Proposal:Emergency access & exits
(Redirected from Proposed features/emergency access & exits)
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
emergency access & exits | |
---|---|
Proposal status: | Proposed (under way) |
Proposed by: | Push-f |
Draft started: | 2022-06-20 |
RFC start: | 2022-06-20 |
emergency=yes | emergency=no | emergency=designated | entrance=emergency | exit=emergency |
Proposal
- Formalize emergency=yes/no to indicate the usability of roads/paths to emergency vehicles, as described in #emergency=yes/no.
- Deprecate emergency=yes/no for hospitals in favor of emergencies=yes/no, as described in #emergencies.
- To do: What about emergency=designated?
- Deprecate the highly misleading entrance=emergency (which was approved to indicate emergency exits) in favor of exit=emergency.
To do: How should entrances specifically intended for emergency services be tagged?
Rationale
This proposal:
- formalizes two not yet formalized tags (emergency=yes & emergency=no)
- deprecates the secondary meaning of emergency=yes/no for hospitals by establishing a dedicated tag (#emergencies)
- deprecates the highly misleading entrance=emergency
Tagging
emergency=yes/no
- emergency=yes indicates that customary emergency vehicles can use a road or path (tagged with highway=*).
This requires the following:- the way must physically allow passage for customary emergency vehicles regarding their width, height and weight
- if there are any barriers along the way, they must be passable for customary emergency vehicles
- emergency=no indicates that any of these requirements are not met (that is customary emergency vehicles cannot use the road or path).
Note that:
- Both of these tags should only be used on a way tagged as a road or path (as per highway=*).
- The specific type of road or path does not change the meaning of these tags. E.g. emergency=yes still means that emergency motor vehicles can use the way if it is tagged with highway=footway or highway=cycleway.
- Neither of these tags implies anything about access=*. If the element is reserved for emergency services (i.e. may not be accessed by regular citizens), you should additionally add access=no or access=private.
- Emergency services are not restricted by legal access restrictions such as access=* or vehicle=*.
emergencies
emergencies[1] is used to indicate whether a hospital (amenity=hospital or healthcare=hospital) is equipped to deal with emergencies:
- emergencies=yes - the hospital is equipped to deal with emergencies
- emergencies=no - the hospital is not equipped to deal with emergencies
- ↑ The key name is of course up to debate. emergency_room=* is currently used about 50 times. Given the approved emergency=emergency_ward_entrance tag emergency_ward=* would perhaps be even more consistent with the established tags. However such a tag seems to be a bit misleading since a hospital probably has multiple emergency rooms/wards, so naming the tag "emergencies" (as in does the hospital handle "emergencies"?) seems to be preferable.
Features/Pages affected
- key:emergency (tag:emergency=yes, tag:emergency=no, tag:emergency=designated)
- key:emergencies (tag:emergencies=yes, key:emergencies=no)
- key:entrance (tag:entrance=emergency)
- tag:service=emergency_access
- tag:exit=emergency
External discussions
Comments
Please comment on the discussion page.