Proposal:Man made=guard stone

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
(Redirected from Proposed features/man made=guard stone)
Latest comment: 5 years ago by Ropino in topic Voting
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Archived proposal  –  please don't change the content of this page.

The content of this proposal has been marked as archived to avoid confusion with the current version of the documentation.

To check whether the displayed page corresponds to the version at the time of archiving (end of voting),
the original revision can be accessed here:  original  compare with current


Proposal:Man made=guard stone


man_made=guard stone
Proposal status: Approved (active)
Proposed by: b-unicycling
Tagging: man_made=guard_stone
Applies to: node
Definition: A guard stone is in most cases a stone built onto or into the corner of a building or wall. They are usually found on either side of an entrance to a laneway or gateway. Guard stones may be put alongside a wall to protect it. Many are historical barriers that kept the wheels of carriages from damaging buildings. Some of them bear survey markers such as benchmarks.
Statistics:

Rendered as: hidden
Draft started: 2021-01-05
RFC start: 2021-01-05
Vote start: 2021-01-20
Vote end: 2021-02-05

Proposal

Guard stones or jostle stones are an architectural element and an often overlooked part of street furniture which has historical roots: To avoid collisions (jostling) between the wheels of horse-drawn carriages and the walls on either side of a lane or gateposts, guard stones were placed at entrances and sometimes along walls. Towns with a historic center still feature them. They are not necessarily made of stone, more recent examples are instead made of metal (Brandenburg Gate in Berlin uses decommissioned canons).

Rationale

Many guard stones are part of the historic heritage, feature local materials and are an indicator for the age of a building or street. Furthermore, they are obstacles for visually impaired or intoxicated pedestrians, as the example from Temple Bar shows: Woman who suffered 'minor in the extreme' injuries after pub fall loses €60k claim

Some examples go back to Roman times and they are generally very common in Europe. They differ from bollards in that they do not prevent access for vehicles, but as architectural elements rather protect buildings and in times gone by also vehicles from damage.

The majority of people taking part in the discussion about the objected proposal barrier=guard_stone felt that man_made was the better option, since guard stones do not limit access (in their opinion).

Examples

See Wikimedia for more examples from Northern Ireland, France, Belgium, Germany and other countries.

In other languages

Language word(s) for guard stone
English jostle stone, chasse-roue
German Prellstein, Radabweiser, Kratzstein, Abweichstein, Abweiser, Radstößer
French chasse-roue, chasse-moyeux
Spanish guardacantón
Italian paracarro
Russian Колёсоотбойная тумба
Czech Nnárožní kámen
Dutch schamppaal, schampsteen, boordsteen, stootsteen

Tagging

They would be placed at the corner nodes of buildings, building passages or walls.

man_made=guard_stone

optional: material=

optional: height=*

optional: heritage=yes (only if it is a protected structure by the local heritage office, should come with a ref=*)

(direction=left/right) (Only if they are along a wall which used to be part of a building, but is now a free standing wall, to indicate which side of the wall they are on.)

Applies to

Nodes

Rendering

Features/Pages affected

key:man_made

External discussions

See discussion about objected proposal barrier=guard_stone.

Voting

Voting closed

Voting on this proposal has been closed.

It was approved with 30 votes for, 2 votes against and 2 abstentions.


The change was reverted. Does this change your vote, @Mateusz Konieczny:? --Jeisenbe (talk) 03:54, 22 January 2021 (UTC)
Though I am still against such tagging, row of standalone stone pillars is row of barrier=bollards 14:06, 23 January 2021 (UTC)
  • I approve this proposal I approve this proposal. --Rorym (talk) 11:32, 20 January 2021 (UTC)
  • I oppose this proposal I oppose this proposal. (was yes) This proposal focuses on the urban usage of guard stones. Apparently they have been widely used historically outside of settlements as a kind of barrier on roads with no buildings near them. This example and its historical usage has changed my mind. --11:43, 23 January 2021 (UTC)
I believe those are rows of barrier=bollard --Jeisenbe (talk) 18:46, 23 January 2021 (UTC)
The change was reverted. It appear to have been an honest mistake. Is that enough to change your vote, @Riiga:, @Mueschel: and @Lectrician1:? --Jeisenbe (talk) 03:54, 22 January 2021 (UTC)
Here's an example in Kilkenny, where there are four along a house wall. The driveway/path used to lead to stables, I'm told.B-unicycling (talk) 14:30, 31 January 2021 (UTC)

Comments

Please comment on the discussion page.

Note: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Proposed_features/man_made%3Dguard_stone&curid=260206&diff=2095225&oldid=2095172 added man_made=guard_stone_row during the vote, by the author. This was removed again by another user, because it is against normal procedures: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Proposed_features%2Fman_made%3Dguard_stone&type=revision&diff=2095754&oldid=2095752