibel zur ODbL! Man darf also keine Daten aus ODbL Quellen zu OSM.org hochladen. Man darf nur Public Domain Daten oder Daten, die Speziell für die Verwendung auf OSM.org freigegeben wurden, verwenden. Da sich OSM.org über die CTs die Veröffentlichung der OSM-Daten unter Public Domain vorbehält, muss jeder Datenspender damit rechnen, das seine Daten irgendwann ohne Copyleft angeboten werden.
• Durch den vollständigen Vollzug der geplanten Lizenzänderung wird es zu massivem Datenverlust und/oder Urheberrechtsverletzungen kommen. Statistiken dazu beziehen sich immer nur auf die neuste Revision eines Elements, es müssen aber alle Elemente gelöscht werden, bei denen sich in irgendeiner Revision ein Username befindet der gegen die Relizenzierung ist oder nicht reagiert hat. Bei kopierten Objekten, lässt sich teilweise gar nicht feststellen auf welchen Objekten sie beruhen.
• Wenn man beim Editieren CC-BY-SA Quellen verwendet hat, dann darf man seine Daten nicht unter der ODbL relizenzieren!
• Der Relizenzierungsprozess ist nicht mit dem rechtlich sauber durchgeführten Lizenzwechsel der Wikipedia vergleichbar!
• In der Entscheidungsfindung und der anschließenden Abstimmung, die die OSMF alleine vorgenommen hat, hätte die Community mit eingebunden werden müssen. Die in den neuen Mitmachbedingungen genannte 2/3 Mehrheit unter den aktiven Mappern, hätte der Entscheidung zur Lizenzänderung Rückhalt in der Community gegeben.
• ODbL == "Public Domain" - Dadurch, dass unter der ODbL Kacheln nicht lizenzgebunden sind, kann man durch automatisiertes Rendern und anschließendes tracen, die Lizenz komplett abstreifen. So ist es mit einigem technischen Aufwand möglich einen lizenzfreie 1zu1-Kopie der OSM-Datenbank anzufertigen! (Diese Aussage ist umstritten. Endgültige Sicherheit würde nur ein Gerichtsprozess bringen, aber auch nur für das jeweilige Land.)
• Mit dem Lizenzwechsel wurden gleichzeitig die Regeln in Bezug auf die Verwendung von Kacheln gelockert. Das wäre nicht nötig gewesen! Jetzt kann es passieren, das ich keine Rechte an Karten habe, die aus von mir erstellten Daten erzeugten wurden!
• OSMF kann aufgrund ihrer Größe und Aufnahmebedingungen problemlos infiltriert werden. Gerade für Kartenfirmen ist die einfache Einflussnahmemöglichkeit reizvoll. (Eine Verschwörungstheorie, im Auge behalten sollte man es aber dennoch!)

My tagging proposals

maxspeed values

Use implicit values in maxspeed: maxspeed=<country code>:[urban|rural|motorway]! It has been proposed to use source:maxspeed=*, but it will not always be tagged and that we will have many maxspeed-values without source:maxspeed. Also source* is used for free text comments about the used sources, not for real tags. Think about the mantra of tagging what you see and not what you interpret! Seeing traffic_sign=city_limit and interpreting maxspeed=50 from it, is more than a mapper should do.

access namespace

Prefix sub-keys from Key:access with 'access:'

• access:bicycle=no instead of bicycle=no

This could make parsing easier and avoid unclear interpretation. I do not use this yet because it would be a major change like renaming 'highway' to 'street'.

addr namespace

• Use the addr:* namespace
  • addr:postcode=* instead of postal_code=*
  • addr:housenumber=<number> - As single node or on the main entrance of a building
  • addr:interpolation=odd/even/all - As a virtual way to interpolate between housenumbers.
  • Relation collection, street or associatedStreet - Relation between street and housenumbers. They are all different names for the same thing, I would prefer collection and street because associatedStreet is a more difficult word.
  • See also: Proposed_features/House_numbers/Karlsruhe_Schema

contact namespace

• Use the contact:* namespace
  • contact:website=* instead of website=* or url=* (url cam mean everything so it is a no-go)
  • contact:phone=* instead phone=*
  • contact:fax=*
  • contact:email=*

Railways

• railway=switch + control=manual;local/manual;remote/automatic;remote
• railway=derail + control=manual;local/manual;remote/automatic;remote - (Gleissperre)

Foot- and Cycleways (Rad- und Wanderwege)

Tag street escorting Cycle- and footways as separate line if:

• if is separated by grass verge or parking places or
• if you have very accurate sources or
• if traffic routing differs from the street

Bike/foot informations on the street

Key	Value	Note
footway[:left|:right]	[track|lane|no|yes]	Try to avoid yes and specify track or lane. Do not use cycleway=both/left/right as we do not have a separate key to store track vs. lane.
cycleway[:left|:right]	[track|lane|no|yes]	Try to avoid yes and specify track or lane. Do not use cycleway=both/left/right as we do not have a separate key to store track vs. lane. Do not use opposite here as we have oneway:bicycle=*.
cycleway[:left|:right]:oneway	[no|yes]	This should always be tagged as we do not have reasonable defaults.

Bike/foot informations on separate line

• highway=cycleway/footway - like with other highway=*-values tag it by condition and not by right of way, use access=* for right of way. Do not use highway=path, it is useless and not well supported.
• oneway=yes/no - always set this tag as we do not have a usable default value
• surface=* - it is always good to know the surface type
• sac_scale=* - only for demanding foootways
• smoothness=* - as mtb:scale=* is only for demanding ways and we do not have a bike_scale yet

Roundabout (Kreisverkehr)

• junction=roundabout instead of highway=roundabout - does not interfere with the street type

general tagging help

• Map Features ENG GER - common tags explained {Erklerungen zu verbreiteten Tags}
• Road Signs ENG GER - list of signs and how to tag them {Liste von Straßenschildern und wie man sie tagged}
• Howto_Map GER - Like Map_Features but sorted by name {Wie Map_Features nur nach Namen sortiert}
• Proposed_features/barriers - better than using "gate" {Poller anstatt Tor}
• GpsDrive naming scheme {Wie GpsDrive Tags nutzt}
• Key:highway ENG GER - The main tag for streets {Der Wichtigste Tag zum beschreiben von Straßen}
• User:Florianheer - some ideas about tagging {Ein paar Ideen zum Taggen}
• Key:access ENG GER - how to set the access of streets {Benutzungsbedingungen/Verbote}

Links

• List of OSM based Services

• Recent OSM changes around: Lübeck - Kiel

Software

• Navit - Routing software
• GpsDrive - Routing software
• Gosmore
• Kosmos - OSM-Renderer, Windows, DotNet
• Viking GPS data editor and analyzer

OSM-Wiki Links

• De:Germany_roads_tagging - how to tag roads in Germany
• WikiProject_Germany
• B   76  30452 relation^edit and way^edit
• B 202  30453 relation^edit and way^edit
• B 502  49630 relation^edit and way^edit
• Kiel Stadtgrenze  27021 relation^edit
• Plön Kreisgrenze  27026 relation^edit
• Kiel Buslines 2  50560 relation^edit
• Buslines in Kiel relation^edit (buggy)

External Links

• Waycheck by Gary68 (gary68.de)
• Tagwatch by stoecker.eu (stoecker.eu)
• Tagwatch, all used Tags in Germany (stoecker.eu)
• Tagwatch etricceline.de (etricceline.de)
• Tagproposals of GPSdrive (gpsdrive.de)
• relation browser (schunterscouts.de)
• OpenRoutingService (openrouteservice.org)
• OSM history at geofabrik (geofabrik.de)
• Downloadsite for worlddumps (openstreetmap.org)
• Splitted worlddumps by geofabrik (geofabrik.de)
• Waycheck Schleswig-Holstein (gary68.de)

Map services

Template:MapLinks

Map-Links for Lübeck (latitude 53.8966, longitude 10.7487, zoom 12):

• General OSM Maps
  • Mapnik (OSM)
  • Osmarender (OSM) at informationfreeway
  • OpenStreetBrowser
  • OpenLinkMap (minzoom=14)
  • OpenOrienteeringMap(minzoom=15)
  • Cycle Map (OSM) at OpenCycleMap
  • Hike & Bike Map
  • NoName (OSM)
  • OpenAerialMap
  • CloudMade Web (OSM)
  • CloudMade Mobile (OSM)
  • Information Freeway (OSM)
  • CloudMade NoNames (OSM)
  • KosmosMap (OSM)
  • Wikipedia (OSM)
  • OpenSeaMap (OSM) FreieTonne Waterway Map (OSM)
  • Mobile Map (OSM)
  • OSM WMS Europe
  • MapSurfer (Road)
  • MapSurfer (Topo)
  • Address map (OSM)
  • Blitzermap - Traffic enforcement map (minzoom=11)
  • Surveillance map
• Quality assurance
  • ITO Map
  • wheelmap
  • OSM Keepright
  • OpenStreetBugs (OSM))
  • Geofabrik Inspector (OSM)
  • maxspeed map (minzoom=13)
  • maxspeed map 2
  • Sautter transparent overlay (multi)
  • Sautter clone
  • GeoTopf Map selector (multi)
  • OSM/Google side-by-side compare (multi)
  • TileChache demo (multi)
  • Google (multi)
  • Flash Teleatlas overlay
  • Topography Rinding and wandering Map Topography Map with overlay
  • geofabrik tools map (OSM)
• Local Maps
  • German Public transport (OSM)
  • Slovakia (OSM)
  • Netherlands (OSM)
  • OpenPisteMap - snow rutes in the alps (OSM)
  • OpenWhitewaterMap - rafting (OSM)
• Routing
  • OpenRouteService (OSM)
  • OpenStreetMap routing service (OSM)
• Aerial photos
  • Multimap Aerial
  • Yahoo Satellite
  • Google Satellite
  • Bing Aerial (incompatible)
• NON-OSM-Maps
  • Yahoo Maps (Navtech)
  • Microsoft Multimap (Teleatlas)
  • GoYellow (Teleatlas)
  • Google Maps (Teleatlas)
• Unlinkable
  • OsmTransport map

edit

Map-Links for Kiel (latitude 54.31066, longitude 10.14553, zoom 12):

• General OSM Maps
  • Mapnik (OSM)
  • Osmarender (OSM) at informationfreeway
  • OpenStreetBrowser
  • OpenLinkMap (minzoom=14)
  • OpenOrienteeringMap(minzoom=15)
  • Cycle Map (OSM) at OpenCycleMap
  • Hike & Bike Map
  • NoName (OSM)
  • OpenAerialMap
  • CloudMade Web (OSM)
  • CloudMade Mobile (OSM)
  • Information Freeway (OSM)
  • CloudMade NoNames (OSM)
  • KosmosMap (OSM)
  • Wikipedia (OSM)
  • OpenSeaMap (OSM) FreieTonne Waterway Map (OSM)
  • Mobile Map (OSM)
  • OSM WMS Europe
  • MapSurfer (Road)
  • MapSurfer (Topo)
  • Address map (OSM)
  • Blitzermap - Traffic enforcement map (minzoom=11)
  • Surveillance map
• Quality assurance
  • ITO Map
  • wheelmap
  • OSM Keepright
  • OpenStreetBugs (OSM))
  • Geofabrik Inspector (OSM)
  • maxspeed map (minzoom=13)
  • maxspeed map 2
  • Sautter transparent overlay (multi)
  • Sautter clone
  • GeoTopf Map selector (multi)
  • OSM/Google side-by-side compare (multi)
  • TileChache demo (multi)
  • Google (multi)
  • Flash Teleatlas overlay
  • Topography Rinding and wandering Map Topography Map with overlay
  • geofabrik tools map (OSM)
• Local Maps
  • German Public transport (OSM)
  • Slovakia (OSM)
  • Netherlands (OSM)
  • OpenPisteMap - snow rutes in the alps (OSM)
  • OpenWhitewaterMap - rafting (OSM)
• Routing
  • OpenRouteService (OSM)
  • OpenStreetMap routing service (OSM)
• Aerial photos
  • Multimap Aerial
  • Yahoo Satellite
  • Google Satellite
  • Bing Aerial (incompatible)
• NON-OSM-Maps
  • Yahoo Maps (Navtech)
  • Microsoft Multimap (Teleatlas)
  • GoYellow (Teleatlas)
  • Google Maps (Teleatlas)
• Unlinkable
  • OsmTransport map

edit

unlinkable

• tracks4bikers routing (OSM)
• Microsoft live (Navtech)
• suchen.de (Navtech)
• NL maxspeedmap
• maps-for-free.com

misc

• osm bbox link

In addition to the CC-by-sa license, this user has granted (or hereby grants) permission to copy, distribute and/or modify all its contributions to OpenStreetMap under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation.