Automated edits/marc marc

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search


purge related to wheelchair=unknown

Proposal delete wheelchair=unknown toilets:wheelchair=unknown and wheelchair_toilet=unknown
Rationale - Without a wheelchair or toilets:wheelchair tag, accessibility of a poi or toilets of a poi is already unknown as as stated explicitly on toilets:wheelchair=*.
- It was also a bug on wheelpmap.org that added the unknown status when a user did not fill in all the fields or change the previous value. This bug seems fixed because I haven't seen a recent case. EDIT: another bug was found.
- In Iraq/Saudi Arabia, some are also due to a 7 years old undocumented import.
- Some mappers also reported to me that they filled "all tags" with the unknown value because their editor proposed a lot of field and they didn't know what to put.
Frequency Once I hope. Regularly if needed
Talk talk have been splitted at the country level for the most affected countries, which represent the majority of the objects concerned.

talk on talk-de (Germany mailing) , no opposition.
talk on talk-fr (French mailing) and #osm-fr, no opposition.
talk on talk-at (Austria mailing) , no opposition.
talk on talk-ch (Switzerland mailing) , no opposition.
talk on tagging (after the beginning of this ae).

Areas affected World.
Outcome delete wheelchair=unknown toilets:wheelchair=unknown and wheelchair_toilet=unknown
Status Done
Changeset(s) 54716666 (achavi, OSMLab) 54982437 (achavi, OSMLab) 55022835 (achavi, OSMLab) 55979006 (achavi, OSMLab) 56007122 (achavi, OSMLab) 56043162 (achavi, OSMLab) 56062865 (achavi, OSMLab) 56132274 (achavi, OSMLab) 56134198 (achavi, OSMLab) 56147022 (achavi, OSMLab)

harmonization related to toilets:wheelchair

Proposal change wheelchair_toilet and wheelchair:toilets to toilets:wheelchair=*
Rationale wheelchair_toilet was the old tag before the approved features toilets:wheelchair 4 years ago.

wheelchair:toilets was a typo on the German page (it has wheelchair:toilets and toilets:wheelchair)
all apps and sites I have check are using toilets:wheelchair or are broken but some datas have not yet been migrated

Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected World.
Talk talk have been splitted at the country level for the most affected countries, which represent the majority of the objects concerned.

talk on talk-de (Germany mailing) , no opposition.
talk on talk-fr (French mailing) and #osm-fr, no opposition.
talk on talk-at (Austria mailing) , no opposition.
talk on talk-ch (Switzerland mailing) , no opposition.
talk on the german wiki page, no opposition, another mapper fix the error there.

Outcome Create tag toilets:wheelchair=* (if it didn't exist yet) with the current value of wheelchair_toilet or wheelchair:toilets

Tag wheelchair_toilet and wheelchair:toilets deleted.

Status Done
Changeset(s) 54853697 (achavi, OSMLab) 54954247 (achavi, OSMLab) 54969523 (achavi, OSMLab) 54969686 (achavi, OSMLab) 54969753 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970092 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970206 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970336 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970497 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970517 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970586 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970636 (achavi, OSMLab) 54970682 (achavi, OSMLab) 55275539 (achavi, OSMLab) 55275920 (achavi, OSMLab) 55276301 (achavi, OSMLab) 55276317 (achavi, OSMLab)

harmonization related to roof:direction

Proposal change roof:slope:direction to roof:direction=*
Rationale both tags have the same meaning.

The most common tag is documented on the wiki. the other one doesn't.
It is therefore useful to change the undocumented and least-used tag in favour of the documented and most-used one.

Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected World
Talk talk on tagging and forum , no opposition.
Outcome Create tag roof:direction=* (if it didn't exist yet) with the current value of roof:slope:direction

Tag roof:slope:direction deleted.

Status Done
Changeset(s) part 1 : 56277877 (achavi, OSMLab) 56476192 (achavi, OSMLab) 56476241 (achavi, OSMLab)

booking-reservation

Proposal change booking=yes|required|no|recommended|only to reservation=*
Rationale in 2018, a contributor created a wiki page for the page booking=*. documented values are exactly the same as the reservation key.

the community discussion led to the use of reservation.
my proposal does NOT concern the other meanings present in this key (url booking, phone number)

Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected World
Talk talk, no opposition.
Outcome Create tag reservation=* (if it didn't exist yet) with the current value of booking

Tag booking deleted.

Status Done
Changeset(s) 98396042 (achavi, OSMLab) 98396192 (achavi, OSMLab) 56476241 (achavi, OSMLab) 98396255 (achavi, OSMLab) 98396327 (achavi, OSMLab) 98396411 (achavi, OSMLab) 98396459 (achavi, OSMLab)

wood

Proposal convert wood=deciduous into leaf_cycle=deciduous, wood=coniferous into leaf_type=needleleaved, wood=mixed into leaf_type=mixed or delete wood=* if the new key is already set with the same value
Rationale in fact, the key wood=* has been replaced by leaf_cycle/leaf_type
Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected Belgium
Talk Announcement made on #osmbe:matrix.org and ml talk-be, no opposition
Status Done
Changeset(s) 125788763 (achavi, OSMLab)

sidewalk-none

Proposal convert sidewalk=none into sidewalk=no
Rationale due to a (fixed) StreetComplete bug and mimicry, the value no is the documented in the wiki and used by iD/Josm/SC. It is also consistent with osm's practice of using no as a negative value. it is also the most common before this EA
Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected Belgium
Talk Announcement made on #osmbe:matrix.org, no opposition
Status Done
Changeset(s) 134195808 (achavi, OSMLab)

pipeline-marker

Proposal convert pipeline=marker into marker=yes + subject=pipeline
Rationale in fact, the old key has been replaced by the new key. many tags for the same meaning make a part of them unused by existing tools and only brings confusion. the new scheme also allows a separation of 2 different pieces of information in 2 keys
Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected Belgium
Talk Announcement made on #osmbe:matrix.org, no opposition
Status Done
Changeset(s) 134881503 (achavi, OSMLab)

parking-lane-parking-condition

Proposal convert parking:lane and parking:condition into the new Street_parking schema
Rationale many tags for the same meaning make a part of them unused by existing tools and only brings confusion. the new scheme also allows each category of information to be stored in its own key by factoring the usual keys prefixed by parking:
Frequency Regularly if needed
Areas affected Belgium
Talk Announcement made on #osmbe:matrix.org, no opposition
Status in progress
Changeset(s) 136520094 (achavi, OSMLab)