Zh-hans:Multilingual names

From OpenStreetMap Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Logo. 要素 : Zh-hans:Multilingual names
One example for 要素 : Zh-hans:Multilingual names
说明
Keys and tags that are used with language postfix
标签

and other tags and their variants

在很多情况下,我们需要处理multilingual names (多语言名称),即一个特征在不同语言中有不同的名称。这在世界主要城市的名称中非常常见。在一些地区,地方和街道的名字都是用所有的当地语言命名的。人们也会想用特定的语言来呈现地图(Map Internationalization)。

Names#Localization is the primary documentation describing how to use Key:name with a language code. People generally agree on using name:code=* where code is a lowercase language's ISO 639-1 alpha2 code (second column), a lowercase ISO 639-2 code if an ISO 639-1 code doesn't exist, or a ISO 639-3 code if neither of those exist. In addition, some cases require to add a script name to the tag according to ISO 15924 name:code-Script=*. Many languages, including widely spoken or written ones, are defined inaccurately or uncoded for in the existing ISO codes, so the tagging necessarily deviates from them where appropriate.

Repeating name with language specific tag

name=* contains the common, default name in the local language. name:<lang_code> is used to tag the name in a specified language in cases where the name differs by language, for example name:ru=Москва gives the city's name in Russsian (language code ru) while name:en=Moscow gives the English language name (language code en).

In cases where multiple languages are tagged for a name, the local-language name tag should be duplicated with the language-specific sub-key. For example, Moscow is tagged with name=Москва, with the same value as name:ru=Москва. This tagging is important because it ensures that data consumers don't need to infer the local language. Guessing name language based on location is unlikely to always succeed - there are places in Russia where name=* is not in Russian, there are places in USA where correctly mapped name=* is not in English.

On the other hand, do not tag names that do not exist. An unremarkable village somewhere in Poland might have only one name (recorded in name=*). In all other languages, this village would be called by its Polish name, because it has no other name. Just because all other languages use the Polish name, you should not add name:<lang_code> tags for all other languages containing the Polish name!

Why?

Tagging both say name=Kraków and name:pl=Kraków is useful especially in case of displaying localized names with fallback languages. If someone would want to

  • display names in Polish
  • in case of Polish name being unavailable, show English name (with "Beijing" being preferred over "北京市")
  • otherwise display name:en=*

In such case the solution would be to

  • display name:pl=*
  • if it is unavailable display name:en=*
  • if both are not present display name=*

But note what would happen if name=* would be in Polish, name:pl=* would be not tagged and name:en=* would be tagged:

  • display name:pl=* - skipped, as not present
  • if it is unavailable display name:en=* - done!
  • if both are not present display name=* - not reached

Alternative would be adding guesses about language of name=* (what is tricky, complicated for many languages and areas impossible, fragile and error-prone).

Or explicitly tagging both name=* and name:<lang_code>.

The Mapbox Directions API, which is powered by Valhalla, is an example of a data consumer that relies on this heuristic. In some regions that have multiple official languages, guidance instructions will include street names and destinations in multiple languages, which is verbose and usually undesirable. But if name=* is accompanied by a matching language-qualified name tag, then the requested language will ensure that only the most relevant language appears in guidance instructions.

Issues

  • what should the plain name=* tag be (local name, at least if not disputed), and how to specify the language that the name tag is in.
  • how to specify transliterations. There is a standard list of transliteration codes. But avoid transliteration except in special cases.
  • Instead one should refer to the international BCP 47 standard for locale tags (and to its associated IANA registry), that allows appending extensions to a base language code, using optional "locale subtags" separated by hyphens ("-"): a 3-letter "extlang" code for dialectal variants (deprecated since ISO 639-3), a standard 4-letter ISO 15924 script code, a 2-letter ISO 3166-1 region code, or a 3-digit UN M.49 region code for international regions. Using region codes should be avoided as much as possible (in most cases it is a script code that should be used instead). Transliteration systems may also be specified if the script code alone is not enough specific and there exists several competing transliteration schemes. These transliteration schemes have standardized codes in Unicode CLDR data, that defines its own extensions of locale subtags for BCP 47. The BCP 47 standard is also normatively referenced and used (instead of ISO 639 which has issues in terms of stability) by all W3C web standards (HTML, CSS, SVG, XML...) and by lot of internationalisation libraries and programming languages (including in C, C++, Java, Javascript in their standard libraries or with ICU).
  • Also avoid using codes used by Wikipedia (or collected in Wikidata in list of Wikipedia articles) for its interwiki links if they are not standard BCP 47 locale tags: their meaning is only to differentiate the Wikipedia editions as they are in fact mapped to valid subdomain names (which are not restricted to be using only BCP 47 locale tags but can be any "word"), or are used in some Wikipedia extensions; most of these non-compliant codes are slowly being phased out and replaced in Wikimedia projects; this includes "en-simple" (use "en" only), "sr-ec" (use "sr-cyrl"), but also some codes which were incorrectly assigned and that represent in fact other languages (such as "nrm" incorrectly used for Norman in Wikipedia). OSM data should not include these imported dirty quirks: replace them by BCP 47 compliant codes (or append "private use" extension subtags defined in BCP 47, for example "en-x-simple" instead of "en-simple" if you really need a distinction from "en" for standard English).
    Note: BCP 47 locale subtags are not case-sensitive (even if they have recommanded casing), and OSM data should use tags with key "name:code" where the code is a complete locale tag compliant to the BCP47 standard, in their preferred form (excluding aliases defined in the IANA registry and deprecated or replaced tags or subtags), but only using lowercase letters (including in locale subtags for scripts and regions).
    Keep uppercase codes used only for naming prefixes or suffixes in region specific tags (that are also independent of the language used): use preferably ISO 3166 codes in this case. For example, Traditional Chinese in Hong Kong is tagged name:zh-Hant-HK=*, not name:zh-hant-hk=*. (Use of the lowercase spellings largely ended in 2018. [1][2])

On this page we give some country by country information particularly regarding the language used in the main 'name' tag. See Exonyms for some examples.

Australia

Australian Aboriginal Languages) can be recorded with their ISO-639-3 suffix (such as name:xwj=* for Whadjuk), or the more generic name:aus=*. For more information, please see the Australian Tagging Guidelines

Bangladesh

While most other countries in OpenStreetMap use the official language for the name=* tag and potentially add name:en=* for an English name, the current standard in Bangladesh is inverted: It is common to use name:bn=* for the Bangla (বাংলা) name, and put the English name in name=*, provided the object has an English name.

This system is currently under discussion and might change in the future. Please refrain from retagging of names to match your preferred scheme.

When adding a name, it is best to look at the actual road signs, placename signs, or shop signs:

  • If something has only a Bangla name: Set name=* to the Bangla name, and optionally add name:bn=* with the same.
  • If something has only an English name: Set name=* to the English name, and optionally add name:en=* with the same.
  • If something has names in both languages: Set name=* to the English name, and optionally add name:en=* with the English and name:bn=* with the Bangla name.

If something already has a name=* tag in either Bangla or English, then please do not change it (unless the name itself is wrong), instead limit yourself to adding name:en=* or name:bn=* as appropriate. This is to avoid edit wars while the community discusses the future tagging scheme.

Bahrain

Signs (including street signs) in Bahrain are written in Arabic and in English, tagging is:
name=شارع القاهرة for Arabic name
name:en=Cairo Street for the English name

name=طارق 25 for Arabic name
name:en=Road 25 for the English name

Belarus

Belarus has two official languages (Belarusian and Russian), Belarusian language has two variants (Classical and Official). As Russian language is used more widely, community decided that the name=* tag value should be in Russian if it exists and make sense. A Russian name value also should be duplicated in name:ru=* tag, Belarusian official should be in name:be=*, Belarusian classical optionally in name:be-tarask=*, int_name=* transliterated from name:be=*.

Belgium

The municipalities with language facilities in Belgium, shaded darker. All of the German area has language facilities. 1. Comines-Warneton 2. Mesen 3. Mouscron 4. Spiere-Helkijn 5. Ronse 6. Flobecq 7. Bever 8. Enghien 9. Drogenbos 10. Linkebeek 11. Sint-Genesius-Rode 12. Wemmel 13. Kraainem 14. Wezembeek-Oppem 15. Herstappe 16. Voeren 17. Malmedy 18. Waimes 19. Lontzen 20. Raeren 21. Eupen 22. Kelmis 23. Burg-Reuland 24. Sankt Vith 25. Amel 26. Bütgenbach 27. Büllingen[1]

Belgium has three official languages (Dutch, French and German) and four language areas (Brussels is considered a separate, bilingual French-Dutch area), see the map.

Brussels

Brussels is completely bilingual, which means that the city council must operate in both languages, and no language can be preferred. The city council solves this f.e. by alternating name signs with Dutch and French as top language.

In OSM, we have a consensus to use a fixed order. Since we refrain from involving politics, it has no further meaning to us than to keep data consistent for human and automated processing. The name=* tag in OSM contains both the French and Dutch name, separated by a spaced hyphen (f.e. name=Rue du Marché aux Poulets - Kiekenmarkt), and the first mapper needs to use the correct order of the names (changing the order of the names afterwards to "nl - fr" is considered vandalism if you are not a beginning mapper). Next to the bilingual name tags, there are also name:fr=* and name:nl=* tags which can be used to render or search the data in a specific language. Make sure to only include 1 spaced hyphen in a street name. Hyphens in street names are never spaced. Knowing this a computer program can easily analyse this data.

A few streets have a name that is absolutely identical in both languages. Needless to say, never concatenate the same name twice (e.g. "Tomberg - Tomberg" makes no sense).

Similar to the name tags, address tags are also bilingual. Every address in Brussels should have the following tags:

Language facilities

Next to the completely bilingual Brussels, there are also municipalities with language facilities (see the map).

These municipalities are supposed to operate in the official language of the community, but must provide services to minority language groups upon request. This means f.e. that all streetnames also have an official translation and are normally signed with the translation too. But there's no language-equality as in Brussels.

These municipalities should have the official translated names under name:nl=*, name:fr=* and name:de=* (depending on which language facilities are offered), the name=* tag should contain only the official name in the primary language. For the moment, the municipalities bordering Brussels also follow the naming schema used in Brussels (with both languages in the name tag), while the other municipalities have a tendency to only include a single language in the name tag. Do not delete translated data by following this rule. If a good translation exists in a dutch municipality in french, do not remove it. We only care for correct data, as much as possible without being intrusive in any way.

Combination with name:left=* and name:right=*

Belgium has many boundaries that follow roads, and different municipalities often opt to give different names to the boundary street, resulting in differing addresses on both sides of the road. These are mapped by adding an addr:left=* and addr:right=* tag to the way.

This becomes even more annoying when one (or both) of the municipalities are bilingual or have language facilities. In these cases, the Belgian community opted to extend the tags to f.e. name:right:fr=*. Note that in these cases, a name:fr=* tag isn't guaranteed to exist, as it's possible that only one side of the street has a translated name. name:left=* and name:right=* should exist in these cases.

Example (way Komenstraat - Chemin des Quatre Rois):

  • name=Komenstraat - Chemin des Quatre Rois (format "fr - nl", see language facilities)
  • name:right=Komenstraat
  • name:left=Chemin des Quatre Rois (format "fr - nl" for Brussels, see language facilities)
  • name:left:fr=Chemin des Quatre Rois
  • name:left:nl=Vier Koningenweg

This tagging scheme is far from a perfect solution, JOSM validator will not let this pass, if you have multiple relation:associatedStreet relations on a single way, JOSM will complain on validation. This is a shortcoming in the tagging scheme for these kind of situations. And there is no appropriate alternative solution at this moment. In Brussels there are quite some streets with this problem. There is probably also not a huge amount of support for name:left:*=* in software at the moment.

Some more BXL examples:

With the problematic common way : way Chaussée de Jette - Jetsesteenweg

Another one:

With the problematic common way here : way Rue de la Grosse Tour - Wollendriestorenstraat (but also the "Rue de la Grosse Tour - Wollendriestoren") (note : lacking straat is correct) At the time of updating this wiki, the name:left:nl=* and name:left:fr=* tags are lacking for all those examples.

About the first mapper rule

Note that the "first mapper rule" is deprecated now. The consensus in the .be community is to address "fr - nl" for all name=* and addr:street=* tags, and include specific languages in subtags. Consistency of data is more important than who came first and what their preferences are. A custom Urbis validation tool is available at github.

Unofficial languages and dialects

Next to the official languages, some dialects can also be added as translations. Do not use loc_name=* for dialects.

In Wallonia, use "name" for the common French name, if you want to complete with the Walloon name, use name:wa=*. For example, for the city of Liège, we use :

name=Liège
name:wa=Lîdje

In West Flanders, name:vls=* is used to mark West-Flemish names. Please stick to the spelling of vls.wikipedia.org when adding translations.

name=Dadizele
name:vls=Deisel

Bulgaria

The official language in Bulgaria is Bulgarian written in Cyrillic.

Road and other signs in Bulgaria are written in Bulgarian and are usually transcribed to the Latin alphabet according to the Bulgarian transliteration law.

  • The geographic terms: планина (mountain), равнина (plain), низина (valley), плато (platteau), град (city), село (village), река (river), езеро (lake), залив (bay) etc., which are part of the geographic name, are generally transliterated as follows: Стара планина Stara planina
    Атанасовско езеро Atanasovsko ezero
  • Geographic terms that are not part of the name, should be translated (here example in English):Нос Емине Cape Emine
  • The terms "северен" (northern), "южен" (southern), "източен" (eastern), "западен" (western), "централен" (central) and similar ones, in case they are part of the geographic name, should be transliterated:Централен Балкан Tsentralen Balkan
    София-юг Sofia-yug
    Перник-север Pernik-sever

Example:

  • name=: name in Bulgarian (бул. Източен)
  • int_name=: transliterated name (bul. Iztochen)
  • name:en= (optional): Iztochen Blvd.

中国

对于中国的一般标签指南,请参阅 Index of China tagging guideline,而不是 Chinese tagging guidelines,后者只是标签指南中的一个部分。

基本规则

  1. 尽量提供多语种的名字。 中国的大多数名字都是用汉字书写的,但是英文版本和拼音版本对外国人来说非常有用。拼音的书写要有重音,否则会与英文名字相同。
  1. Try to give ethnic language name. (in discussion) The name=* in autonomous divisions (of Provincial, Prefectural, or County level; see Wikipedia:Autonomous administrative divisions of China) may be in multiple languages, each separated by a slash. The Mandarin name should be first for sociolinguistic reasons. (Most name tags in such divisions are Mandarin-only for now.) For discussion about this problem, you can refer to [tagging guidelines#Multilingual labeling of ethnic languages]

案例

Normal area Autonomous divisions
name=<Chinese>
name:zh=<Chinese>
name:en=<English>
name:zh_pinyin=<Chinese Pinyin (with tones, compliant with orthography)>
name=<Chinese> or name=<Chinese>/<Local language> (the format is still in discussion)
name:xx=<Local language>
name:zh=<Chinese>
name:en=<English>
name:zh_pinyin=<Chinese Pinyin (with tones, compliant with orthography)>

语言代码规则

What zh means

name:zh=*代表未指定的中文变体。通常情况下,标签中使用的文字是物体所有者、经常使用的用户或该地区的人们所喜欢的文字。换句话说,在中国大陆、马来西亚和新加坡,带有这个标签的大多数对象都是简体中文,而在台湾、香港和澳门的大多数对象则是繁体中文。也会有例外情况。在华语地区以外的地方,此标签的字体一般取决于第一个贡献者的字体偏好,先到先得,因此附近的不同物体在此标签中可能有不同的字体,但尽量不要在每个物体的单一标签中混合不同的字体。有时,当 name:zh=* 包含一个中文变体时,另一个中文变体将存储在 name:zh-Hant=* 和/或 name:zh-Hans=* 分别用于繁体中文和简体中文。否则,如果希望仅用简体中文或繁体中文渲染地图,则可以考虑使用音译,但请注意,截至目前,所有简体中文和繁体中文之间的机器音译都不完全准确,可能会发生错误转换,因为一些繁体字形与多个简体字形分开对应,而也有一些简体字形与多个繁体字形分开对应。

如上所述,某些功能具有诸如 name:zh-Hant=* 和/或 name:zh-Hans=* 之类的键来表示用繁体/简体中文字符编写的名称。不要使用 name:zh-traditional=*name:zh-simplified=*

请注意,简体中文和繁体中文应使用不同的对应字体显示,因为对于某些字符,它们共享相同的Unicode代码点,但在繁体中文和简体中文中表示不同的字形。

有时像 name:zh-CN=*name:zh-HK=*name:zh-MO=*name:zh-SG=* 这样的键,当功能在这些地区的名称与当地中文名称或国际中文名称不相同时,这些键将用于中国(大陆)、香港、澳门、新加坡等不同地区的功能的中文名称。建议将国家/地区代码大写(尽管现在OSM数据库中存在其他变体)。这些标签的值通常包含与它们指示的地区的首选脚本相同的脚本。

A few features have been tagged with keys like name:zh-Hant-CN=* to represent the Chinese name for a region with alternative script.

Romanization(罗马字)

Avoid transliteration except in special cases.

The community has currently settled on name:zh_pinyin=* for labelling pinyin. However, this is not a standard language code (as Pinyin is not a language, only a romanisation system); a better one would be name:zh-Latn-pinyin=*, i.e. "Chinese written in Latin script, specifically the pinyin variant". Do not use name:zh-py=*.

The key name:zh-Latn=* indicates Chinese romanization in general; it could (in theory) include Postal romanisation (obsolete), Wade-Galles romanisation (obsolete), romanisation based on local language variant, or Tongyong pinyin (obsolete). In general, if one want to transliterate Chinese names from Chinese characters into Latin characters for map rendering or other purposes, then one should consider the transliteration standard of the region those characters are being used. Generally they are transliterated using pinyin standard with the Standard Mandarin Chinese pronunciation in Pinyin, allowing for local readings of certain characters. In Hong Kong and Macau, the transliteration should be done using their Cantonese pronunciation.

List of Defined Chinese romanization codes[1]
Romanization/Transliteration system defined code
Pinyin romanization zh-Latn-pinyin
Tongyong Pinyin romanization zh-Latn-tongyong
Wade-Giles romanization zh-Latn-wadegiles
Jyutping Cantonese Romanization yue-Latn-jyutping

Local languages(当地方言)

It is also possible to add local names using the same template name:code if the language has an ISO 639-1, ISO 639-2, or ISO 639-3 code (for example 'yue' for Cantonese). Note that for Mongolian languages, multiple different scripts have been used in the tag for the language, and different scripts require different glyph, also if the script being used is Traditional Mongolian Script then it must be rendered vertically. For Manchu languages when the content is being written in Manchu script, vertical rendering is also necessary.

name:zh-classical=* for Literary Chinese have been deprecated, please use name:lzh=* instead.

name:zh-min-nan=* for Min Nan have been deprecated, please use name:nan=* instead. Do not use name:zh-min=*, use codes for individual Min languages instead.

Name types

All the subkeys mentioned above can combine with all types of different ?_name keys, like alt_name:zh-Hant=*, old_name:zh-CN=*, short_name:yue-Latn=*, etc..

Ethnic language langcode

According to ISO 639-1 and wikipedia, those language of minor ethnic should be tagged with these langcodes

List of Defined Chinese minor ethnic langcodes
Language name (English) Language name (native) langcode
Tibitan བོད་སྐད bo
bo-Latn-tibetanpinyin/zwpy
bo-Latn-wylie
Uyghur ئۇيغۇرچە / ئۇيغۇر تىلى ug
ug-Cyrl
ug-Latn
Mongolian ᠮᠣᠩᠭᠣᠯ ᠬᠡᠯᠡ mn
mn-Cyrl
mn-Mong
mn-Latn
Manchu ᠮᠠᠨᠵᡠ ᡤᡳᠰᡠᠨ mnc(ISO 639-2)
mnc-Latn-moellendorff
Yi ꆈꌠ꒿ ii
ii-Latn
Korean 조선말 ko / ko-CN
Zhuang Vahcuengh za

Translation Rule

Orthography(正词法)

It is strongly recommended to follow the Hanyu Pinyin Orthographic rules (汉语拼音正词法), especially with regard to spacing between words in Pinyin. Adding spaces aid searching and reading.

Other romanization methods should follow their own orthographical rules. If a word-based orthography is not defined, the pinyin method can be used as reference.

Road name(路名)

Road name word order rule
  1. Adj. Later

Typical City: Beijing, most of City in Shandong Province, Changsha and Xiangtan in Hunan.

For road names in the mode of "<special_name><direction><road_type>", such as "解放西路", as a rule, you do not need to advance the <direction> in the English word order, but translate it part by part, and result to "Jiefang West Road"

If <special_name> is named after a mountain or river, such as "黑龙江北路", you don't need to separate mount or river to special name, just use pinyin to instead. For this example you can translate it to "Heilongjiang North Road"

name=朝阳公园南路
name:zh=朝阳公园南路
name:en=Chaoyang Park South Road
name:zh_pinyin=Cháoyánggōngyuán Nánlù
  1. Adj. Before

Typical City: Shanghai

Position words indicating different sections of the same road should be placed in front of the road name, and use English.

Numerals in this type of attribute words are placed after the entire road name.

Attribute words that do not represent different sections of the same road should be transliterated, using pinyin.

name=南京东路
name:zh=南京东路
name:en=East Nanjing Road
name:zh_pinyin=Nánjīng Dōng Lù
name=中山东一路
name:zh=中山东一路
name:en=East Zhongshan Road Number One
name:zh_pinyin=Zhōngshān Dōng Yī Lù
name=南车站路
name:zh=南车站路
name:en=Nanchezhan Road
name:zh_pinyin=Nánchēzhàn Lù
通名标准译名表

For road names, you should follow this dict at first. If some word don't show in this list, refer to official guideline that China government released. However, an indication of 大道 (avenue), 路 (road), etc. is customarily provided. Try to use official translations on the street signs for the English names; if unavailable, refer to the vocabulary in #Taiwan for entries like 巷 and 弄.

应根据路牌上实际表示的英文名称填写,但不要写成诸如“JIE”“LU”之类的汉语拼音。

高速公路/快速路 Expressway
高架路 Elevated Road
公路 Highway
环路 Ring Road
支路 Side Road (北京) / Branch Road (上海) / Access Road (深圳)
辅路 Auxiliary Road / Side Road (深圳)
Road / Street (深圳)
大道 Avenue / Boulevard (深圳)
街/大街 Street
胡同 Hutong
Alley
支弄 Branch Alley
Lane / Alley
Path / Trail (专用于徒步线,如深圳的鲲鹏径:Kunpeng Trail)
支线 Branch

Proprietary and generic name(专名与通名)

Places follow the same convention. The only difference is that Chinese maps add 市,镇,省,县 at the end of the name, so we follow this convention, but do not translate this part in English.

City

place=city
name=自贡市
name:en=Zigong
name:zh=自贡市
name:zh_pinyin=Zìgòng Shì

City with ethnic language

place=city
name=巴林左旗 or name=巴林左旗/ᠪᠠᠭᠠᠷᠢᠨ ᠵᠡᠭᠦᠨ ᠬᠣᠰᠢᠭᠤ
name:zh=巴林左旗
name:mn=ᠪᠠᠭᠠᠷᠢᠨ ᠵᠡᠭᠦᠨ ᠬᠣᠰᠢᠭᠤ
alt_name:mn=ᠪᠠᠭᠠᠷᠢᠨ ᠵᠡᠭᠦᠨ ᠬᠣᠰᠢᠭᠤ;Baɣarin Jegün qosiɣu;Баарин Жэгүн қосиу
name:en=Bairin Left Banner
alt_name=Bairin
name:zh_pinyin=Bālín Zuǒ Qí

Town

place=town
name=淅川县
name:en=Xichuan
name:zh=淅川县
name:zh_pinyin=Xīchuān Xiàn

Town (Single character special name) (Because 杨镇 only have one character in special name)

place=town
name=杨镇
name:en=Yang Zhen
name:zh=杨镇
name:zh_pinyin=Yáng Zhèn

Administrative division

Contrary to places, administrative divisions should retain their full names and suffixes.

type=boundary
boundary=administrative
name=泾县
name:en=Jing County
name:zh=泾县
name:zh_pinyin=Jīng Xiàn
type=boundary
boundary=administrative
name=双江拉祜族佤族布朗族傣族自治县
name:en=Shuangjiang Lahu, Va, Blang and Dai Autonomous County
name:zh=双江拉祜族佤族布朗族傣族自治县
name:zh_pinyin=Shuāngjiāng Lāhùzú Wǎzú Bùlǎngzú Dǎizú Zìzhìxiàn

Croatia

All name=* tags should be in Croatian. Bilingual places are no exception. Italian names should be in name:it=* tags, and Serbian names should be in name:sr=*.

This was decided by vote on our mailing list: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-hr/2013-May/001815.html

Ethiopia

With more than 90 recognized languages, OSM tagging in Ethiopia can be challenging. The national official language is Amharic name:am=* and the language of instruction in high schools and universities is English name:en=*. Each of the Regions (states) within the country have also adopted an official language for that region. Typically, official as well as unofficial signs in the various regions show names in two or more scripts: the local language, often using Roman or Latin script and then in the Amharic script. Translation from Amharic to English is not uniform due to the sounds not found in English.

For OSM tags the following convention should be used.

Finland

Some cities/places/streets have names in Finnish and Swedish. Use name key for the commonly used language (mostly Finnish, use Swedish version if municipality is mainly Swedish) and name:fi and name:sv for the specific language version.

Three Sami languages are recognized up in the north, Northern, Inari and Skolt Sami, in the following municipalities: Enontekiö, Utsjoki, Inari and Sodankylä. The ISO 639-1 code system covers only Northern sami (tagged as name:se). But with the ISO 639-2 code system all three languages are taggable with the name key. Northern Sami is tagged with name:sme, Inari Sami with name:smn and Skolt Sami with name:sms.

More information on the Finland page.

France

Bilingual street sign in Perpignan, both in Catalan and French.
name=Rue de la Poissonnerie
name:ca=Carrer de la Peixoneria

France has many regional languages besides French. None of them are recognized nationally, but may have some limited support from regional or local collectivities (including in schools and universities). There are also bilingual street signs. Some language codes are :

  • name=* for the default official name, as defined by the State-runned INSEE or by the municipal land registry (the cadastre). It may contain a local language name in bilingual areas, none of them official in France.
  • name:fr=* for the vernacular French name (needed exclusively off territories of the French Republic, especially for French variants like Londres for London or Munich for München))
  • name:br=* for Breton ; see the specific French project in name:br=*
  • name:ca=* ca for Catalan
  • name:co=* co for Corsican
  • name:frp=* frp for Arpitan (or Franco-Provençal)
  • name:gcf=* gcf for Guadeloupean Creole
  • name:gsw=* gsw for Alsatian, the French variant of Allemanic (note: gsw is also used for other Allemanic variants in Switzerland and in Südbaden, Germany)
  • name:oc=* oc for Occitan (including Auvergnat, Bearnese, Bigourdan, Cévenol, Gascon, Limousin and Provençal)
  • name:ty=* ty for Tahitian (in French Polynesia)
  • name:eu=* eu for Basque (Gascon must be under name:oc),
  • name:vls=* vls for West Flemish (around Dunkirk)

In Britanny and Normandy, there are also the "Gallo" and "Norman" languages but they still have no specific ISO 639 code assigned (they may be represented in conforming BCP 47 tags as "fr-gallo" or "fr-x-norman" using a private extension only to collect the data, that won't be used interoperably before there's a documented agreement on which subtags to use; for Norman the assigned code "nrf" refers ambiguously to modern Jersiais, Guernésiais or Continental Norman and don't seem to discriminate their own local dialects, so it would still safely replace the "fr-x-norman" private use extension of French, or we could use "nrf-FR" font continental Norman, "nrf-JE" for Jersiais, and "nrf-GG" for Guernésiais if a distinction is really needed at the same place).

Germany

In 70 municipalities in the official Sorbian settlement area in the federal states of Brandenburg and Saxony, Sorbian is recognized as a second official language. Towns and villages, that bear an official (!) name in German and Sorbian, should be tagged as follows:

Lower Sorbian [for Brandenburg]:

  • name=* : Names in both languages German - Sorbian
  • name:de=* : Name in German
  • name:dsb=* : Name in Lower Sorbian

Upper Sorbian [for Saxony]:

  • name=* : Names in both languages German - Sorbian
  • name:de=* : Name in German
  • name:hsb=* : Name in Upper Sorbian

Sorbian placenames in Wikipedia:

Greece

The official language in Greece is Modern Greek. Street signs usually have 2 or 3 lines :

  1. name:prefix=* "Οδός" (=street) can be omitted, we add anything else such as "Πλατεία" (=square), "Λεωφόρος" (=avenues and boulevards).
  2. name=* name in Greek e.g., "Σταδίου", "Ελευθερίου Βενιζέλου".
  3. int_name=* transcribed name as seen on the street sign e.g., "Stadiou", "Εleftheriou Venizelou", "Eleftherias". Transcribed/transliterated to the Latin alphabet using ISO 843 type 2 (same as ELOT 743).

We can also optionally add

  • old_name=* old Greek name; e.g., "Πανεπιστημίου".
  • alt_name=* when a street is also known with another name; e.g., "Γρηγορόπουλου"

When there is a first and a last name, like in Eleftheriou Venizelou (Ελευθερίου Βενιζέλου) the order of first and last names is kept, unlike in printed guides where they were reversed for indexing reason.

Transliteration and transcription links:

Haiti

The country has two official languages : French and Haitian Creole. Street names generally are only noted in French though. name=* Names in both languages (Haitian Creole first, followed by French)
name:ht=* Name in Haitian Creole
name:fr=* Name in French


Example:

name=Okay Les Cayes
name:ht=Okay
name:fr=Les Cayes

Hong Kong

主条目:zh-hant:Hong Kong tagging

Under "One Country, Two Systems", in Hong Kong, one of the special administrative regions of China, both Chinese and English are gazetted as the official languages. As a result, both Chinese and English names are used. The current bilingual (Chinese zh and English en) tagging conventions as follows:
name=* Names in both languages (Traditional Chinese first, followed by English)
name:zh=* Name in Traditional Chinese
name:en=* Name in English

Take Connaught Road Central (干諾道中) in Central for example.
name=干諾道中 Connaught Road Central (note the space between the languages)
name:zh=干諾道中
name:en=Connaught Road Central

Please exercise discretion when you see an object that's named by neither Chinese nor English, or try to discuss with other editors if you cannot decide it alone.

Cantonese transliteration of place name can be stored in name:yue-Latn=* tag but it is not that common in the OpenStreetMap database for now. Data users intended to transliterate Chinese place name in Hong Kong into English should also use Cantonese pronunciation instead of Mandarin pronunciation of those Chinese characters.

India

See India#Naming in different scripts and languages for more information on conventions followed for multilingual names in India.

Iran

We use name=* and full_name:fa=* for Persian street names and name:en=* for English street names . See Iran/Tagging rules#Naming for more information.

Ireland (Republic)

Officially, all street signage must be bilingual, Irish and English, unless the name is of a place in a Gaeltacht (area where a majority speaks Irish as a first language), in which case signs must be Irish-language only.

Certain rare examples exist of placenames outside Gaeltachts where the English version has been successfully supplanted by the Irish version, at least when written. Such towns (including Portlaois/Port Laoise and Dunleary/Dún Laoghaire, formerly Kingstown). Examples (past and current) do exist of places where the English name has endured despite signage that would suggest differently (Kells/Ceanannas, Bagenalstown/Muine Bheag, Charleville/Rath Luirc/An Rath). For these places, only local knowledge will allow you to tag "correctly".

Safest tagging practise is generally to use the English-language version, where given, as the primary name, including the Irish-language version under name:ga=*. Where only a single name is provided, this name will be in Irish, but is likely, in the absence of local knowledge to the contrary, to be the best primary name.

In Gaeltacht areas, it is probably best to use the Irish version of a name as primary name and tag the English version (where known) under name:en=*. This simple rule of thumb does break down where a Gaeltacht place is better known in English, or whose popularly used local Irish version is different to the officially recorded name, as in Dingle, a mostly English-speaking town in a Gaeltacht whose local Irish name is Daingean Uí Chúis but which is officially known as An Daingean.

Israel/Palestine

Officially the State of Israel has Hebrew as an official language, and Arabic, up till 2018 as a co-official language, and since then as a language with "special status in the State". The State of Palestine, with claimed sovereignty over the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip, and civil jurisdiction over the Gaza Strip and portions of the West Bank, has Arabic as its official language.

Two facts are to keep in mind: 1. Palestinian and Syrian Arabs are a significant minority within 1948 borders of Israel. 2. Hebrew-speaking Israelis are a significant minority within the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, living in settlements that are illegal under the International Law.

The main objective is to respect and represent both native Arabic speakers and native Hebrew speakers living in the Holy Land, and not to externally impose on each of the two languages.

Thus it is impossible to draw a solid lingual line in the small territory that is the Holy Land. The naming practice in OSM has been that the name=* tags are either Arabic or Hebrew, whichever one is (locally) more commonly used (most of the time this will be the language, which dominates in the municipality).

Regardless of the name tag, Hebrew names should be in name:he=* tags, Arabic names should be in name:ar=*, and English names should be in name:en=*.

Hebrew Name Tag Arabic Name Tag
name=<Hebrew>
name:he=<Hebrew>
name:ar=<Arabic>
name:en=<English>
name=<Arabic>
name:he=<Hebrew>
name:ar=<Arabic>
name:en=<English>

Alternative Arabic transliteration of Hebrew names, as well as Alternative Hebrew transliteration of Arabic names should be inputted in the alt_name tag. For Arabic transliterations of Hebrew names, please choose the spelling that contains special letters such as چ and ڤ, as the primary one, and display the variant that does not contain these letters in the alt name tag. Similarly, for Hebrew transliteration of Arabic names, please choose the spelling that contains the diacritic geresh as the primary Hebrew name, and the spelling that does not contain geresh, in the alt name tag.

Hebrew Name Tag Arabic Name Tag
name=נוף הגליל
name:he=נוף הגליל
name:ar=نوف هچليل
alt_name:ar=نوف هجليل
name:en=Nof HaGalil
name=جسر الزرقاء
name:he= ג'סר א-זרקא
alt_name:he= גסר א-זרקא
name:ar=جسر الزرقاء
name:en=Jisr az-Zarqa

Since 1948, the State of Israel has been trying to change the Arabic spelling of certain historic cities in territories that became Israel in 1948. Examples are the city of Ashkelon, عسقلان in Arabic, whereas the State of Israel has been using the spelling اشكلون, or Beersheba, بئر السبع in Arabic, whereas the State of Israel has been using the spelling بئير شيبع. The new State-imposed spellings are modern creations, not native to Arabic, nor common among native Arabic speakers of Israel/Palestine. The common and historic spelling is to be the primary Arabic one, whereas the Official Israeli Arabic spelling is to be presented in the alt name tag. This is to respect the variant that is commonly accepted by Native Arabic speakers living in the Holy Land.

Example
name=בית שאן
name:he=בית שאן
name:ar=بيسان ‎<Common and Historic Arabic spelling>
alt_name:ar=بيت شان <State of Israel's Arabic spelling>
name:en=Beit She'an

As for the English name tag, there's several general categories to follow:

  1. Historic cities with well-known and accepted English names, different from both Hebrew and Arabic: Eg. Hebron, in Arabic it is الخلیل (Al-Khalil), and in Hebrew it is חברון (Hevron). Hebron is to be used as the English name tags. English transliterations of Arabic and Hebrew names can be added to alt name tags.
  2. Localities within 1948-Israeli borders (Excluding the first category): These are to have the English spelling recognized by the State of Israel as the English name tag.
  3. Israeli settlements in the West Bank (including East Jerusalem): These are to have the English spelling recognized by the State of Israel as the English name tag.
  4. Palestinian localities in the West Bank (including East Jerusalem) and the Gaza Strip (Excluding the first category): These are to have the English spelling recognized by the Palestinian Authority as the English name tag.

Italy

Friuli-Venezia Giulia

In Friuli Venezia Giulia many places and geographical features (rivers, mountains...) have a toponym in Friulian. These names should be added as name:fur=*. In some villages the names of the roads are both in Italian and Friulian so you should add them in the same way. In certain cases there are two version of the toponym, one in standard Friulian and one in the local form; you should add the local form too using loc_name=*. Here you can find a document with a complete list of toponyms in standard Friulian. There's a rendering which shows Friulan names and you can find it here.

Some features have also a name in German; you should add them using name:de=* and name:sl=* There seems to be consensus in including italian and slovenian languages in the general name-tag separated by a slash, where the italian name comes first.

Examples:

name=Duino / Devin
name:sl=Devin
name:it=Duino

Südtirol - Alto Adige (South Tyrol) and Trentino (Welschtirol)

Languages of South Tyrol. Majorities per municipality in 2001

German and Italian are both official languages of South Tyrol. In some eastern municipalities Ladin is the third official language. (c.f. Wikipedia). Every town has two (or three) official names; but even the street names are mostly bilingual (trilingual).

The German and Italian (and Ladin) names of towns, streets, POIs, etc. are tagged separately with the respective name:* tags (name:it=* for Italian, name:de=* for German and name:lld=* for Ladin). There seems to be consensus in including both languages in the general name-tag separated by a dash, where the (locally) more commonly used name comes first (most of the time this will be the language, which dominates in the municipality). For most areas it is German, while in some urban areas Italian is dominant or equally used by the population. In the Dolomitic area Ladin is dominant. Examples are "Bolzano - Bozen" (Italian first), "Brixen - Bressanone" (German first), "Urtijëi - St. Ulrich - Ortisei" (Ladin - German - Italian).

Examples:

name=Bolzano - Bozen
name:de=Bozen
name:it=Bolzano

name=Brixen - Bressanone
name:de=Brixen
name:it=Bressanone

name=Urtijëi - St. Ulrich - Ortisei
name:de=St. Ulrich
name:it=Ortisei
name:lld=Urtijëi

In Trentino also all three languages exist. While Italian is widely dominant, the other two are also recognized as official and dominant in some areas. The Ladin language in the Northeast Dolomitic area and in two areas the local German dialects: Bersntol - Valle dei Mocheni and Lusern - Luserna. Historically many places in Trentino also have German names not anymore recognized as official. Some of them are still used and others reused by traditional associations. A discussion about how non official names should be included might be useful, see tags alt_name=* and old_name=*.

Sardegna (Sardinia)

Languages of Sardinia.

In Sardinia Sardinian and Catalan toponyms are protected by the national law 482/1999 and all the names in the local languages are co-official with Italian. These names should be added as name:sc=* (for Sardinian), or name:ca=* (for Catalan) and also the name tag must contain both the local and the italian name. You can find the local toponyms here. Other local languages, and related place names, are Corsican (Sassarese and Gallurese) name:co=* and name:lij=* for Ligurian (tabarchino).

Many places and geographical features (rivers, mountains...) have a toponym in the local languages. In some villages the names of the roads are both name so you should add them in the same way. In certain cases there are two version of the toponym, one in standard form and one in the local form; you should add the local form too using loc_name=*.

The correct tagging would be like:

name=Nùgoro/Nuoro
name:it=Nuoro
name:sc=Nùgoro

or

name=L'Alguer/Alghero
name:it=Alghero
name:ca=L'Alguer
name:co=L'Aliera
name:sc=S'Alighera

Japan

See Japan tagging and JA:Naming sample for more information.

Usage Description Example
name Japanese name name=首都高速道路
name:en English name, which can be a romanisation of Japanese if it's used by English speakers name:en=Metropolitan Expressway
name:ja Japanese name name:ja=首都高速道路
name:ja_rm romanisation of Japanese. In use, but name:ja-Latn is favoured since 2018 name:ja-Latn=Shuto Kōsoku Dōro
name:ja-Latn romanisation of Japanese name:ja-Latn=Shuto Kōsoku Dōro
name:ja_kana Japanese Kana form
name:ja-Hira Japanese Hiragana form

name:ja_rm=* and name:ja_kana=* are traditionally used key values with non-standard code. Standard language code for romanised Japanese should be name:ja-Latn=*, and the Hiragana form should be name:ja-Hira=*. See also BCP 47.

If one want to transliterate Japanese name into latin characters for various different purpose on objects that have no name:ja-Latn=* tags, then they should use the Japanese transliteration engine for Japanese characters instead of Chinese transliteration for the Kanji in Japanese names, as the pronunciation and transliteration will be unintelligibly different.

Kazakhstan

Kazakhstan has two official languages (Kazakh and Russian), Kazakh language has two variants (Cyrillic and Latin). As Russian language is used more widely, community decided that the name=* tag value should be in Russian if it exists and make sense. A Russian name value also should be duplicated in name:ru=* tag, Kazakh Cyrillic should be in name:kk=*, int_name=* transliterated from name:kk=*.

Korea

Korean is the only official language in Korea. Korean is written in Korean (using Hangeul).

Street signs often incorporate romanised or translated versions of names. Most often they are in English, but Chinese and Japanese can also be found. The romanisation should follow the Revised Romanisation of Korean for South Korea, and the McCune–Reischauer romanisation for North Korea.

Usage Example
name=Korean name=경부고속도로
name:en=English name:en=Gyeongbu Expressway
name:ko=Korean name:ko=경부고속도로
name:ko-Latn=romanisation of Korean name:ko-Latn=Gyeongbugosokdoro
name:ko-Hani=Hanja form name:ko-Hani=京釜高速道路

name:ko_rm is deprecated and name:ko-Latn= should be used now.

name:ko_hanja is deprecated and name:ko-Hani= should be used now.

Standard language code for Hanja should be name:ko-Hani=*

See also:

Kuwait

Signs (including street signs) in Kuwait are written in Arabic and in English, tagging is:
name=شارع القاهرة for Arabic name
name:en=Cairo Street for the English name

name=شارع 25 for Arabic name
name:en=Street 25 for the English name

Lebanon

Street signs in Lebanon are written in Arabic and in French, tagging is :

name=طرابلس for arabic name
name:ar=طرابلس for arabic name
name:fr=Tripoli for the french version

Luxembourg

In Luxembourg, Village names and their signs are bilingual, Luxembourgish and French. For example, Bascharage in French is Nidderkäerjeng in Luxembourgish. Most street names generally are only noted in French, but some bilingual street signs have been installed.

name:lb=* can be used for Luxembourgish names when there is one.

Examples

for Rue de Koerich / Kärcherwee, the correct tagging is:

name=Rue de Koerich
name:lb=Kärcherwee


for Rue Saint-Ulric / Tilleschgaass, the correct tagging is:

name=Rue Saint-Ulric
name:lb=Tilleschgaass

Macau

Official languages in the territory are Chinese [usually written in Traditional script] and Portuguese, put both of them in the name=* tag and then separately in name:zh=* and name:pt=*, like this:

Other language tags like name:en=* for English or name:zh-Hans=* for Simplified Chinese can also be added.

Morocco

By consensus of the community, names of cities and other administrative areas (from the country as a whole down to arrondissements) are written in French, Tamazight (Berber) and Arabic, in that order.

name=Casablanca ⵜⴰⴷⴷⴰⵔⵜ ⵜⵓⵎⵍⵉⵍⵜ الدار البيضاء
name:ar=الدار البيضاء
name:fr=Casablanca
name:zgh=ⵜⴰⴷⴷⴰⵔⵜ ⵜⵓⵎⵍⵉⵍⵜ

NOTE: the following is acceptable as an alternative for the name:zgh=* tag:
name:ber=ⵜⴰⴷⴷⴰⵔⵜ ⵜⵓⵎⵍⵉⵍⵜ

Street signs in Morocco are principally written in Arabic, with some also including French and/or Tamazight. If the French or Tamazight names are known (even if they are not on a particular sign), the preferred tagging includes them. The order is the same as for cities.

name=Avenue Rabat شارع الرباط
name:ar=شارع الرباط
name:fr=Avenue Rabat

As with city names, the Berber (or Tamazight) version is included, it should be between the French and Arabic versions in the full name, with a key of name:zgh=* or name:ber=*.

About the first mapper rule

Note that the "first mapper rule" is deprecated now. The consensus in the .ma community is to use "fr - ar" (or "fr - zgh - ar") for all name=* and addr:street=* tags, if known, and include specific languages in subtags. Consistency of data is more important than who came first and what their preferences are.

About "mapping what's on the ground"

If the French or Tamazight names are known (even if they are not on a particular sign), the preferred tagging includes them. In general, Arabic terms are translated (not transliterated) into their French equivalents: "Rue" not "Zanqat" (for زنقة) and "Avenue" (or "Boulevard") not "Chari" (for شارع). However, if the sign on the ground uses a word that has been transliterated into Latin script, follow that.

Netherlands

Frisia

In the province of Fryslân, also known as Frisia (English exonym) and Friesland (Dutch vernacular), most towns have both a Frisian and a Dutch name. Use the official name as name=*. In addition to the official name, use name:nl=* for Dutch names and name:fy=* for Frisian names. It is up to each municipality to decide what its name and that of the places within it are. For villages, towns, and cities, the official blue signs marking the village/town/city-limits tend to show the status quo:

  • If two names are shown, the upper name is the default name=*. Which one is name:nl=* and which one is name:fy=* is not noted on the sign, but locals know, as do most Frisians (so ask when in doubt).

In some rare cases these blue signs may be slightly out-of-date, but lacking local knowledge they act as suitable representatives of ground-truth.

Examples

name             Leeuwarden
name:fy          Ljouwert
name:nds         Liwwadden
name:nl          Leeuwarden
name             Damwâld
name:fy          Damwâld
name:nl          Damwoude
name             Eastermar
name:fy          Eastermar
name:nl          Eastermar
old_name:nl      Oostermeer

Limburg

In the South-Eastern province of Limburg the local dialect may be used (name:li=*).

Examples

name             Maastricht
name:li          Mestreech

Carnaval

Many villages, towns, and cities in (predominantly, but not exclusively) the southern parts of the Netherlands take their annual carnival celebrations quite seriously. A long-standing and well-documented custom is the use of pseudonyms for the places concerned during the festivities. These names are recorded in name:carnaval=* (cf. TagInfo name:carnaval=*).

Examples

Shown here is a representative sample of the name tags of the city of 's Hertogenbosch,including name:carnaval=* (with most other exonyms omitted for brevity):

alt_name:ja      デン・ボス
alt_name         Den Bosch
name             's-Hertogenbosch
name:carnaval    Oeteldonk
name:de          Herzogenbusch
name:fr          Bois-le-Duc
name:ja          スヘルトーヘンボス
name:li          De Bósj
name:nl          's-Hertogenbosch

Low German

In Eastern parts of the Netherlands, some places have a Low German (Nederduits) name as well. Use name:nds-nl=* for these:

name             Oldeberkoop
name:fy          Aldeberkeap
name:nds-nl      Berkoop

New Zealand

Some places in New Zealand have official dual English-Māori names. Correct tagging for these is as follows:

name=Aoraki / Mount Cook (official dual name)
name:en=Mount Cook (English name)
name:mi=Aoraki (Māori name)

North Macedonia

The official languages in North Macedonia are Macedonian written in Cyrillic and Albanian written in Latin.

Even though it is official language Albanian is not used for road names and most of other signs in most Macedonia. Across the country For road names and signs only Macedonian is used and it also is transcribed (when available) to the Latin alphabet according to the Macedonian transliteration rules.

  • The geographic terms: планина (mountain), низина (valley), плато (platteau), град (city), село (village), река (river), езеро (lake), залив (bay) etc., which are part of the geographic name, are generally transliterated as follows:

Шар планина → Shar planina

  • Geographic terms that are not part of the name, should be translated (here an example in English):

Охридско езеро → Lake Ohrid

  • The terms "северен" (northern), " јужeн" (southern), "источeн" (eastern), "западен" (western), "централен" (central) and similar ones, in case they are part of the geographic name, should be transliterated:

Скопје Север → Skopje Sever

  • Dates that are part of road names or signs should be transliterated. The number should be separated from the ordinal suffix with a dash ("-"):

1-ви Мај → 1-vi Maj

  • Ordinal numbers should also be transliterated. The number should be separated from the ordinal suffix with a dash ("-"). The ordinal suffix should be declined according to the corresponding gender:

15-та Бригада → 15-ta Brigada

Examples:

name=Методиjа Патчев
int_name=Metodija Patčev (transliterated name using diacritics system)
name:en=Metodija Patchev (transliterated name using digraphs system)

name=Булевар Ослободување
int_name=Bulevar Osloboduvanje (transliterated name using diacritics system)
name:en=Boulevard Osloboduvanje (translated to target language)

name=3-ти Ноември
int_name=3-ti Noemvri (transliterated name using diacritics system)
name:en=3-ti Noemvri (optional since it's same as int_name)

Norway

Most names in Norway will be in Norwegian only and are tagged with name only. Wherever other languages are used as well, the Norwegian name is also tagged with name:no, including for the Norwegian name of countries and other names abroad.

There are two written Norwegian languages, bokmål and nynorsk, which are tagged name:nb and name:nn, respectively. The two languages are very similar with only slight variations in spelling. Each municipality decides which of the two languages is the official language for that area, so names will generally exist in only one of the two languages. For this reason name:nb and name:nn are only used in the few exceptional cases were a distinction between names in both languages are needed. Examples of names with both bokmål and nynorsk spelling:

  • 15 country names (e.g. Norway, Austria, Belarus, East Timor) and a few other names abroad
  • National institutions - Official spelling

Sami and Kven names are tagged as follows:

  • Northern Sami: name:se - Official language in the municipalities of Guovdageaidnu - Kautokeino, Kárášjohka - Karasjok, Porsanger - Porsáŋgu, Deatnu - Tana, Unjárga - Nesseby, Gáivuotna - Kåfjord and Loabák - Lavangen
  • Lule Sami: name:smj - Official language in the municipality of Hábmer - Hamarøy
  • Southern Sami: name:sma - Official language in the municipalities of Snåase - Snåsa and Raarvihke - Røyrvik
  • Skolt Sami: name:sms
  • Kven (Finnish origin): name:fkv - Third administrative language in the municipality of Porsanger - Porsanki

Within the municipalities listed above all Norwegian names should be tagged with name:no. Outside of these municipalities Norwegian names should be tagged with name:no wherever multiple languages are present for the name of an object. If only the Norwegian name is present (outside of the listed municipalities) it should be tagged with name only.

The name key should always be used in addition to the language specific key. If names are present in more than one of the Norwegian, Sami or Kven languages for a given object, they should all be included in name with a spaced hyphen " - " between them. In the municipalities listed above, the Sami name should be the first, otherwise the Norwegian name should be the first.

Example (in Porsanger municipality):

name:se=Leavdnja
name:no=Lakselv
name:fkv=Lemmijoki
name=Leavdnja - Lakselv - Lemmijoki

See also:

Pakistan

The official languages of Pakistan are Urdu (name:ur=*) and English (name:en=*). These languages are are lingua franca; their official status serves to facilitate inter-communication between native speakers of a wider variety of languages. Urdu and/or English are commonly used in official documentation, education, and media in Pakistan. About 7% of Pakistanis speak Urdu as a first language, but is understood by the majority of the population as a secondary language. English is understood by a large minority of Pakistanis. Internet usage has proliferated rapidly in recent years, and Pakistan has 8th highest number of internet users in the world as of 2021.

Most people in Pakistan speak a regional language natively. Common regional languages include but are not limited to:

Many of these languages are also spoken in neighboring countries, and the conventions for distinguishing differences in use of the same language across different locales in South Asia is currently not accurately defined by any of the existing ISO standards. The long-standing convention OSM and on other multi-lingual sites such as Wikipedia has been to use different language codes for different variants of the same language. name:pa=* refers to Punjabi written in Gurmukhi script used in India, and name:pnb=* refers to Punjabi written in Shahmukhi script used in Pakistan. Besides the difference in script, these codes refer to the same language. Suffixes to specify script are typically not used in this case and are unlikely to be supported or expected by data consumers for Punjabi. (The ISO 15924 suffix which comes closest to describing Shahmukhi is "Aran," or "Arabic Nastaliq," which confusingly describes the typesetting most commonly used for various languages in Pakistan rather than a particular script variant and is outside of the scope of what Unicode accounts for. It is unlikely this is ever used or expected.)

There are some language terms you may come across in references which are not easy to define, or lack a clear definition. Saraiki describes the native language to various people in and around southern Punjab which is mutually intelligible with Punjabi; sources vary as to whether or not it constitutes a separate language. Hindko is used as an umbrella term for variety of dialects across discontinuous areas of Pakistan which are also mutually intelligible with Punjabi. Lahnda and Western Punjabi are exonyms which have been used by linguists in varying ways to describe a non-specific regional variant, or group of variants spoken in Pakistan or western Punjab more generally - these terms are not valid descriptors of any particular variant and are not recognizable to most Punjabi speakers. Sources referring to either of these two terms as if they constitute a separate language or variant can be disregarded as they have no bearing to ground truth.

"Default" official names or signposted names can vary in their origin; tags with language suffixes can be added in conjunction with a default name=* to help clarify the language a name is associated or where a name in another language exists.

Road signs on Karakoram Highway near the Pakistan-China border featuring Pakistani destination names in Latin, Chinese, and Cyrillic script
Road signs on Karakoram Highway near the Pakistan-China border featuring Pakistani destination names in Latin, Chinese, and Cyrillic script

Pakistan is home to many immigrants and refugees, and surrounded by countries which have people groups in common and are also multi-lingual. Translations where available to any applicable languages are potentially useful. Examples of languages that residents of Pakistan may speak natively can include, but is not limited to, Persian/Dari, Bengali, Rohingya, Uzbek, Turkmen, Tajik, Somali, Mandarin Chinese, Tibetan, Uyghur, Arabic, and Russian.

Poland

Poland has one official language (Polish), one recognized regional language (Kashubian) and one unrecognized, de-facto minority language (Silesian). There are also regions where two names are used (also on street signs) because of big percentage of minorities (mostly German and Kashubian). Correct tagging for these is as follows:

  • name=Białystok (official name in Polish)
  • name:be=Беласток (Belarusian name for Białystok)
  • name:lt=Vaičiuliškės (Lithuanian name for Wojciuliszki)
  • name:csb=Miechùcëno (Kashubian name for Miechucino)
  • name:de=Sankt Annaberg (German name for Góra Świętej Anny)
  • name:szl=Anaberg (Silesian name for Góra Świętej Anny)
  • name:rue=Бiлянка (Rusyn name for Bielanka)

Portugal

Portugal has one official language (Portuguese) and one recognised regional language (Mirandese). Correct tagging for these is as follows:

  • name=Cicouro/Cicuiro (official dual name)
  • name=Cicuiro (official name in Mirandese)
  • name:pt=Cicouro (Portuguese name)
  • name:mwl=Cicuiro (Mirandese name)

Qatar

Signs (including street signs) in Qatar are written in Arabic and in English, tagging is:
name=شارع القاهرة for Arabic name
name:en=Cairo Street for the English name

name=شارع 25 for Arabic name
name:en=Street 25 for the English name

The refs for the ring roads are displayed in English with "Ring" spelled out.

ref=C Ring

Many roads have two names - one word name and one number name. The number name should go into the alt_name tag.

Romania

In cities and villages where there is a minority representing at least 20% of the population, the local signs must be multilingual. In this case, street and city names should be written in Romanian; additionally, one can add the name in the secondary language using a different tag.

For cities without a significant minority population, street names must be written in Romanian. City names can be added in different languages using name:iso_code=* if there are significant sources supporting that name.

For example:

For features that have Transylvanian Saxon names, the tag name:gem=* is being used.

Russian Federation

Since Russian is the official language of Russian Federation name=* tags should contain the name in Russian (Cyrillic). For Russian regions having own official languages, native names should also be tagged.

For example, Altai republic uses Altay language in addition to Russian.

name=Катунь + name:ru=Катунь + name:alt=Кадын

In case of international brands, an original name may be used without translation if a brand holder prefers to use it without localization. For example:

name=KFC, name=Subway or name=Toyota should not be transliterated at all since brand holders uses original names.
Please, don't forget to put the same value to name:code=* key in the favor of data completeness (name=value + name:code=value).

If international company use cyrillic name:

name=Макдоналдс + name:ru=Макдоналдс + name:en=McDonald's or name=Папа Джонс + name:ru=Папа Джонс + name:en=Papa John's.

Serbia

The Serbian language is using both Cyrillic (official) and Latin (popular) alphabets, so the naming scheme needs to support both. The current proposal is to use name:sr=* for the Cyrillic script, and name:sr-Latn=* for Latin. The locale tags have been chosen according to BCP 47.

The default name=* tag should be filled in using Serbian Cyrillic, unless the feature is in an area where the language and script of the sizable ethnic minority is in official use (e.g. Subotica or Preševo). In that case, name:sr=* must be added, as well as the tag specifying the language of the default tag (e.g. name:hu=*, name:sq=*, etc.).

Slovakia

There are regions in Slovakia in which a minority language is spoken by a large percentage or even the majority of local inhabitants (e.g. Hungarian in Southern Slovakia). Some of those places (villages, towns) do have official names in the local language, the state does recognize the minority language at those municipalities. In those cases, the current state of tagging is this:

name=official name in Slovak
name:hu=official name in Hungarian

The current opinion of the majority of the active Slovak mapping community is to NOT put both names into the name=* tag. If you'd like to discuss this, please visit the Slovak forum.

Slovenia

Bilingual name of places in Slovenia (bottom three). The first one has name in 3 languages as it is direction to a place in Croatia.

There are 2 regions in Slovenia in which an officially recognized minority language are spoken by a large percentage of local inhabitants, namely:

Those 2 minority languages are officially recognized by the Constitution (unlike some newer, albeit larger ex-Yugoslav minorities) and co-official in these areas. In these 2 parts some of the places (cities, villages, towns, hamlets) and/or streets have an official names also in that official language.

In those areas, the tagging is done like this:

  • name=official name in Slovenian / official name in minority language (= names separated by "/" sign, same as on the signs, example shown on the right)
  • name:sl=official name in Slovenian

Followed by the name in minority language:

Names in other languages can be added to separate tags, but NOT to the main name=* tag.

  • name:de=name in German
  • name:hr=name in Croatian
  • name:it=name in Italian (eg in areas of Slovenia where Italian is not officially recognized as minority language)
  • name:ja=name in Japanese
  • ... other languages as needed / known ...

Spain

Depending of the zone you could find 3 additional languages: Català (ca), Galego (ga) and Euskera (eu)

Català its spoken in Catalunya, Illes Balears and several places in the Valencian Community (north east and balearic islands) Usually the official name for the places is that one but sometimes you are going to find names in Spanish, as an example the official name for one of the provinces its Lleida, but also for tradition this place its known and marked in several maps as Lérida.

The correct tagging would be:

name=Lleida
name:es=Lérida
name:ca=Lleida

The same happens with the Galego, spoken in the northwest corner, and with Euskera spoken in the basque region and Navarra. There are few exceptions like Donostia - San Sebastián and Vitoria - Gasteiz where the official form depends on the local administration and historic use of the names, so the correct tagging in this case would be:

name=Vitoria - Gasteiz
name:es=Vitoria
name:eu=Gasteiz

Please check out the right situation in each placename.

Switzerland

The ISO code for Rhaeto-Romance languages including the 4. national language Romansh is rm (ISO 639-1; ISO 639-2: roh) Currently ISO 639-1 and -2 specifications do not provide any differentiation between Romansh dialects, therefore rm should be used mainly for the more or less official "Rumantsch Grischun". The problem of missing ISO codes for different Romansh dialects seems still unresolved and needs discussion.

For names in Swiss german dialects ('Schwiizertüütsch','Schwyzerdütsch') add following tag to name=* tags: name:gsw=a Swiss german name. For explanations about the notation of Swiss german dialects see GISpunkt HSR Wiki.

Example: name:gsw=Züri as an addition to name=Zürich and name:en=Zurich. Code gsw most probably means "German SWiss". See [3] and [4].

See de:Switzerland/Map Features#Mehrsprachige Benennung (name).

Taiwan

Translating Taiwan names

Taiwan uses traditional Chinese characters. Names in Chinese should use these characters. Romanised names should be mentioned as the name:en=Street Name field.

Taiwan#Translation (中文地址英譯) mentions how to translate names.

Following the Taiwan Post Office guide, the following rules should be applied:

Name (Chinese) Name (English)
大街 Avenue
大道 Boulevard
Road
西 West
East
Section
Street
Lane
Alley

Since "Aly." and "Ln." sound quite cryptic and don't save that many characters, the whole English name will be used for Lanes and Alleys.

A whole standard entry should include:

name=<Chinese>
name:zh=<Chinese>
name:en=<English>

Here is a real life example:

name=南京東路三段256巷28弄
name:zh=南京東路三段256巷28弄
name:en=Alley 28, Lane 256, Section 3, Nanjing East Road

Taiwan Romanisation

Avoid transliteration except in special cases.

Different Romanisations are in use in Taiwan. See WikiProject_Taiwan/Taiwan_tagging#Romanization. name:en=* should use the name given on the street sign.

There's not yet a consensus on how to enter other romanisations. It might be useful as different forms are sometimes used (e.g. on maps or on business cards) and it should be possible to find streets based on such variants.

A possible method to enter names in different romanization could be using alt_name:en=* for different English spelling variants. Or use name:zh-Latn-[code_for_different_romanization_methods]=* (See also Type:variant entries in IANA language subtag registry), despite this is not currently used in OSM.

(There might even be a point in romanizing Hakka and Hokkien, hak-Latn and min-Latn. It's fortunately not as hard, as the systems are much less controversial.)

Other zh in Taiwan

name:zh-Hans=* can be used to label Simplified Chinese variant of name, name:nan=* and name:hak=* can be used to represent Min Nan and Hakka name, see also #China.

Some features currently use name:zh_zhuyin=* to represent their (Mandarin) Chinese name pronunciation in Zhuyin symbols, however as the ISO 15924 standard code for Zhuyin symbols is Bopo (stand for Bopomofo), standard-compliant code would be zh-Bopo (currently not in use).

Taiwan's Austronesian languages

Taiwan is home to many Austronesian aboriginal peoples with their own languages. If there is an aboriginal name known for a place, it should be added to a name:LANG tag, where LANG is the language code of the specific language in ISO 639-3. The writing should conform to the current Writing systems of Formosan languages (原住民族語羅馬字).

See Formosan languages or WikiProject_Taiwan/Taiwan_tagging#Naming scheme for codes to represent Formosan languages. (Note the Formosan classification leaves out the Yami language.)

Thailand

Thailand has names written in Thai script. Many street signs list RTGS transliterated (English) names as well.

We state the local (Thai) name in the name tag. For other languages the name-tag is extended by the language code. A special rendering allows selection of the language to display as well as bilingual naming: http://thaimap.osm-tools.org/

Transliterated Thai script (using RTGS) is usually entered in the name:en tag. Whether it is a translation or a full transliteration depends on the context and on the ground-truth. A good rule of thumb is to check what locals would use when describing the feature to a foreigner or how it is listed in the english Wikipedia. For example "วัดโพธิ์" is called "Wat Pho", not "Pho Temple". Here a full transliteration is used. On contrast "ถนนสุขุมวิท" is called "Sukhumvit Road" (also on street signs), not "Thanon Sukhumvit". The name is still a RTGS transliteration but the word for Road is translated.

Example:

name=เชียงใหม่
name:en=Chiang Mai
name:th=เชียงใหม่

If the English name and the direct romanization are different, the latter can be listed under the name:th-Latn=* tag, e.g. name:th-Latn=Thanon Sukhumwit.

In some areas of Thailand other languages are common as well. Often signs contain words in those languages as well. Use the appropriate language code to enter them in OSM.

The Language spoken in Northern Thailand is Kam Muang (ᨣᩴᩤᨾᩮᩥᩬᨦ) and can often be found on street signs with the ISO639-3 code of nod.

Example:

name=เชียงราย
name:th=เชียงราย
name:en=Chiang Rai
name:nod=ᨩᩭᨦᩁᩣᩭ

In the 4 provinces of Songkla, Patani, Yala and Narathiwat Bahasa Jawi (بهاس جاوي) is used widely, these are sometimes written in either Roman, Arabic or Thai script.

Example:

name=ปัตตานี
name:th=ปัตตานี
name:en=Pattani
name:mfa-Latn=Patani
name:mfa-Arab=ڤطاني
name:mfa-Thai=ปัตตานี

Tunisia

Street signs in Tunisia are written in Arabic and in French, tagging is :

name=عربي for arabic name
name:ar=عربي for arabic name
name:fr=français for the french version

Ukraine

Ukraine has one official language (Ukrainian). However due to historical background of many territories in some areas Polish is also in use. Additionally, as a post-Soviet cultural phenomenon, Russian is extremely widespread as a second language, in some areas (Crimea, Eastern Ukraine) dominating over official Ukrainian. Finally, in Crimea there is another language used by the peninsula's indigeous people, Crimean Tatars, who constitute a notable part of the population there. Considering these factors, Ukrainian OSM community widely uses Relation:associatedStreet to provide scalable multilingual support. Generally the following scheme is used:

name on the way (street) - in Ukrainian or in Russian, according to the truth on ground rule. There had been several holywars concerning "default" language. While inside a city it is recommended to keep this tag to a single language prevalent there (i.e. on the street signs). "Default" for Ukraine is Ukrainian, however one should use it reasonably. As an example many signs in Crimea installed during Soviet period are still in Russian. In questionable situations DWG recommends to keep to the "Truth on the Ground" rule.

name on the relation (associatedStreet) - same as above.

name:uk, name:ru on the relation (associatedStreet) - for multilanguage support. May be accompanied by the less widespread name:pl (Polish), name:crh (Crimean Tatar) as well as international name:en etc.

Note that all street ways sould be included in the relation with "street" role, while the houses related to the street should be included with "house" role for correct address processing.

United Arab Emirates

Signs (including street signs) in the UAE are written in Arabic and in English, tagging is:

name=شارع القاهرة for Arabic name

name:en=Cairo Street for the English name

The street signs in the locations noted below that have English names for numbered streets are displayed in a slightly different order from each other.

{{tag|name||شارع 25} for Arabic names with street numbers

name:en=Street 25 for the English name in Abu Dhabi (numbered streets only)

name:en=25 Street for the English name in Dubai (numbered streets only)

name:en=25th Street for the English name in Al Ain (numbered streets only)

United Kingdom

Cornwall

Cornwall is a county in the UK. People spoke Cornish (Kernewek) up to the 19th Century. There are some people that think Cornwall should/could be its own country, or at least keep its own identity and so some road signs to attractions get the Cornish flag spray painted over the English Heritage sign.

Some of the street signs of Kerrier District Council have the names also written in Cornish. It seems good to add this data to OSM, though the English name is likely to be the only one used.

The ISO 639-1 code is kw. So name=English Street, and name:kw=Cornish Translation (if shown).

Isle of Man

Many street signs in the Isle of Man have both an English version and a Manx version of the name. The Manx version should be added to the object using the name:gv=* tag, and the English version added with the name:en=*. Whichever version is used as the primary name (usually the English version) should be used in the main name=* tag as well.

Northern Ireland

Some street signs in Northern Ireland, particularly in West Belfast, are in both English and Irish, and most place names have an Irish translation. The English name should be tagged with name=*, and the Irish with name:ga=*. The rule in the Republic where the Irish name is listed with name=* in Gaeltachts (Irish-speaking areas) also applies here, however as of yet there are no official Gaeltachts in the North.

There are also street signs which are in both English and Ulster Scots. Examples can be seen in villages such as Ballywalter and Greyabbey on the Ards peninsula. The Scots tag is name:sco=*.

Scotland

Some signs in the Highlands of Scotland have names in both English and Gaelic, almost always for place names (Mallaig, Fort William etc.), but often also on street signs, such as this one in Oban. Gaelic names can be tagged using name:gd=*, with name=* for the name in English. Note there are a few place names where the Gaelic name is the official name, for example Drochaid a' Chaolais Chumhaing in Sutherland.

gd is the ISO 639-1 code for Scottish Gaelic, which isn't the same as the other Gaelic languages (Irish and Manx), so this code is only for Scottish Gaelic. This is the Gaelic which is used in Canada as well.

An OSM rendering showing the Gaelic names is available at OSM Alba.

Scots names can be tagged using name:sco=*, with name=* for the name in English. Names in Scots are not usually listed on signs. Often the Scots name for a place can only be determined with local knowledge.

Some places (mainly islands) have Old Norse names as well, use name:non=* for these. (non is the ISO 639-2 code for Old Norse)

Na h-Eileanan Siar

In the Western Isles (officially Na h-Eileanan Siar), Gaelic is the primary language. The Gaelic name can be tagged using name=*, with name:en=* for the English name. Most street signs primarily show the Gaelic name. An example of this in the wild is Steòrnabhagh (Stornoway).

Wales

In Wales many, but by no means all, places and features are named differently in Welsh and English.

Instances where the name is different in Welsh and English

The name tag should contain the name widely used by the local population.

This should be either the name used in English or the name used in Welsh but not both.

If the name included in the name: tag is that used in English, name:cy can be added to show the alternate name (cy is the two letter ISO639-1 language code for the Welsh language).

If the name included in the name: tag is the name used in Welsh, name:en can be added to show the alternate name (en is the two letter ISO639-1 language code for the English language).

Examples:

  • name: Welshpool
  • name:cy Y Trallwng


  • name: Biwmares
  • name:en Beaumaris

It should not be necessary to add both name:en and name:cy though it is not harmful to do so.

Instances where the name is the same in Welsh and English

The name: tag should contain the name.

It is not, in principle, necessary to add either a name:cy or a name:en (since there is only one name in both languages).

However

Multi-lingual tagging in Wales is currently patchy. Adding a name:cy tag even though this will duplicate the information in the name: tag would help other mappers distinguish between cases where multi-lingual tagging has not yet been applied and cases where the name is the same in Welsh and English.

Example:

  • name: Ynysybwl
  • name:cy Ynysybwl


Note: This has been the subject of much discussion discussion, also with editions of this article of the wiki. The most recent discussion can be found on this thread. For earlier discussions please see this thread and this of talk-gb for more information.

United States of America

Alaska

Languages of indigenous peoples of Alaska:

Name ISO code Location used
Inupiat (Inupik) ik Arctic Northwest Arctic
Central Siberian Yupik ess St. Lawrence Island
(Central Alaskan) Yup'ik esu Norton Sound to Alaska Peninsula
Alutiiq ems Koniag, coastal Chugach, Kodiak
Unangan (Aleut) ale Aleutians
Dena'ina (Tanaina) tfn Southcentral Alaska
Deg Xinag (Ingalit) ing Interior Alaska
Holikachuk hoi Innoko River
Koyukon koy Interior Alaska
Dinak'i (Upper Kuskokwim) kuu Upper Kuskokwim River
Gwich’in (Kuchin) gwi Arctic Northeast Alaska
Lower Tanana taa Interior Alaska
Upper Tanana tau Interior Alaska
Tanacross tcb Interior Alaska
Hän haa Interior Alaska
Ahtna aht Copper River
Eyak eya Copper River Delta
Tlingit tli Alexander Archipelago
Haida hai Haida Gwaii
Sm’algyax̣ (Coast Tsimshian) tsi New Metlakatla, lower Skeena River

American Samoa

With only 3% of the population speaking English only, and 88.6% speaking Samoan, most names should be in Samoan, with name:sm=* and name:en=* if applicable.

Samoan sm American Samoa

Guam

The Filipino language (name:fil=* has a notable presence in Guam, however, English remains the majority. Chamorro name:ch=* is also spoken by about 17% of the population. Some place names retain names originating from these languages.

Chamorro ch Guam, Northern Mariana Islands

Northern Mariana Islands

Like American Samoa, English speakers are a minority. According to the CIA World Factbook, 33% of the population speak "Philipine languages", the majority of which is most likely Filipino (name:fil=*). The official languages are Chamorro, Carolinian, and English. In general, use the names of places on USGS topographic maps or signed names if possible.

Carolinian cal Northern Mariana Islands
Chamorro ch Guam, Northern Mariana Islands
Tanapag tpv Northern Mariana Islands

Hawaiʻi

The US state of Hawaiʻi has both English and Hawaiian (name:haw=*) as its official languages. Most place names retain the aboriginal Hawaiian names, with a few notable examples like Pearl Harbor. Most place names are now officially spelled with the ʻokina (glottal stop) and kahakō (macron) where appropriate. Use the ʻokina ( ʻ ) on names of Hawaiian origin even when signs appear to use the straight apostrophe ( ' ) or a curly quotation mark (   ).

Puerto Rico

The predominantly spoken language in Puerto Rico is Spanish (name:es=*.

Uzbekistan

Uzbekistan has one official language: Uzbek. Additionally, Karakalpak is recognized for the Autonomous Republic Karakalpakstan.

Historically, most places had Russian names, because of the Soviet Union. Many minorities of Russian, Tatar, Krigisian, Turkmen, and even German origin had been living or are still living in Uzbekistan. Therefore, nearly all places had Russian names that have only in the past years been substituted with Uzbek names in Latin letters or have traditional names in other languages. Russian continues to be widely used, especially in larger cities. On their websites or on social media, many businesses in Uzbekistan refer to their address in Russian. Hence, the current naming practice in Uzbekistan is to use Uzbek (in Latin script) for default names, while Russian names are thoroughly added in name:ru=*. In Karakalpakstan, the default name shall be in Karakalpak.

name=Toshkent for official Uzbek name in Latin letters
name:kaa=Tashkent for the Karakalpak name
name:ru=Ташкент for the Russian name
name:en=Tashkent for the main English name
name:de=Taschkent for the German name
alt_name:uz=Тoшкент for the alternative Uzbek name in Cyrillic or other Latin versions of the name
alt_name:en=Toshkent for the alternative English names

Vietnam

Vietnamese is the national language of Vietnam. Vietnamese-language names are tagged name:vi=*. See Key:name:vi for details about orthography and tips for non-Vietnamese speakers who need to map Vietnamese-language names. In many rural parts of Vietnam, languages other than Vietnamese are commonly spoken; names in these languages should also be tagged if known.

Shared boundary features

Sometimes a boundary is a shared feature like a river with different names on each side of the border. One example is the Rhine river separating Germany and France.

Always add name:code=* for each involved language, and for compatibility with older rendering engines, also set name=* to both names, separated by a forward slash with spaces in between, sorted in (a somewhat neutral) Unicode alphabetical order.

For the Rhine river, this would be:
name=Le Rhin / Rhein
name:fr=Le Rhin
name:de=Rhein

Note that, in the rare case when the feature borders multiple language regions, like the Danube river, joining all names within name=* can produce an inconveniently long string. Though not implemented anywhere yet, one could:

  • create a relation for the whole feature without name=*, only name:code=* tags
  • break down the feature for each pair of adjacent regions (usually countries)
  • for each pair of regions, create a relation for the feature's parts separating the two regions with name=* containing the two local names and no name:code=* tags

Finally, if only part of the feature is used as a boundary, set name=* of the non-boundary parts to the name used in the containing region, as in most other objects.