Talk:Tag:landuse=farmland

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Individual Fields

With the announcement yesterday that SteveC has joined Bing Maps and that their imagery will become available for tracing, I started wondering about adding field boundaries near here when the imagery becomes available. These are my thoughts on mapping individual fields:

  • From the imagery, tag as many of the field boundary ways as possible with barrier=hedge/barrier=ditch/barrier=fence (or whatever, as appropriate).
  • Complete the field "boundary" with untagged ways, to form a closed area, with barrier=gate nodes if appropriate (possibly can't be determined from imagery).
  • Use a multipolygon relation tagged as landuse=farmland with the boundary ways as the members, role outer.
  • If the field has a name that you know (or have compatible source for) that tag can also go on the relation as name=*

Thoughts or comments? I'll test the above on a few fields once the imagery becomes available and see how it goes. --EdLoach 09:21, 24 November 2010 (UTC)

Further suggestions received - one large landuse=farmland area with barrier=* ways on top. May be simpler. --EdLoach 09:40, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


Redirected to landuse=farm

This page is redirected to landuse=farm. Maybe that's not the best thing, but in September somebody got rid of the redirect and copied the exact contents of Tag:landuse=farm here instead. That's pretty silly given that this content includes an explanation of why landuse=farmland is not the best tag to use.

For now I've put back the redirect, but maybe it should have explanatory content similar to the Farm page on here

-- Harry Wood 13:45, 22 February 2011 (UTC)

I'm amazed at how old this is. Either way, I'm copying the content Tag:landuse=farm over here, as it is already so edited as to only point to the usage of Tag:landuse=farmland. I'll try to edit the contents to deprecate Tag:landuse=farm. Messy Unicorn (talk) 08:54, 28 September 2014 (UTC)
Yes I see what you have done, but can explain why you are doing it?
Amazed at how old what is? Ye olde tale of the landuse=farmland tag? Here's another old discussion: What's wrong with landuse=farm?. ...still no answer to that question.
-- Harry Wood (talk) 00:53, 6 October 2014 (UTC)