Zh-hans:已弃用的地图要素
deprecated tag(不推荐使用的标签)或deprecated feature(已弃用的地图要素)是OpenStreetMap社区共识推荐删除和替换为其他标记的标签。
任何人都被允许并鼓励使用 他们认为有用的任何标签。
随着时间的推移,标签将变得更加详细和复杂,绘图者社区根据需要发明了新的标注方式来更详细地描述地图要素。有时,社区会发现扩展现有标签不足以满足当前的绘制需求,而是决定应用更好地反应现实世界情况的新标签替换旧标签。在某些情况下,甚至可能会同时出现多个相互竞争的标签方案。如果其中一个方案随着时间的推移获得足够的社区支持,则可能会形成社区共识以弃用另一个方案。将某个功能记录为已弃用,可以让绘图人员和开发人员了解到社区推荐使用多种标记方案中的哪一种。
标签通常会在社区内进行广泛讨论,例如在标注邮件列表时,允许每个人都做出贡献。
- 标签可以被描述为不需要的,并在OSM Wiki上说明原因;
- Validator投诉可能会被添加到JOSM、iD、Osmose和其他validator或其他质量保证工具中;
- 通常需要在给定项目的错误跟踪器上打开问题。
- 可能会从默认或编辑器渲染中删除对这种标签的支持;
- 通常需要在给定项目的错误跟踪器上打开问题。
- 人们可以检查他们所在地区的标签使用情况并编辑对象以改进标签;
- 数据使用者可能会放弃对标签的支持;
- 通常需要在给定项目的错误跟踪器上打开问题
- 在极少数情况下,可以进行自动编辑以改进标签。此类编辑必须遵循自动编辑行为准则。
在任何情况下,您都不应在不符合自动编辑行为准则的情况下擅自自动(或半自动)的将弃用标签大规模替换为数据库中的其他标签。任何此类编辑都将被回退。 |
示例
有一些有代表性的案例,例如highway=unsurfaced标签有以下特征:
- 不支持渲染
- 与替代标签相比使用量很好
- 与广泛使用的描述道路的标记方案冲突
- 不支持编辑
- 数据使用者不支持
- 编辑器会在使用此标签时报错
所有这些都清楚地证明了该标签已被弃用。 因此,它在此wiki上被描述为已弃用。
另一方面,highway=motorway标签显然没有被弃用,因为:
- 绘图者大量和持续使用
- 没有可行的替代方案
- 与其他的标签方案没有严重冲突
- 编辑器支持
- 数据使用者支持
- 没有编辑器抱怨它的使用
因此,它在wiki上并没有被描述为已弃用。
优缺点
- 弃用可能导致混淆、劣质、同义或导致错误的标签;
- 标签的弃用让使用绘图者感到困惑,尤其是那些错过弃用讨论的绘图者(大多数绘图者从不参与此类讨论,他们只画图);
- 弃用将影响数据使用者对标签的使用;
- 人们经常在标签已弃用或标签应弃用或有人告诉我标签已弃用后,进行违反自动编辑行为准则的,未经讨论的大规模编辑;
- 经常有人表达这样的观点:如果两个标签具有完全相同的含义,则弃用一个并重新标记对象是浪费时间和精力,并且会干扰渲染而没有任何好处;
- 经常有人又会表达相反的观点:应该弃用具有相同含义的标签中的一个;
- 人们常常不同意哪些标签是同义的,哪些是可以弃用的,以及应该怎样弃用。甚至讨论已经进行过的弃用都会引起激烈争论。
- 因此,又出现了另一种观点:关于弃用的讨论是一件耗时的事情,不值得花精力在上面;
- 同时,还有许多人花费大量时间在计划、提议、支持弃用和至少部分出于希望弃用某个标签动机的编辑上。
维基指南
还请保持列表与下面的关系保持同步:
- Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated"
- Category:Key descriptions with status "deprecated"
您也可以在功能页面上使用 Template:Deprecated。
您需要持之以恒地更新wiki内容,验证您更改的页面在wiki链接的位置。而且,请在翻译页面中添加弃用警告,而不仅仅是在英文页面中,否则世界上的某些地区可能会仅仅因为维基页面过时,而广泛地使用已经废弃的标签 |
一般来说,标签应该被描述为已弃用,因为编辑器中没有对它们的支持。相反 - 直接修改OSM Wiki上已弃用的标签并要求绘图者改变意见是不受欢迎的。
一切都比想象中更复杂
- 绘图者们的意见可能因地区而异:在德国的绘图者们有一个明确的共识,即连接路关系在德国不需要,但同时法国的绘图者却选择继续使用这一标注方案。
- 在某些情况下,地图绘制者的意见在区域中没有很好地区分,并且同一地区的地图绘制者有不同的偏好。 这种情况最有可能导致冲突。
- 某些标签一个编辑器中可能得到支持或首选,而其他软件可能会鼓励使用相反的标签方案。
- 在某些情况下,验证器的报错是有误的,应该修改。例如,请参见这种情况,其中将某些标签组合会被描述为已弃用。一般来说,任何验证器都有可能需要改进,而不是根据错误的质量检查建议修改地图数据。
- 一些使用次数非常高的标签被弃用——例如is_in=*标签被JOSM视为已弃用,而waterway=riverbank被iD视为已弃用。
- 机器编辑或批量编辑可能会影响单个标签或整组标签的使用次数。此类行为可能得到社区其它人的广泛支持,也可能不受欢迎,因此仅计算标签的使用次数并不是衡量绘图者对标记支持与否的最好方法。
- 有时绘图者或社区的意见会与验证器或质量检查工具开发人员之间的意见相冲突。有时,不同的绘图小组会对绘图方式进行完全相反的建议。
- 仅将wiki上已弃用的内容描述为不推荐使用的标签
- 数据使用者可能落后于绘制者的首选或数据库中存在的数据,有时非常明显。请注意,一些项目会积极地为地图绘制者提供有用的反馈(例如OSM Carto),但是其他地图项目可能不一定。
- 通过提案流程弃用的标签可能会仍在使用,如果这些标签仍在大量使用中,不应被视为已弃用。
- 绘图者之间的共识很难判断,因为只有极少数人参与讨论,有时很难区分一个人是在“单纯的在抬杠”还是“代表许多绘图者分享他们的意见”。
- 在某些情况下,一些标签会被某些软件视为已弃用,强烈建议重新标记它,而其他软件和绘图者则支持。
- 在某些情况下,弃用和删除此类标签是个好主意,在某些情况下则不是
- 意见会随着时间的推移而变化,多年前广泛使用或不喜欢或弃用或批准的标签目前可能会被不同地考虑。
- 由于软件中的错误,特别是在预设中,某些标签可能存在大量存在(或被标记为已弃用),这是不要盲目信任编辑器的另一个原因
- 有时并不推荐使用更新的标签。当有人引入与现有标签重复的新标签时,就会发生这种情况,通常这些标签没有得到足够的使用,甚至被记录为已弃用。
- OSM wiki 上的文档、其他地方的文档、编辑器预设和来自其他编辑者的建议可能已过时、不完整、错误或有其他问题。 任何一方都不应该被认为是万无一失的。
过时的功能
以下是参与标记讨论的人员推荐使用替代标记的功能。 请注意,其中一些功能仍在地图功能上,只要它们仍然被广泛使用,就应该保留在那里!
Date | Deprecated key/value | Current usage | Suggestion of replacement | N | Reason
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
2013-12-31 | emergency=aed | overpass-turbo / tag-history | emergency=defibrillator | 58 | Proposed features/automated external defibrillator (archive)
|
2014-06-13 | amenity=emergency_phone | overpass-turbo / tag-history | emergency=phone | 47 | WikiProject Emergency Cleanup
|
2015-09-11 | amenity=fire_hydrant | overpass-turbo / tag-history | emergency=fire_hydrant | 64 | On 01/01/2015, there was about 12,000 uses of amenity=fire_hydrant and 300,000 uses of emergency=fire_hydrant. 9,000 of the 12,000 had both tags. Both were allowed. Early July 2015, there was around 0 uses of amenity=fire_hydrant. On 09/11/2015, amenity=fire_hydrant has been deprecated.
|
2015-01-08 | aerialway=canopy | overpass-turbo / tag-history | aerialway=zip_line | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-21 | amenity=abandoned | overpass-turbo / tag-history | abandoned:*=* | 49 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Besides, the deprecated tagging does not indicate which kind of amenity (or whatever) it used to/will be... See also Lifecycle prefix.
|
2016-04-06 | amenity=advertising | overpass-turbo / tag-history | advertising=* | 11 | An ad is not an amenity... Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated".
|
2015-12-18 | amenity=artwork | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=artwork | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-08 | amenity=car_repair | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=car_repair | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2016-01-02 | amenity=citymap_post | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=information | 20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2015-12-18 | amenity=community_center | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=community_centre | 39 | British English is preferred in tags.
|
2015-12-21 | amenity=creche | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=childcare or amenity=kindergarten |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2016-01-02 | amenity=disused | overpass-turbo / tag-history | disused:amenity=*, or such | 49 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Besides, the deprecated tagging does not indicate which kind of amenity (or whatever) it used to/will be... See also Lifecycle prefix.
|
2015-02 | amenity=dog_bin | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=waste_basket + waste=dog_excrement or amenity=vending_machine + vending=excrement_bags |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2015-02 | amenity=dog_waste_bin | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=waste_basket + waste=dog_excrement or amenity=vending_machine + vending=excrement_bags |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2015-12-08 | amenity=education | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=college or amenity=school or amenity=college or amenity=university or office=tutoring |
12 | This tag has never been approved, nor had wide usage. Take one of the replacements to correctly tag the education place.
|
2015-05-13 | amenity=ev_charging | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=charging_station | 26 | The latter tag is more expressive than the former.
|
2009-10 | amenity=garages | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=parking + parking=* or landuse=garages |
50 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". There is currently no consensus on the preferred tagging suggestions, as both got consensus on Oct. 2009 (Proposed features/Additional parking types for amenity=parking; Proposed features/tag:landuse=garages).
|
2007 | amenity=hotel | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=hotel | 7 | better fits into toplevel tags
|
2015-12-22 | amenity=kiosk | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=kiosk | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-21 | amenity=nursery | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=childcare or amenity=kindergarten |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-21 | amenity=park | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leisure=park | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-18 | amenity=preschool | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=kindergarten | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2016-01-02 | amenity=proposed | overpass-turbo / tag-history | proposed:amenity=*, or such | 49 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Besides, the deprecated tagging does not indicate which kind of amenity (or whatever) it used to/will be... See also Lifecycle prefix.
|
2015-06-07 | amenity=real_estate | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=estate_agent | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-04 | amenity=sauna | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leisure=sauna | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2007-07-16 | amenity=shop | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=* | 1 | Introduction of "shop"
|
2023-04-09 | amenity=spa | overpass-turbo / tag-history | (shop=beauty & beauty=spa) or (amenity=public_bath & bath:type=thermal) | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2014-10-20 | amenity=winery | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=wine or craft=winery |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-11-07 | amenity=youth_centre | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=community_centre + community_centre:for=juvenile or community_centre:for=child;juvenile |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=arch | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=yes + bridge:structure=arch |
25 | Proposed features/Bridge types
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=beam | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=yes + bridge:structure=beam |
25 | Proposed features/Bridge types
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=humpback | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=yes + bridge:structure=humpback |
25 | Proposed features/Bridge types
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=lift | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=movable + bridge:movable=lift |
25 | Proposed features/Bridge types
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=pontoon | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=yes + bridge:structure=floating |
25 | Proposed features/Bridge types
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=suspension | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=yes + bridge:structure=suspension |
25 | Proposed features/Bridge types
|
2013-10-06 | bridge=swing | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=movable + bridge:movable=swing or bridge=yes + bridge:structure=simple-suspension |
24 | Proposed features/Bridge types - was formerly used to map two very different bridge types (hanging/swinging rope bridges and movable swing bridges)
|
2012 | building:type=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | building=* | 29 | Proposed features/Building attributes has been abandoned.
|
2018 | building=condominium | overpass-turbo / tag-history | building=apartments | 56 | The difference between a condominium and an apartment is purely legal, difficult to verify, and unimportant to OSM.
|
2011-10-27 | building=entrance | overpass-turbo / tag-history | entrance=* | 14 | Cleaning the semantics of the "building" tag; entrance=* approved. building=entrance is still considered coexisting.
|
2020-01-31 | car=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | motorcar=* | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2006 | class=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | highway=* | 2 | Introduction of Key:highway
|
2012-11-28 | color=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | colour=* | 18 | Usage of American form color probably mainly due to a bug in JOSM presets.
|
2013-10-22 | date_off=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Conditional restrictions or opening_hours=* |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2013-10-22 | date_on=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Conditional restrictions or opening_hours=* |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2013-10-22 | day_off=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Conditional restrictions or opening_hours=* |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2013-10-22 | day_on=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Conditional restrictions or opening_hours=* |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2018-06-28 | camp_site=pitch | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=camp_pitch | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2018-06-28 | camp_site=camp_pitch | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=camp_pitch | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2018-12-01 | amenity=embassy | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=diplomatic and diplomatic=embassy | 20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2019-06-12 | diaper=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | changing_table=* | 20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2014-05-01 | drinkable=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | drinking_water=* | 21 | There is no need for redundant tags. One key is sufficient.
|
2012-09-14 | escalator=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | highway=steps + conveying=* |
38 | Proposed features/Escalators and Moving Walkways
|
2023-02-25 | emergency=dry_riser_inlet | overpass-turbo / tag-history | emergency=fire_service_inlet & fire_mains=dry | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-02-25 | emergency=sprinkler_connection | overpass-turbo / tag-history | emergency=fire_service_inlet & fire_sprinkler=yes | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-21 | highway=abandoned | overpass-turbo / tag-history | abandoned:highway=*, or such | 49 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Besides, the deprecated tagging does not indicate which kind of amenity (or whatever) it used to/will be... See also Lifecycle prefix.
|
2009-08 | highway=byway | overpass-turbo / tag-history | highway=track/path + designation=byway_open_to_all_traffic or designation=restricted_byway access=* |
13 | More accurate tagging for public rights of way in England and Wales.
|
2012 | highway=ford | overpass-turbo / tag-history | ford=* | 17 | "highway=ford" on a way doesn't allow tagging the highway itself (as e.g. "unclassified"). This doesn't apply to nodes; though, and renderers haven't quite caught up (ref openstreetmap-carto issue 267 and elsewhere) - don't automatically (or semi-automatically) change "ford" node tagging.
|
2008-06-12 | highway=incline_steep | overpass-turbo / tag-history | incline=* | 3 | Any type of highway=* (primary, secondary, ...) may have inclined sections tagged separately, this does not create a new type of highway
|
2008-06-12 | highway=incline | overpass-turbo / tag-history | incline=* | 3 | Any type of highway=* (primary, secondary, ...) may have inclined sections tagged separately, this does not create a new type of highway
|
2007 | highway=minor | overpass-turbo / tag-history | highway=tertiary or highway=unclassified or highway=service or such | 9 | Abandoned feature.
|
2008-10-19 | highway=stile | overpass-turbo / tag-history | barrier=stile | 4 | Their "concept" better fits in this new key and highway gets a bit uncluttered.
|
2008-03-19 | highway=unsurfaced | overpass-turbo / tag-history | highway=* + surface=unpaved highway=track |
5 | Any highway classification can be unsurfaced.
|
2014-10-19 | historic_name=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | old_name=* or name=* |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-12-21 | historic=abandoned | overpass-turbo / tag-history | abandoned:historic=*, or such | 49 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Besides, the deprecated tagging does not indicate which kind of amenity (or whatever) it used to/will be... See also Lifecycle prefix.
|
2008-01-10 | historic=icon | overpass-turbo / tag-history | No | 6 | No description, usage completely unknown
|
2008-01-20 | historic=museum | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=museum | 16 | Tag historic=* should be used for historic items (and therefore not a museum).
|
2013-10-22 | hour_off=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Conditional restrictions or opening_hours=* |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2013-10-22 | hour_on=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Conditional restrictions or opening_hours=* |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2010 | landuse=farm | overpass-turbo / tag-history | landuse=farmland or landuse=farmyard |
36 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Originally designed to mark agricultural zones, this tag has confused many contributors, who tagged also buildings with it.
|
2010 | landuse=field | overpass-turbo / tag-history | landuse=farmland | 46 | Proposed features/agricultural Field#Conclusion?
|
2011-05-09 | landuse=pond | overpass-turbo / tag-history | natural=water + water=pond |
30 | Even though this tag is widely used, it has been deprecated by Proposed features/Water details. Both tagging schemes should persist for some time.
|
2011-05-09 | landuse=reservoir | overpass-turbo / tag-history | natural=water + water=reservoir |
30 | Even though this tag is widely used, it has been deprecated by Proposed features/Water details. Both tagging schemes should persist for some time.
|
2007-07-16 | landuse=wood | overpass-turbo / tag-history | landuse=forest or natural=wood |
8 | Was intended to depend on whether the woodland/forest was "managed" or "primaeval", but also see Forest for more discussion about the problems here.
|
2017-04-13 | leisure=beach | overpass-turbo / tag-history | natural=beach | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2014-08-02 | leisure=club | overpass-turbo / tag-history | club=* | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2016-01-02 | leisure=gambling | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=gambling or such | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2014-01-27 | leisure=video_arcade | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leisure=adult_gaming_centre for venues with gambling machines; or leisure=amusement_arcade for venues with pay-to-play games. |
44 | Proposed features/Gambling
|
2016-01-02 | man_made=cut_line | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=cutline | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2017-06-17 | man_made=hot_water_tank | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=storage_tank + content=hot_water |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2013-05-23 | man_made=jetty | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=pier | 42 | Tag whose definition remains unclear. man_made=pier is way more widely used.
|
2016-01-02 | man_made=village_pump | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=water_well | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2016-07-09 | man_made=water_tank | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=storage_tank + content=water |
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2016-01-02 | man_made=well | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=water_well | 31 | No specific reason stated, should be replaced with an actual reason. Actual reason may be described at tag page, this entry also may be an invalidly listed one.
|
2015-03-19 | name:botanical=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | species=* | 37 | Taken from Category:Key descriptions with status "deprecated".
|
2011-08-31 | natural=land | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Relation type=multipolygon or natural=coastline |
15 | For tagging islands in lakes and rivers use Relations/Multipolygon, for islands in the sea use natural=coastline and place=island.
|
2008-11-18 | natural=marsh | overpass-turbo / tag-history | natural=wetland + wetland=marsh |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2017-03-08 | natural=moor | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Look the natural=moor page for lots of suggestions. | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2009-08-08 | noexit=no | overpass-turbo / tag-history | fixme=Continue | 40 | If there is an exit... it should be mapped!
|
2016-03-02 | office=administrative | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=government | 55 | Proposed features/Government offices
|
2015-06-07 | office=real_estate_agent | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=estate_agent | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-06-07 | office=real_estate | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=estate_agent | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2012-12-08 | place_name=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | name=* | 23 | Although it made sense in the past, nowadays it completely overlaps with name=*. More info here.
|
2016-06-30 | pole=transition | overpass-turbo / tag-history | location:transition=yes | 54 | Implementation of location=* key by Proposed features/PipelineExtension which also supports underwater.
|
2010-09 | power_rating=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | generator:output=* | 28 | Proposed features/generator rationalisation
|
2010-09 | power_source=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | generator:source=* | 28 | Proposed features/generator rationalisation
|
2013-01-24 | power=station | overpass-turbo / tag-history | power=substation or power=plant or power=generator |
19 | The value "station" is ambiguous and has been used both for substations and power plants / generators ("power station"). Please take the opportunity to review the object and add useful information, not just "correct" it.
|
2014-11-25 | power=sub_station | overpass-turbo / tag-history | power=substation | 19 | The value "station" is ambiguous and has been used both for substations and power plants / generators ("power station"). Please take the opportunity to review the object and add useful information, not just "correct" it.
|
2013-02-01 | power=underground_cable | overpass-turbo / tag-history | power=cable + location=underground | 54 | Implementation of location=* key by Proposed features/PipelineExtension which also supports underwater.
|
2014-10-24 | railway=preserved | overpass-turbo / tag-history | historic=railway + railway=rail (or whatever type) + railway:preserved=yes |
41 | See OpenRailwayMap/Aktiventreffen 2014 2#Tracks. Clashes with railway=narrow_gauge when such railways are preserved.
|
2008-05-30 | route=ncn | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Cycle_routes | 27 | Cycle routes
|
2007-07-16 | shop=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=yes or shop=* (the actual shop type) |
51 | A star '*' should not be considered as a correct value tag.
|
2015-12-08 | shop=antique | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=antiques | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2012-03-08 | shop=auto_parts | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=car_parts | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2014-01-27 | shop=betting | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=bookmaker or shop=lottery See also Tag:shop=betting. |
44 | Proposed features/Gambling
|
2016-01-02 | shop=disused | overpass-turbo / tag-history | disused:shop=*, or such | 49 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". Besides, the deprecated tagging does not indicate which kind of amenity (or whatever) it used to/will be... See also Lifecycle prefix.
|
2017-04-06 | shop=dive | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=scuba_diving | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2010-06-06 | shop=fish | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=seafood (see also Tag:shop=fish). | 45 | Proposed features/seafood shop
|
2010-06-06 | shop=fishmonger | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=seafood | 45 | Proposed features/seafood shop
|
2015-12-20 | shop=furnace | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=fireplace | 52 | This tag is confusing. A furnace is a big oven used for melting metals; some people also applied this tag for shops selling cooking stoves.
|
2016-01-02 | shop=gallery | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=art | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2014-01-27 | shop=gambling | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=gambling (see also Tag:shop=gambling). | 44 | Proposed features/Gambling
|
2017-04-06 | shop=glass | overpass-turbo / tag-history | craft=glaziery | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2017-04-07 | shop=moneylender | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=money_lender | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2012-02-11 | shop=organic | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=* + organic=* |
34 | Taken from Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated". See also Talk:Tag:shop=organic.
|
2015-12-08 | shop=perfume | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=perfumery | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2015-06-07 | shop=real_estate | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=estate_agent | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2020-04-23 | shop=vehicles | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Specific values of shop=* such as shop=car, shop=bicycle, shop=boat etc. instead | 31 | No specific reason stated, should be replaced with an actual reason. Actual reason may be described at tag page, this entry also may be an invalidly listed one.
|
2020-06-10 | natural=riverbed | overpass-turbo / tag-history | natural=water + water=river + intermittent=yes (if often water) or natural=shingle/sand... (if almost never water) instead |
90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2016-01-02 | shop=window | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=windows | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2013-12-23 | sport=diving | overpass-turbo / tag-history | sport=scuba_diving or sport=cliff_diving |
90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2010-08-25 | sport=gaelic_football | overpass-turbo / tag-history | sport=gaelic_games + specific tag of gaelic game |
31 | No specific reason stated, should be replaced with an actual reason. Actual reason may be described at tag page, this entry also may be an invalidly listed one.
|
2016-09-13 | sport=paragliding | overpass-turbo / tag-history | sport=free_flying |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2014-05-28 | tourism=bed_and_breakfast | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tourism=guest_house + guest_house=bed_and_breakfast |
84 | Redundant tag.
|
2008-03-19 | waterway=mooring | overpass-turbo / tag-history | mooring=* | 10 | More flexibility; allows us to keep original value of waterway=
|
2016-01-02 | waterway=wadi | overpass-turbo / tag-history | waterway=stream or waterway=river + intermittent=yes or/and natural=valley |
53 | In Arabic wadi means valley, but this conflicts with explanations in Wikipedia and probably with interpretations in various parts of the world. For initial discussion that ended with wadi deprecation see https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/2015-January/thread.html#20946. Beware that this kind of edit requires local knowledge: it is impossible to do it correctly with mass replace without local knowledge.
|
2014-06-06 | wood=deciduous | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leaf_cycle=deciduous | 22 | The values wood=coniferous and wood=deciduous are ambiguous. It was approved to use leaf_type=* instead.
|
2014-06-06 | wood=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leaf_type=* or leaf_cycle=* |
22 | The values wood=coniferous and wood=deciduous are ambiguous. It was approved to use leaf_type=* instead.
|
2018-10-27 | man_made=MDF | overpass-turbo / tag-history | telecom=exchange | 35 | Proposed features/Telecom local loop (archive)
|
2018-10-27 | man_made=telephone_exchange | overpass-turbo / tag-history | telecom=exchange | 35 | Proposed features/Telecom local loop (archive)
|
2018-10-27 | telecom=central_office | overpass-turbo / tag-history | telecom=exchange | 35 | Proposed features/Telecom local loop (archive)
|
2018-10-27 | telecom=outdoor_dslam | overpass-turbo / tag-history | telecom=service_device | 35 | Proposed features/Telecom local loop (archive)
|
2018-10-27 | telecom=street_cabinet | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=street_cabinet + utility=telecom | 35 | Proposed features/Telecom local loop (archive)
|
2019-03-26 | shop=underwear | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=clothes + clothes=underwear | 20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2019-07-31 | access=public | overpass-turbo / tag-history | access=yes | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2019-10-27 | power=marker | overpass-turbo / tag-history | marker=* + utility=power | 57 | Deprecated by the Proposed features/Utility markers proposal.
|
2019-10-27 | power=cable_distribution_cabinet | overpass-turbo / tag-history | man_made=street_cabinet + utility=power | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2019-10-27 | pipeline=marker | overpass-turbo / tag-history | marker=* + subject=pipeline | 57 | Deprecated by the Proposed features/Utility markers proposal.
|
2020-7-14 | role=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Use relations. for eg type=multipolygon for role=outer/inner, type=restriction for roles=from/to, type=waterway for role=main_stream | 62 |
|
2020-11-12 | wetland=saltern | overpass-turbo / tag-history | landuse=salt_pond | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2020-12-5 | protect_class=23 | overpass-turbo / tag-history | boundary=special_economic_zone | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=air_traffic | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=low_flying_aircraft | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=bend | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=curve | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=bicycle | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=cyclists | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=bicycles | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=cyclists | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=cattle | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=animal_crossing + hazard:animal=cow | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=deer | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=animal_crossing + hazard:animal=moose | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=reindeer | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=animal_crossing + hazard:animal=reindeer | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=wild_animal | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=animal_crossing + hazard:animal=wild_animal | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=wild_animals | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=animal_crossing + hazard:animal=wild_animal | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=farm_animals | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=animal_crossing + hazard:animal=livestock | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=crosswinds | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=side_winds | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=dangerous_turn | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=turn | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=pedestrian | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=pedestrians | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=playing_children | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=children | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=rockfall | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=falling_rocks | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=rock_slide | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=landslide | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | hazard=slippery_road | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=slippery | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2020-12-27 | protect_class=16 | overpass-turbo / tag-history | hazard=* | 63 | Proposed features/hazard
|
2017-04-12 | highway=razed | overpass-turbo / tag-history | razed:=* prefix, or more specifically razed:highway=* (or other lifecycle prefix) | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2018 (maybe 2013) | building=building | overpass-turbo / tag-history | building=yes | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-01-17 | protect_class=25 | overpass-turbo / tag-history | landuse=military + military=* | 87 |
|
2021-02 | amenity=swimming_pool | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leisure=swimming_pool | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | shop=lingerie | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=clothes + clothes=underwear | 20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2021-02 | amenity=gym | overpass-turbo / tag-history | leisure=sports_centre | 7 | better fits into toplevel tags
|
2021-02 | amenity=office | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=* | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | amenity=hospice | overpass-turbo / tag-history | healthcare=hospice | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | clothes=lingerie | overpass-turbo / tag-history | clothes=underwear | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | clothes=bridal | overpass-turbo / tag-history | clothes=wedding | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | amenity=public_building | overpass-turbo / tag-history | various | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-02 | tomb=cenotaph | overpass-turbo / tag-history | historic=memorial | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-02 | shop=photography | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=photo | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2022-12-27 | site_type=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | archaeological_site=* | 31 | No specific reason stated, should be replaced with an actual reason. Actual reason may be described at tag page, this entry also may be an invalidly listed one.
|
2023-01-13 | surface=trail | overpass-turbo / tag-history | surface=unpaved | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | amenity=life_ring | overpass-turbo / tag-history | emergency=life_ring | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | amenity=administration | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=government or such | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | access=restricted | overpass-turbo / tag-history | access=private or (depending on situation and other present tags) - access=forestry, access=agricultural | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2023-01-12 | building:age=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | start_date=* | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-03 | amenity=house | overpass-turbo / tag-history | building=house | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-03 | amenity=healthcare | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Healthcare | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-03 | amenity=health_centre | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Healthcare | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-02 | office=tax | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=government + government=tax or office=tax_advisor | 55 | Proposed features/Government offices
|
2021-02 | amenity=register_office | overpass-turbo / tag-history | office=government + government=register_office | 55 | Proposed features/Government offices
|
2021-02 | sport=hockey | overpass-turbo / tag-history | sport=ice_hockey or sport=field_hockey | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-02 | sport=football | overpass-turbo / tag-history | sport=soccer or sport=rugby or sport=australian_football or sport=american_football or sport=canadian_football and possible other sport=* (various values). See Football | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-02 | sport=shooting_range | overpass-turbo / tag-history | sport=shooting + "physical" tag | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2021-02 | amenity=club | overpass-turbo / tag-history | club=* | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-05-19 | post_office:type=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | post_office=* | 95 | Proposed features/shop as post-partner
|
2021-05-21 | landuse=school | overpass-turbo / tag-history | landuse=education | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2021-09 | residential=condominium | overpass-turbo / tag-history | residential=apartments | 56 | The difference between a condominium and an apartment is purely legal, difficult to verify, and unimportant to OSM.
|
2022-01-03 | vending=parcel_mail_in | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=parcel_locker with parcel_mail_in=yes | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2022-01-03 | vending=parcel_pickup | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=parcel_locker | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2022-01-04 | no_overtaking=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | overtaking=* | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2022-01-02 | embassy=embassy | overpass-turbo / tag-history | embassy=yes | 97 | The embassy=embassy tag has been deprecated by a voteː Proposed features/deprecate embassy=embassy.
|
2022-02-27 | boundary=forestry_compartment | overpass-turbo / tag-history | boundary=forest_compartment | 98 | The boundary=forestry_compartment tag has been deprecated by a voteː Proposed features/boundary=forest(_compartment) relations (v3).
|
2020-01-24 | building=collapsed | overpass-turbo / tag-history | demolished:building=* or building=ruins or delete the object | 99 | This is a misleading use of building=* & it conflates different types of (collapsed) buildings.
|
2020-01-15 | building=abandoned | overpass-turbo / tag-history | building=* + abandoned=yes | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2020-01-15 | building=disused | overpass-turbo / tag-history | building=* + disused=yes | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2022-09-28 | door=loadingdock | overpass-turbo / tag-history | amenity=loading_dock | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2022-11-27 | manufacturer:type=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | model=* | 59 | Proposed features/Manufacturer and Model#Rationale_of_the_proposal
|
2022-11-27 | vehicle:wikidata=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | model:wikidata=* | 59 | Proposed features/Manufacturer and Model#Rationale_of_the_proposal
|
2022-11-27 | vehicle:wikipedia=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | model:wikipedia=* | 59 | Proposed features/Manufacturer and Model#Rationale_of_the_proposal
|
2022-12-08 | parking:lane:left=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | parking:left=* | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2022-12-08 | parking:lane:right=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | parking:right=* | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2022-12-08 | parking:lane:both=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | parking:both=* | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2022-12-08 | parking:condition:left=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Street_parking#Legal_properties | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2022-12-08 | parking:condition:right=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Street_parking#Legal_properties | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2022-12-08 | parking:condition:both=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | Street_parking#Legal_properties | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2022-12-08 | parking:orientation=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | orientation=* | 65 | Replaced by new street parking schema, that is intended to be easier and more logical to apply, follows established OSM conventions more closely and harmonises tagging of parking spaces mapped on the centerline as an attribute of a street with parking spaces mapped as a separate feature.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=broadband | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=telecom | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=cable_tv | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=television | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=communications | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=telecom | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=gas | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=gas | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=power | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=power | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=street_lighting | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=street_lighting | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=telecom | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=telecom | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=water | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=water or utility=sewerage | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-01-27 | street_cabinet=water_management | overpass-turbo / tag-history | utility=water or utility=sewerage | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-03-28 | surface=granite | overpass-turbo / tag-history | material=granite or paving_stones:material=granite | 60 | As discussed on https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/2023-March/088110.html and https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/type-of-stone-in-surface-surface-granite-and-similar/9424
|
2023-03-28 | surface=marble | overpass-turbo / tag-history | material=marble or paving_stones:material=marble | 60 | As discussed on https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/2023-March/088110.html and https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/type-of-stone-in-surface-surface-granite-and-similar/9424
|
2023-04-20 | tower:type=lattice | overpass-turbo / tag-history | tower:construction=lattice due to usage. Tag has same meaning and is much more used. See tag history comparison. | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-05-01 | 3d_printing=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | 66 | this key has no clear meaning, and isn’t relevant to the suggested combinations.
| |
2023-05-16 | highway=trail | overpass-turbo / tag-history | highway=path | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-05-23 | shop=winery | overpass-turbo / tag-history | shop=wine or craft=winery | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2023-07-04 | maxspeed:seasonal:winter=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | maxspeed:conditional=*, winter as condition
|
20 | This is more expressive and more flexible.
|
2015-03-17 | denotation=cluster | overpass-turbo / tag-history | natural=tree_group or mapping all natural=tree | 84 | Redundant tag.
|
2023-11-05 | bridge=simple_brunnel | overpass-turbo / tag-history | bridge=yes | 90 | Poor or ambiguous semantics.
|
2023-12-15 | continuous_sidewalk=* | overpass-turbo / tag-history | crossing:continuous=yes | 61 | Proposal:Continuous crossings
|
2023-12-15 | crossing=pavement | overpass-turbo / tag-history | crossing:continuous=yes | 61 | Proposal:Continuous crossings
|
2024-04-19 | railway=facility | overpass-turbo / tag-history | railway=station | 67 | 1. Using this relation was time-consuming. 2. Mixing railway=facility with public_transport=stop_area resulted in complex and confusing tagging like type=public_transport + public_transport=stop_area + railway=facility for passenger stations and railway=facility without any type=* for non-passenger stations. 3. It resulted in mixing tags like public_transport=stop_position and railway=subway_entrance with features such as landuse=* from a railway operations perspective. 4. This relation duplicated a lot of tags of railway=station. 5. This relation mapped one real world feature as two features in OSM, which is not a good practice. Related discussion
|
2024-06-22 | cycleway=opposite | overpass-turbo / tag-history | oneway:bicycle=no + cycleway=no | 68 | Replaced by the more recent and more logical oneway:bicycle=* tagging; mixed infrastructure and access/direction information; logical problems if used with cycleway side suffixes; exclusion of other transport modes and other associated problems (see deprecation proposal for details).
|
2024-06-22 | cycleway=opposite_lane | overpass-turbo / tag-history | oneway:bicycle=no + cycleway=lane | 68 | Replaced by the more recent and more logical oneway:bicycle=* tagging; mixed infrastructure and access/direction information; logical problems if used with cycleway side suffixes; exclusion of other transport modes and other associated problems (see deprecation proposal for details).
|
2024-06-22 | cycleway=opposite_share_busway | overpass-turbo / tag-history | oneway:bicycle=no + cycleway=share_busway | 68 | Replaced by the more recent and more logical oneway:bicycle=* tagging; mixed infrastructure and access/direction information; logical problems if used with cycleway side suffixes; exclusion of other transport modes and other associated problems (see deprecation proposal for details).
|
2024-06-22 | cycleway=opposite_track | overpass-turbo / tag-history | oneway:bicycle=no + cycleway=track | 68 | Replaced by the more recent and more logical oneway:bicycle=* tagging; mixed infrastructure and access/direction information; logical problems if used with cycleway side suffixes; exclusion of other transport modes and other associated problems (see deprecation proposal for details). |
这个模板可以在Template:Deprecated_features查看和编辑
重大的成功弃用
“重要”意味着已弃用的标签曾被广泛使用,至少使用超过10000次。
“成功”意味着现在已经支持和接受新标签,而旧标签则大部分被删除。
- old style multipolygons - 这是一个有趣的案例,因为它不是关于标签,而是关于定义哪些标签适用于多边形的方法;
- place_name=* - 在2012-11-08时它被使用了超过3.5万次(http://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/place_name/)
- landuse=farm http://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/landuse/farm
- amenity=embassy - https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/amenity=embassy#chronology
- access=public - https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/access=public#chronology
- amenity=emergency_phone - http://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/amenity/emergency_phone&***/emergency/phone
- wood=* 到 leaf_type=* / leaf_cycle=* https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/wood#chronology
- highway=ford 到 ford=yes https://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/highway/ford
- 旧式维基百科标签被淘汰或停止增长 - https://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/wikipedia:de/&***/wikipedia:pl/&***/wikipedia:ru/* **/wikipedia:en/
- camp_pitch
- waterway=wadi - https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/waterway=wadi#chronology(不确定它是否有资格成功)
- power=sub_station - http://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/power/sub_station&***/power/substation(不确定是否成功)
- amenity=sauna 到 leisure=sauna https://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/amenity/sauna
- amenity=register_office 到 office=government + government=register_office https://taghistory.raifer.tech/#***/amenity/register_office&** */government/register_office
参见
- OSM-Editor不推荐使用的键和值/验证源列表
- iD-Editor不推荐使用的键和值/验证源列表
- 可丢弃标签
- Any tags you like
- Category:Key descriptions with status "deprecated" 和 Category:Tag descriptions with status "deprecated" - 许多未在上表中列出的标签
- 链接到"模板:已弃用"
- 链接到"模板:可能的同义词"
外部链接
- ↑ https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/100093213
- ↑ https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/104007471
- ↑ https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/105550460
- ↑ https://discord.com/channels/413070382636072960/782593988611014676/849697804292849725
- ↑ https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/105550460
- ↑ https://discord.com/channels/413070382636072960/782593988611014676/849697804292849725