GPS device reviews

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
GPS Satellite NASA art-iif.jpg
A good way to get involved in the OpenStreetMap project is to upload GNSS (GPS, Galileo, GLONASS, BeiDou/COMPASS, etc.) traces. Recorded by your satellite receiver or mobile phone, the typical trace is a record of your location every second, or every meter (“tracelog”). Convert it to GPX format if it wasn't done for you automatically. The collected data can be displayed as a background of thin lines or little dots within the map editor. These lines and dots can then be used to help you add map features (such as roads and footpaths), similar to tracing from aerial imagery.
Record tracelog Convert Modify Upload Accuracy Device reviews

Thinking of getting a GPS receiver to add data to OSM? These reviews are here to help. If you think about other mapping related hardware too, look at the Hardware Guide.

If you buy a GPS unit via any of our retail partners then up to 10% of the purchase price will be donated to OpenStreetMap. This helps to help keep our servers running. See the Shop for details.

The correct term is GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System), though the most common system GPS have become the name most people use (if you go to your local shop and ask for a GNSS, the clerk will probably not know what you mean).

Legend for the summary tables

Units are listed alphabetically.

Type can be:

  • Data Logger: the GNSS includes an automatic geographic position logging system with extraction possibility to another electronic device
  • Recreational: the GPS receiver can either simply deliver a geographic position for another device or display it on a simple screen with no navigation facility.
  • Navigator: the GNSS includes a screen with maps and software for turn-by-turn navigation assistance
  • Mobile Phone: the GPS is included in a mobile phone device
  • Smartphone: probably the most abundand GPS device these days
  • Professional GNSS: the GNSS is designated for massive or accurate geographic survey. Many such devices also combines the various GNSS technologies, such as combined GPS/Glonass receivers and evaluate the different carrier signals.

Glonass is also available as a backup/augmentation in some GPS receivers, but at the moment not available as standalone handheld units.

Storage can be:

Internal MultiMedia (MMC) Secure Digital (SD) None
Specify the capacity MMC, or MMC Mobile SD Card, SD Mini, or SD Micro none

Common GPS chipsets are:

  • SiRFStar I, II, IIe, IIe/LP, IIt, III
  • SiRFLoc
  • SiRFXTrac
  • Nemerix
  • RFMD
  • MTK
  • Sony Solution
  • u-Nav + iTrax 3rd Gen
  • Atmel Antaris 4l
  • u-blox
  • Ublox
  • Xemics
  • HP6515 AGPS
  • Skytraq Venus 5
  • Skytraq Venus 6

Methods of DGPS correction / Augmentation can be

  • SBAS (WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS), Beacon, NTRIP, Direct IP, IALA are free services, with various coverage.
  • Spotbeam, Inmarsat, Veripos, HP/XP are semiglobal services but requires licenses and are not likely in handheld units.
  • Corrections can be transmitted as proprietary formats, single station corrections, or 'RTCM' format correction list. Some receivers might use RTCM as identifier for corrections, but the source than is one of the systems mentioned above.

Alternative forms of GNSS are named according to the promoters of the satellite constellations: the existing GPS system properly named, Glonass, Galileo (still in deployment), and BaiDou (COMPASS). On devices equiped with tuners capable of hearing multiple constellations, it may be possible to get more precision and better coverage than what can be done today with just the GPS alone (some newer constellations will provide additional services not limited to one-way geolocating, such as Argos-style emergency signals for search and rescue).

AGPS is an abreviation for Assisted GPS, and is usually an enhancement for GPS-enabled cell phones. It allows receivers quicker startup time, as well as continuing to give positions with weak or missing satellite data.

Connectivity can be achieved by:

WiFi Bluetooth IrDa NFC/RFID USB PS/2 Serial RS232
Wlan.jpg Bluetooth.jpg Irda.gif ))) Usb.png PS 2.png SerialCOM.jpg

GNSS: Global navigation satellite system (GNSS) that can be received. Possible values are

  • GPS
  • GLONASS
  • Galileo
  • Baidou

Measured DRMS accuracy: Horizontal RMS (root mean square, or Distance Root Mean Square, DRMS) deviation of the measured position from the true (or long-term averaged) position. Should be assessed by measuring a point cloud under good visibility conditions for at least several hours. Not to be confused with the DOP accuracy estimation, which may not match the actual obtained accuracy.

Dual-frequency: If the device can use two frequencies for accuracy enhancement, such as E1/E5a for Galileo or L1/L5 for GPS.

Summary table

Brand Name Type release date GPS Chipset No Channel Augmen­tation Data Logging Capacity Storage Connec­tivity Estimated Price Supports DOP GNSS measured DRMS accuracy Dual-frequency
Apple IPhone 3G Smartphone 2008 ? ? 8 GB 8 GB internal Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 200 $ ? GPS 8.3 m[1] no
Bad Elf GPS-2200 Recreational, data logger MTK 66 SBAS, WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS 360,000 (100 hrs at 1 Hz) 64 MiB internal Bluetooth.jpg (to Apple iOS) 150 US$ GPS ? no
ClearEvo EcoDroidGPS Professional GNSS for Android UBLOX M8030 72 SBAS L1 C/A: WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS, GAGAN no no Bluetooth.jpg (tested 6 simultaneous Android phone connections) 85 US$ GPS, GLONASS, Galileo ? no
Columbus V-900 (Mark II) Data Logger, Recreational 2009 MTK MT3339 66 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS 25,000,000 SD Micro max. 4 GiB Bluetooth.jpg 109 € VDOP, HDOP, PDOP GPS ? no
Columbus V-990 (Mark II) Data Logger, Recreational 2009 MTK MT3339 66 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS 25,000,000 SD Micro max. 4 GiB 89 € VDOP, HDOP, PDOP GPS ? no
Garmin eTrex 10 Data Logger, Navigator 2011 MediaTek ? WAAS, EGNOS 10k Internal Usb.png 119 € / $109.99 / £99.99 no GPS, GLONASS ? no
Garmin eTrex 35 touch Data Logger, Navigator 2015 MediaTek ? WAAS, EGNOS 10k, 200 routes, 10000 points, 200 tracks or to SD-card Internal, SD Micro Usb.png 245 $ no GPS, GLONASS ? no
Garmin GPSmap 276Cx Outdoor mapping GPS 2016 ? ? WAAS, EGNOS Internal 8GB SD Micro Usb.pngWlan.jpg 600 US$ ? GPS, GLONASS ? no
Garmin GPSmap 60CSx Outdoor mapping GPS 2007 SiRFstarIII 12 WAAS, EGNOS Internal or up to 4 GiB SD-card (since FW 3.90) SD Micro Usb.png 294.15 US$ (Amazon.com) GPS ? no
Garmin Oregon 300 Outdoor mapping GPS 2008 STM STA2062 "Cartesio" 32 WAAS, EGNOS 850 MiB internal or microSD-card (4 GiB work well) SD Micro Usb.png 300 € (Amazon.com) ? ? no
Garmin Nüvi 205 Navigator 2009 SiRFstarII ? ? no 940 MiB Internal memory and microSD-card SD Micro Usb.png Discont'd no GPS ? no
Garmin Nüvi 760 Navigator 2007 SiRFstarII ? ? Internal 10,000 points SD Card up to 4 GiB Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 300 ~€ GPS ? no
GiSTEQ CD110BT Data Logger 2007 MTK 51 ? internal 150,000 points internal 4 MiB Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 60 GB£~ GPS ? no
Geneq SX Blue II GPS Recreational 2010 ? 10 + 2 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS, GAGAN 0 0 Usb.png SerialCOM.jpg Bluetooth.jpg 1500 € HDOP VDOP PDOP GPS 0.3 m (claimed by manufacturer) no
Geonaute Keymaze 300 (see [1] for OSS driver) Outdoor Mapping GPS 2007 SiRF Star III ? WAAS internal 200 points internal Usb.png 89 ~€ ? ? no
GlobalSat DG-100 Data Logger 2007 SiRF Star III 20 WAAS 60k Internal Usb.png 110 US$ GPS ? no
GlobalSat BT-308 Recreational SiRF Star II e/LP 12 WAAS 0 no Bluetooth.jpg ? ? ?
GlobalSat BT-335 Data Logger, Recreational SiRF Star III 20 WAAS 60k Internal Bluetooth.jpg 80 € ? ? ?
GlobalSat BT-338 Recreational SiRF Star III 20 WAAS, EGNOS 0 no Bluetooth.jpg ? ? ?
GlobalSat BT-359 Recreational SiRF Star III 20 WAAS, EGNOS 0 no Bluetooth.jpg 80 US$ ? ? ?
GlobalSat BT-368 Recreational SiRF Star III 20 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS 0 no Bluetooth.jpg 47 GB£ ? ? ?
GlobalSat BT-821C Recreational Mediatek MT3339 66 WAAS, EGNOS, QZSS, MSAS, GAGAN no no Bluetooth.jpg (charged over 5V DC power jack 4.0mm x 1.7mm Center PLUS) 50 US$ yes GPS ? ?
GlobalSat BR-355 Recreational SiRF Star III e/LP 20 WAAS, EGNOS 0 no Usb.png SerialCOM.jpg 60 US$ ? ? ?
GlobalSat BU-353 Recreational SiRF Star III e/LP 20 WAAS, EGNOS 0 no Usb.png 28-57 GB£ ? ? ?
GlobalSat BR-304 Recreational SiRF Star II e/LP 12 no 0 no PS 2.png SerialCOM.jpg 50 US$ ? ? ?
GlobalSat BR-305 Recreational SiRF Star II e/LP 12 no 0 no PS 2.png 50 US$ ? ? ?
GlobalSat BU-303 Recreational SiRF Star II e/LP 12 no 0 no Usb.png 50 € ? ? ?
GNS GNS 2000 PLUS Recreational; inbuilt battery Mediatek MT3333 99 WAAS, EGNOS, QZSS, MSAS, GAGAN 54k (date/pos every 5s) Internal Bluetooth.jpg (charged over Mini-USB) 96 € yes GPS, GLONASS, Galileo ? ?
Holux GPSport 245 Recreational MTK3318 20 ? 200,000 Internal 4 MiB Usb.png $180 ? ? ?
Holux GPSport 260 Recreational MTK3329 ? ? 160,000 Internal 4 MiB Usb.png $340 ? ? ? ?
Holux M-241+ Data Logger, Recreational MTK MT3333 66 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS 250,000 ? Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 110 € GPS, GLONASS ? ?
Holux RCV-3000 Data Logger MTK MT3333 66 WAAS, EGNOS 250,000 Internal 4MiB Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png(standard USB cable with USB mini-B plug) 83 ~Euros (03/2018, amazon.de) Yes (NMEA output); No (logging to memory) GPS, GLONASS ? ?
Huawei P10 Smartphone 2017 BCM4774 ? ? 64 GB 64 GB internal Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 250 € yes GPS, GLONASS, BaiDou, Galileo 1.7 m[2] no
Huawei Mate 20 Smartphone 2018 ? ? 128 GB 128 GB internal Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 400 € yes GPS, GLONASS, BaiDou, Galileo yes
Magellan eXplorist 510 Data Logger, Navigator ? ? ? ? SD Card Usb.png ? ? ?
Mio Cyclo 605 HC Navigator (Cycle) ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Navilock BT-821G Recreational Mediatek MT3333 99 WAAS, EGNOS, QZSS, MSAS, GAGAN no no Bluetooth.jpg (charged over 5V DC power jack 4.0mm x 1.7mm Center PLUS) 90 € yes GPS, GLONASS ? ?
Navilock NL-8002U GPS receiver module u-blox UBX-M8030 72 WAAS, EGNOS, QZSS, MSAS no no Usb.png 66 € [2] yes GPS, GLONASS, Galileo ? ?
Qstarz BT-Q1000XT Datalogger 2010 MTK II 66 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS 400k, can log 5 Hz GPS: Bluetooth.jpg log: Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png ? GPS ? no
Royaltek RGM-4600]] Recreational 2012 SiRFstarIV 48 no 0 no ? ? no
Samsung Galaxy S5 Smartphone 2014 Qualcomm Snapdragon 801 MSM8974AC ? yes 32 GB 32 GB internal Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 200 € VDOP, HDOP GPS, GLONASS, Baidou 1.7 m[3] no
Samsung Galaxy S7 Smartphone 2016 Qualcomm Snapdragon 820 MSM8996 ? yes 32 GB 32 GB internal Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 300 € VDOP, HDOP GPS, GLONASS, BaiDou 5.1 m[3] no
Solmeta Geotagger Pro2 Data Logger with Compass 2013 MTK MT3339 22 EXIF and internal 2GB internal Nikon Cord 200 US$ ? ? no
Transystem i-Blue 747ProS Data Logger, Recreational 2013 MTK II 66 WAAS, EGNOS, MSAS, AGPS 250k Internal 8 MiB Usb.png 75 € (amazon.de) (~$80 on eBay.com) (2014-03-20) ? GPS ? no
Umax i-gotU GT-120/USB Data Logger 2009 SiRF III 20 WAAS, EGNOS 65,000 Internal Usb.png 45 € no DOP, but EHPE available ? ? no
Ventus G730 Data Logger 2012 SkyTrac Venus 6 65 WAAS, EGNOS 256,000 points Internal Usb.png 45 £ - 60 £ ? ? ? no
Wintec WBT-202 Data Logger 2011 u-blox Antaris 5 18 (tracking), 32 (aquisition) WAAS, EGNOS 260k internal / 134M with 2GB microSD Internal and SD Micro (64 MB-2 GB) Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 109 € (2009-10-24) ? ? no
Xiaomi Mi 8 Smartphone 2018 BCM47755 ? ? 64 GB 64 GB internal Bluetooth.jpg Usb.png 300 € VDOP, HDOP GPS, GLONASS, BaiDou, Galileo 1.0 m[4] yes

See also